3 ms·
I'm not American and to me, this kind of response, that I've seen a lot over the last month, is almost like a sort of turnkey censorship by the means of uncriti
by Barrin92 7y ago
I'm not American and to me, this kind of response, that I've seen a lot over the last month, is almost like a sort of turnkey censorship by the means of uncritical faith into the first amendment and myth.
The entire piece mostly consists of personal attacks. On elites who are allegedly all corrupt and untrustworthy. On journalists who don't really know anything, and it conjures up an image of all elites only holding the positions they hold because they think of everyone else as if they were unwashed masses.
It's hard to have a serious discussion when that's the premise that the argument is built on. There is no serious discussion on the dangers of false information, what merit there may be to delegating decision making to experts in particular in a crisis like this (I for once have more trust in Fauci than Trump to be honest, and I think many people would agree).
It's almost comical in a way that a piece that asks for more free speech so vehemently attacks people who exercise their free speech to question something that really matters, whether the foundations that the United States are built on are correct. We can and should have free speech about absolutely everything, except of course the merits of free speech and the American constitution, which is timeless, self-evident, and made by god.
- runawaybottle 7y agoWhy do you reject the premise? In the last twenty years, a motivated political establishment executed a fraudulent war, with most of the media either being complicit or negligent. Within the same era, you had a financial establishment that concocted economic fraud that was akin to a financial terrorist attack that literally collapsed the economy. Again, the media/press was mostly complicit or negligent as it happened, and the political establishment was mostly unwilling to administer criminal justice in the aftermath. So, that’s roughly two bullshit wars, and economic collapse due to deliberate fraud on a massive scale, all wrapped up in a package of negligent media coverage, and zero justice. These institutions don’t deserve respect at the moment. It will take a long time to reestablish integrity on their part. I understand if you find this general attitude snobbish, distasteful, and pretentious, which is fine, you may be more polite than the rest of us. But the premise is not inaccurate.
- AndrewBissell 7y agoI have never seen a "just trust the experts/institutions" type respond when I point all this out to them, but you've worded it better than I ever have. What I find especially funny is the political class's persecution complex on this point. For all intents and purposes, the "experts" and their enablers in media and government are still calling a good 98% of the shots, but just losing that last 2% has sent them into fits of finger-pointing rage.
- dlivingston 7y ago> There is no serious discussion on the dangers of false information... And what person, in all of the USA, would you nominate to be the arbiter of truth? Who decides, then, what is false information and what is true? “Leave it to the experts”, you might say, “What is false is what Fauci et al says is false.” And you may be right, but recall that the US still has a military presence in the Middle East due to the “expert opinions” of our intelligence agencies that Hussein had WMDs.
- throwaway122378 7y agoTo take the counter point, it’s almost unacceptable to be a conservative in today’s world when those in academia, journalism, and politics label anyone with a ‘right of center’ stance as a nazi. Most colleges have become eco chambers of today’s youth too scared to entertain or even hear a viewpoint that differs from theirs. Opening the door to major platforms (billion plus DAU) determining when media Is spreading false information will do more harm than good.
- snowwrestler 7y agoIt's written by Matt Taibi, who is of a genre of journalist that succeeds more by tapping into and channeling public outrage than by straight reporting. During the 2008 financial crisis in the U.S., he channeled left-leaning outrage against banks and financial institutions a la Occupy Wall Street. More recently he's tapping into right-leaning outrage against the media, experts, and Trump opponents a la the "alt-right". See for example in this piece: > In the Trump years the sector of society we used to describe as liberal America became a giant finger-wagging machine. The news media, academia, the Democratic Party, show-business celebrities and masses of blue-checked Twitter virtuosos became a kind of umbrella agreement society, united by loathing of Trump and fury toward anyone who dissented with their preoccupations. This is basically a 180 degree turn from a-decade-ago Matt Taibi, who worked in the show business news media (Rolling Stone) and got famous for aggressively wagging his finger at people.
- axguscbklp 7y agoYou have a point but to be fair, maybe he genuinely changed his views as he saw the "sector of society we used to describe as liberal America" develop, over the last few years, a larger and larger subset that can fairly be described as a hysterical cult. This last decade has, it seems to me, seen quite a rise in hysterical cultism on both major sides of the American political spectrum.