7 ms·
My non lawyer understanding is that Attorneys General effectively have an infinitely long list of crime to go after. The volume of outcry is an incredibly effec
by Waterluvian 7y ago
My non lawyer understanding is that Attorneys General effectively have an infinitely long list of crime to go after. The volume of outcry is an incredibly effective way to get your cause pushed up that list.
- adrr 7y agoI hope this doesn't stop the AG from completing their investigation of ICANN which is a non-profit based in California. They should still subpoena all the communications at ICANN related to the proposed ownership transfer of .org that is outlined in the original letter to ICANN. https://www.icann.org/en/system/files/correspondence/ca-ago-to-icann-board-23jan20-en.pdf https://www.icann.org/en/system/files/correspondence/ca-ago-...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- syshum 7y agoI am sure that ICANN is hoping the matter is just dropped now.
- rndgermandude 7y agoI am sure the PIR/ISOC and Ethos Capital are hoping this even more
- rvnx 7y agoA couple of dozens of millions of dollars in lobbying to their favorite parties may help them to think the right way
- sbarre 7y agoYeah, unfortunately, the truth is probably that they are regrouping and planning a different and more defensible path to the same outcome, and will just try this again in a few years.
- ohashi 7y agoICANN did leave door open if they could convert PIR to a for profit in PA. I hope PA AG has something to say about this.
- LurkersWillLurk 7y agoCan you describe this door? The Pennsylvania AG is pretty good, although probably not as technically inclined.
- ohashi 7y agoIf you read the end of the full statement (https://www.icann.org/resources/board-material/resolutions-2020-04-30-en https://www.icann.org/resources/board-material/resolutions-2...) "If PIR is able to provide additional information that resolves the concerns raised by the Board, PIR remains able to re-submit or initiate a new Change of Control Request." That's how they concluded, leaving the door open if they can manage to get past this hurdle.
- seganddr 7y agoWhat can be done to initiate a change in their leadership?
- crazypython 7y agoThen we should ask, can we fund them more? Moreover, if we don't live in California, can we lobby our states to help pay for the Cali AG?
- jerf 7y agoHaving an "effectively infinite" list of crime isn't the result of a lack of funding, but the size of the set of things that technically constitute "crimes". Quadrupling their funding would still leave them with an effectively infinite amount of crime they could deal with. (This being another place where "unbounded" is probably a better word than "infinite"... there isn't literally an infinite amount of crime, but it is the case that pretty much no matter what they do, when they reach for another crime to prosecute, there will always be one there.) One of the subtle checks & balances in our system is that we don't even want prosecution to literally go after every crime... we want them to choose the things that are actually important. There's a lot of things labeled "crimes" today where the cost of enforcement greatly exceeds any value to society of that enforcement. (Expanding on that, one of the biggest problems, if not the biggest problem, with automated crime enforcement is that it removes this check & balance that almost nobody has even realized exists yet.)
- whatshisface 7y agoRather than being a balance, doesn't this fact leave a giant hole open for biases and the influence of personal connections?
- jerf 7y agoYes, it does that too. It's an "and". That said, I will still take "biased human picking what to prosecute" over "a prosecution sufficiently funded to prosecute literally everything". I mean, sure, I'd prefer "real justice", but "biased human" is still constrained in their actions and has to produce enough results useful to society to be able to hide their corruption in, whereas totally perfect enforcement would be a nightmare.
- 7y ago