8 ms·
In this aspect and many others, Urbit is reminiscent of Scientology.
by pavlov 7y ago
In this aspect and many others, Urbit is reminiscent of Scientology.
- tptacek 7y agoYou are not the first to draw this analogy!
- seemslegit 7y agoNot just Scientology, it's Cults 101
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bitwize 7y agoOr the Gurdjieff movement, which (also like Urbit) is full of completely made up terms and concepts like "organ kundabuffer", "being-partkdolg-duty" and "the sacred Rascooarno", which the faithful just sort of accept and don't really explain except in their own terms, or with reference to other bits of Gurdjieff's impenetrable prose. When confronted, Gurdjieffites usually resort to the sort of tactics displayed upthread, if they're feeling charitable: "Have you considered that you are simply, in your somnambulent ignorance, criticizing that which you do not understand because your sleep prevents you from understanding? Come talk to me after you've spent 20 or 30 years in the Work and have something to criticize." In short, to criticize the system you must first embrace the system in its totality, only then will you understand it well enough to level legitimate criticism. If they're not feeling charitable, they might declare you an Eternal-Hasnamuss-Individual and tell you your destiny is to become food for the moon. But at least they won't sue you or send private investigators after you (I think), so that's nice.
- carapace 7y agoI think you've been hanging out with the wrong "Gurdjieffites". At least some of those terms are pretty easy to figure out. "organ kundabuffer" was a specific organ that excreted some kind of drug (in Gurdjieff's pre-history.) "being-partkdolg-duty" is the task and operation of remembering oneself. "the sacred Rascooarno" is death of the physical body. ...and so on.
- throwanem 7y agoHave you tried to look up definitions for some of them? I tried to figure out what a "hasnamuss" is, and about halfway through https://www.doremishock.com/beelzebub/hasnamussfieldguide.htm https://www.doremishock.com/beelzebub/hasnamussfieldguide.ht... found myself overcome with the urge to sneeze. The tick marks had gotten up my nose, as I'm sure you'll agree is a very present danger given their swarming multiplication throughout the text. But, having got past them, I found they'd done me a sort of mercy in distracting from the vast swamp of sheer nonsense into which I might otherwise have fallen. It appears from https://gnosticteachings.org/books-by-samael-aun-weor/the-elimination-of-satans-tail/288-the-kundabuffer-organ.html https://gnosticteachings.org/books-by-samael-aun-weor/the-el..., too, that: "It is necessary to know that the Kundabuffer Organ is the negative development of the fire." That's something I am certainly glad now to know! It makes the rest of it seem so much simpler. (Leaving aside sarcasm for a moment, "the negative development of the fire" seems like just the sort of thing a Quaker might describe as a perversion of the Inner Light, or a Catholic might regard as akin to what would become of humans absent the Holy Spirit indwelling. I'm sure someone conversant with the inner mysteries of Gurdjieff's particular flavor of syncretistic guff would consider both of these analogies to be shocking misapprehensions of the true nature of whatever it is supposed to be. But I'd be astonished to find such a person able to usefully explain what it is supposed to be.)
- carapace 7y ago> Have you tried to look up definitions for some of them? No. I've read Gurdjieff's "All and Everything" (as much of it as has been published) and thought about it deeply. Even so, I don't think I understand even half of it. The part I do understand makes me think that Gurdjieff was a genius, comparable only to Leonardo da Vinci, with the difference that, where Leonardo explored the external world, Gurdjieff explored the internal world. FWIW, as far as I can tell the "kundabuffer" was literally an organ that excreted some kind of drug. It deranged our thinking and perception, essentially making us high, so that we wouldn't notice that we were being used to somehow stabilize the orbit of the Moon after some disaster. Eventually the Moon's orbit was stabilized and the organ removed, but it was too late. The effects persisted. No one (of the alien/angels that were doing all this) noticed the problem until one person discovered that earthlings were destroying each other. (War is unknown other than on Earth. The rest of the Universe literally have no idea. Which is why no aliens land on the lawn: they're all totally terrified of us.) What's the big deal?
- ur-whale 7y ago> Come talk to me after you've spent 20 or 30 years in the Work and have something to criticize. Reminds me of Mochizuki's Inter-universal Teichmüller theory [1] Looks like the same psychological trickery works both on the bleating masses and the highly educated. [1] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/math-mystery-shinichi-mochizuki-and-the-impenetrable-proof/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/math-mystery-shin...
- StavrosK 7y agoI thought you were talking about a Vonnegut book for way too long.
- am_lu 7y agoI find Gurdjieff a bit too much to swallow on its own but this book give me a lot to think. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_Search_of_the_Miraculous https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_Search_of_the_Miraculous