5 ms·
We are trusting a few large companies to moderate acceptable speech on the internet. Is it a good idea to entrust such power to a semi-homogenous group of liber
by nicbou 7y ago
We are trusting a few large companies to moderate acceptable speech on the internet. Is it a good idea to entrust such power to a semi-homogenous group of liberal Americans in the Bay Area? Shouldn't the rest of the planet also have a say in this?
Suppose America goes to war with Examplistan. What does that mean for the Examplistanis? Will they get deplatformed as enemy propaganda? Will the internet become a propaganda machine for wherever those large companies are headquartered?
What if Google was anti-LGBT? Would we grant it the same moderation powers? Would we be ok with YouTube removing or demonetising videos featuring homosexual displays of affection?
I find it crazy that we grant those companies so much power simply because they happen to share some of our views.
- lurquer 7y agoWho is this “we” you repeatedly use in your post? Perhaps you mean “I”? You make good points... But, with all due respect, your use of that pronoun evidences a strange collectivist view of the world that may be part of the problem.
- cfmcdonald 7y ago> Suppose America goes to war with Examplistan. What does that mean for the Examplistanis? Will they get deplatformed as enemy propaganda? Will the internet become a propaganda machine for wherever those large companies are headquartered? Isn't this already the case? You can post videos on YouTube encouraging people to join the U.S. Marines, but not Al-Queda. I guess I don't find this very disturbing. Why should Google be required to host data for an enemy state? > What if Google was anti-LGBT? Would we grant it the same moderation powers? Would we be ok with YouTube removing or demonetising videos featuring homosexual displays of affection? YouTube's policies reflect mainstream social mores. Had YouTube existed 30 years ago, it almost certainly would have done this, and most people would have been fine with it. If YouTube did this today, it would quickly cease to be the dominant video hosting platform.
- paganel 7y ago> Why should Google be required to host data for an enemy state? It's MS, not Google, but personally I find things like these very wrong and disturbing [1]: > GitHub, the world’s largest host of source code, is preventing users in Iran, Syria, Crimea and potentially other sanctioned nations from accessing portions of the service, chief executive of the Microsoft-owned firm said. [1] https://techcrunch.com/2019/07/29/github-ban-sanctioned-countries/ https://techcrunch.com/2019/07/29/github-ban-sanctioned-coun...
- sneak 7y ago> Why should Google be required to host data for an enemy state? For the same reason the telephone company isn’t allowed to arbitrarily cancel your phone service based on who you choose to call with it. > YouTube's policies reflect mainstream social mores. This is precisely the problem. Before, the bar to be silenced was the law; now the bar to be silenced is arbitrary application of “mainstream social mores”. Surely you see the problem there? Have you never derived benefit from media or creative works that fall outside of “mainstream social mores”? Even if you haven’t, YouTube’s been deleting videos of war crimes in Syria, making it harder for investigators to track them down and document them. How’s that for “mainstream social mores”?
- runawaybottle 7y agoAre they deleting them due to graphic explicitness?
- sneak 7y agoDoes it matter? Wouldn’t you want evidence of war crimes to be both graphic and explicit, therefore making it better documentation of a crime and more likely to assist in the prosecution of the criminal(s)?
- NotSammyHagar 7y agoIt does matter why they ban things. They make mistakes too, sometimes put things back. It always matters.
- sneak 7y agoI disagree. The danger is not YouTube or YouTube's policies, whatever they may be at any point in time. The danger is centralized models that permit invisible, sometimes-on, sometimes-off, point-and-click censorship. Those models fail when the military puts a machine gun in a sysadmin's face in wartime, regardless of how good or decent their censorship policies were in peacetime. It's the model that's bad, not YouTube's current policies.
- gerland 7y ago> YouTube's policies reflect mainstream social mores. The real problem is that YT also influences those social mores. It's a snowballing effect that no one is able to stop. New social trend >> YT starts to promote it >> Becomes social norm >> YT starts to enforce it >> New social trends are able to spawn only from the previous trend. You might want to keep up this situation as long as it fits your point of view, but you have to take into account that this process will warp this exact point of view in ways that you do not control. 20 years ago the left was synonymous with freedom of choice and individualism, now there are hardly any traces of those values left. Excuse the pun. If YT always bends to the "popular opinion", then it actually means that it has knee-jerk reactions to the most emotional outbursts. What influences the norm is in reality the base instinct, dopamine fueled, thoughtless reactivity without any plan or purpose. It does not matter if you will take left or right wing ideology. Platforms like YT are instrumental in making sure that in the end we will get the worst version of it. How the hell did the left end up in a poistion where they represent the worst mixture of Orwell and Huxley? I have no doubt that it would be near impossible to end at this place without corps capitalising on social moods.
- iaml 7y ago> Would we be ok with YouTube removing or demonetising videos featuring homosexual displays of affection? Well it kinda already happened[0] and everyone's ok with that so I guess you have your answer there. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship_by_Google#YouTube https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship_by_Google#YouTube
- jowsie 7y agoYouTube change their whole site to have Rainbows and #Pride all over it once a year while actively demonetising anyone who uses the words 'gay' or 'lesbian' in their videos. This has led to LGBT focused channels creating entire dictionary's of code words that are shared within the community. https://youtu.be/ll8zGaWhofU https://youtu.be/ll8zGaWhofU