3 ms·
Government is far worse than the private sector at long term planning. Mostly, governments optimize for things to look good on the next election day. With 4 ye
by BurningFrog 7y ago
Government is far worse than the private sector at long term planning.
Mostly, governments optimize for things to look good on the next election day. With 4 year terms, that's an average 2 years planning horizon.
- pbourke 7y ago> Government is far worse than the private sector at long term planning. How many public companies have needed bailouts after spending most of their profits on stock buybacks, again? > Mostly, governments optimize for things to look good on the next election day. With 4 year terms, that's an average 2 years planning horizon. As opposed to public companies and the quarterly earnings cycle?
- AbrahamParangi 7y agoBailouts are public failures, not private failures. Businesses are doing what they should in fighting tooth and nail to survive. The market is doing what it should in killing businesses too stupid or greedy to survive. It is the government doing the wrong thing by saving the incompetent. If the government bails out idiots, what's the point in being smart?
- Ygg2 7y agoBailouts are public. But that doesn't mean there aren't bailouts of private sector. If government doesn't bailout idiots like e.g. private banks, their entire economy can collapse. That means no pensions, no jobs, and destroyed economy.
- kwhitefoot 7y agoGovernments could bail out the victims instead, that is the pensioners, the employees.
- Ygg2 7y agoThat's true, however it's both easier and politicaly good move to bail out banks. Easier because you don't have to see who had which plan and how to bail out each person on it. Plus banks are both more powerful and easier to return the favor than the victims.
- domador 7y agoAre airlines idiots? Aren't they more like victims of extremely unfortunate circumstances? Do we want to lose commercial air travel for a few years? If airlines are worth helping out and saving, then maybe so are certain other businesses. While we're at it, let's work on toning down the greed part, which as it is was already destroying society even before this crisis.
- AbrahamParangi 7y agoWhat makes you think that allowing the holders of airline bonds and equity to take a bath will result in commercial air travel disappearing? Edit: I should be clear. Yes they're idiots. There is no reward without risk. Stock buybacks make businesses fragile. They're functionally equivalent to selling insurance. They provide predictable returns with high probability and absolute ruin with low probability. They've been playing Russian Roulette for years and it turned out a bullet was in the chamber this time.
- bhupy 7y ago> How many public companies have needed bailouts after spending most of their profits on stock buybacks, again? Setting aside for the moment the general agreement that bailouts are bad, and a policy failure rather than a market failure...maybe another question to ask is: what percentage of the GDP comprises public companies that needed bailouts after spending most of their profits on stock buybacks? One of the advantages of decentralized planning is that there is no single point of failure — some subset of corporations are always efficiently providing for consumers. Governments that are large and centralized enough are single points of failure, and it's really hard to correct that once such failures occur. > As opposed to public companies and the quarterly earnings cycle? But Value Investing is a big part of the market, and it's fundamentally a long-run investment strategy. Some of the most successful and impactful companies don't pay dividends, or operate on losses with the expectation of profits at some time in the distant future. Even the argument that Governments are good at doing big things without the expectation of profit seems to be under scrutiny. NASA's planned SLS moon mission is a bit of a disaster — way over budget and way behind schedule. Because the boosters aren't reusable, each launch is expected to cost $1B (with a B) dollars — EACH launch! Meanwhile SpaceX's target cost-per-launch is $50M. SLS is unlikely to fly until at least 2021[1]. Meanwhile, SpaceX is building a factory that will manufacture 1 Starship (capable of going to the Moon), every 72 hours[2]. I don't even need to go down the F-35 rabbit hole. [1] https://arstechnica.com/science/2019/07/nasas-large-sls-rocket-unlikely-to-fly-before-at-least-late-2021/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2019/07/nasas-large-sls-rock... [2] https://arstechnica.com/science/2020/03/inside-elon-musks-plan-to-build-one-starship-a-week-and-settle-mars/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2020/03/inside-elon-musks-pl...
- jlbnjmn 7y agoInstitutions are groups of people with rules. People not following rules will ruin any form of governance, public or private. The best way to improve any group of people is by being an example. Thank you for your exemplary insight.
- kian 7y agoOn the contrary, I'd say that public companies accurately forecasted that regardless of their shenanigans they'd be bailed out by the government, and acted accordingly in a long-term fashion. That's why, at some point, it will be critical to the future viability of our institutions and way of life to let companies fail when they make catastrophic mistakes, no matter how large they are. One strong slap from reality, and nobody there to back them up, will be a sufficient signal to engender long-term planning that doesn't rely on the public's largesse. Corporate corpses are the best fertilizer for the institutions we need to build going forward.
- mistermann 7y agoDemocratic governments. China seems to have a decent strategy going.
- nickff 7y agoAre you talking about the strategy of a country which enabled the global pandemic we are all currently suffering through? The one that first tried to ignore the problem, then tried to cover it up, and has subsequently been lying about it? Ignorance followed by suppression and deceit is definitely a course of action, though I don't agree that it's a great strategy.
- mistermann 7y agoYes, that's the China I'm talking about. I think you might be on a bit of a different tangent that the context of the comment I'm replying to though.
- BurningFrog 7y agoNon democratic systems fail in other ways, but it's true that they don't have the next election to worry about, and they can have a longer planning horizon. The planning usually benefits the ruling elite more than the people, but it's still a real point. The astonishing rise of China last 30 years has made me accept that it can actually work out occasionally!