3 ms·
I found a more substantial rebuttal to the film than "we need to deplatform this ASAP" https://www.filmsforaction.org/articles/skepticism-is-healthy-but-planet
by chomp 6y ago
I found a more substantial rebuttal to the film than "we need to deplatform this ASAP"
https://www.filmsforaction.org/articles/skepticism-is-healthy-but-planet-of-the-humans-is-toxic/ https://www.filmsforaction.org/articles/skepticism-is-health...
- NotAnAccountNO 6y agoVery informative thank you. From this rebuttal I see that the movie probably packages true information, some of it outdated, in a provocative way. The only fully scientific rebuttal is to run the experiment: run the whole economy without fossil fuels or nuclear, and see how much it looks like the middle-ages, how much it looks like utopia. My guess is 80/20 on the middle-ages side, but who know.
- throwaway_me_ 6y agoThe rebuttal is in the beginning stating that Germany's renewable electricity production is important and not it's total energy consumption, at the end they claim that we need to shift all of our energy consumption to renewable electricity. This is a fundamental contradiction.