4 ms·
Pollyanna thinking. We'll have what, 30M unemployed people? Who mostly can't be retrained to be engineers, even if we needed that many engineers which we don't
by JoeAltmaier 7y ago
Pollyanna thinking.
We'll have what, 30M unemployed people? Who mostly can't be retrained to be engineers, even if we needed that many engineers which we don't.
No, we're entering a post-scarcity economy. Never mind Marxism or Socialism or Capitalism - when Labor has nothing left of value to offer, where do they go? What leverage do they have?
"It'll be like that forever" flies in the face of history. When weaving machines came in 1760, the weavers didn't just get reeducated or reallocated - they starved and died, along with their families.
I always feel sad at the oft-repeated theme "We'll just get everybody working again!". In the 1950's, lots of philosophers and writers imagined a future of robots lifting the yoke of labor from our shoulders, freeing us for lives of leisure. Now that it's happening, all I hear is schemes to make people work again. The old Puritan ethic - if you're not working, your a waste of breath.
- throwanem 7y agoSeems pretty pollyannaish to think we're heading into post-scarcity anything, for anyone. Where is that idea even coming from? Or is "post-scarcity" just a nice way of saying "massive social stratification built on the exploitation of an effectively permanent underclass"?
- gridlockd 7y ago> Who mostly can't be retrained to be engineers, even if we needed that many engineers... I didn't say they will become engineers. A low-class worker will stay in low-class work, but there will still be demand for it. Even if the market doesn't demand it, the government is there as a buyer of last resort. Again, there's always something to do. There's always something to improve, to build or to repair. Where do you think work came from before capitalism? The argument for capitalism is that it's generally more efficient than government at allocating resources and creating wealth. If that fails, we can still fall back to something else. > Never mind Marxism or Socialism or Capitalism - when Labor has nothing left of value to offer, where do they go? What leverage do they have? They can riot. > When weaving machines came in 1760, the weavers didn't just get reeducated or reallocated - they starved and died, along with their families. If this was a historical fact and not a figment of your imagination, it would be repeated at every opportunity where "the dangers of automation" were discussed.