7 ms·
The old indicators don't necessarily work here. Unemployment is because of the lockdown. Some of them (many of them?) will return after lockdown.
by JoeAltmaier 7y ago
The old indicators don't necessarily work here. Unemployment is because of the lockdown. Some of them (many of them?) will return after lockdown.
- jameskilton 7y agoHopefully I'm wrong but I don't believe that they will. The lockdown isn't going to just disappear, it's going to be a drawn-out process figuring out how we're supposed to live with this virus. More places may be open but the demand will still be much lower than it has been. And that will have knock-on effects through everything else. I fear we are going to see a lot more people filing for unemployment for months to come.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoAll of which is true, but it's too early to distinguish permanent damage from temporary inconvenience. There will be elements of both, and at the moment it's impossible to tell them apart. We won't know the true picture until six months after the last significant outbreak. If we're lucky and there's no recurrence we'll have a clearer picture heading into winter. If we're not and there is, there will be more damage and we won't be able to see the final picture until late next year.
- vinceguidry 7y agoI feel like commerce will figure out a way to adapt. Restaurants will build social distancing into the experience. I work with NCR, the largest POS platform provider in the country. They didn't lay off a single person. Commerce isn't going away.
- gremlinsinc 7y agoSome retailers were already struggling, I heard as many as 50% of mall retailers could close by 2021, which could cause the malls themselves to close and kick out the remaining tenants if they go bankrupt. Sure there's tons of other retailers, I'm from Dayton, where NCR used to be, so am familiar w/ the company, just because they haven't laid off yet, doesn't mean a year from now things will be as rosy. I know for a fact in 2008 they laid off a lot, and iirc that's when they closed down the NCR/dayton facility. Didn't all happen at once, but it eventually did. The crisis then was markets and just normal business. This is a full shut down of society followed by a period of consumer confidence issues (assuming consumers even have cash to consume with), it's not just going to bounce back.
- freepor 7y agoThis virus is only two months old. Companies with cash reserves don’t have to lay-off immediately... they can wait a few months and figure out how many they need to lay-off.
- wonderwonder 7y agoI agree, demand will remain low. I have been lucky enough to keep my job to date and I have discovered the joy of saving. The amount of money I have been able to keep once I stopped going out to eat and buying useless things is amazing. I can't think that I am alone in this. Compound this with the uncertainty in the job market and I think many people are going to be focused on saving for quite a while.
- save_ferris 7y ago> They find a 30% collapse in vacancy postings, reflecting a massive decline in companies’ demand for workers. It’s not clear how many will be able to return after lockdown, but this piece argues that those who won’t be able to return to old jobs will struggle to find new ones given the decreased demand in labor. The situation I fear is that communities open back up but business activity remains low due to fear around viral contraction. If business is open but customers aren’t coming in, the workers who returned to those jobs might not have them for too long.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoAlso, those looking for a job will be shoulder-to-shoulder with 6M other people. That part won't be pretty.
- gridlockd 7y ago> The situation I fear is that communities open back up but business activity remains low due to fear around viral contraction. If that's true, labor demand will shift to delivery, fulfillment and online marketing. Perhaps the US is collectively going to "move inside", but if so, that's only because there never was a lot of interesting stuff outside to begin with. Look at Europe with its pretty cities or China with its metropolises, people are already back in the streets, they aren't so paranoid about the virus.
- pbourke 7y ago> people are already back in the streets, they aren't so paranoid about the virus. Photos of crowds are one thing - economic stats tell the real story. It’s too early to tell how people’s behavior has changed.
- save_ferris 7y ago> If that’s true, labor demand will shift to delivery, fulfillment and online marketing Delivery and fulfillment are not good paying jobs, and it can take years to development expert-level marketing skills to earn top dollar. Lots of people are going to struggle with this kind of transition. > Perhaps the US is collectively going to "move inside", but if so, that's only because there never was a lot of interesting stuff outside to begin with. This is completely subjective, based on personal preference, and a position that I completely disagree with. And Italy is still locked down for another week, at which point they’ll slowly begin reopening. Wuhan has reopened but we won’t know the full economic impact of their reopening for a while.
- mywittyname 7y agoI'm not this optimistic. I suspect lots of small businesses aren't coming back and larger ones are going to continue to run "lean" (read: overworking their employees) for as long as possible. After 2008, it took like four years for hiring to pick back up.
- newacct583 7y agoTo be fair, the 08 recovery was deliberately hamstrung by the lack of government stimulus. Congress approved basically nothing after the first round of QE. Hopefully we won't repeat the mistake this time.
- pbourke 7y agoI agree that the fiscal stimulus, under the control of Congress, was much less that it should have been. However QE is monetary stimulus under the Fed’s control and as I recall there were several rounds of it, in addition to other programs. Edit: reading your comment again, and I think you mean that Congress didn’t do any further fiscal stimulus after the Fed did QE1, which seems right to me. Leaving my comment up for clarity.
- jcomis 7y agoIt was shocking how fast some corporate players went "lean". Almost as if they were waiting for a viable excuse to do so without blowback rather than out of actual necessity. They know they have the upper hand. People are deathly afraid of being unemployed, something that was just starting to fade away after 2008.
- toasterlovin 7y agoOn the other hand, if your cash flow generation stops because sales stop, employees are often the largest remaining expense. And you can't delay paying employees, unlike vendors. So you have to be decisive, or else you can go from having a healthy company to financial insolvency in the span of a few weeks.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoTo me this feels a little like the situation around 2000 and 2001. A lot of fundamentals were out of whack but things kept moving. Then 9/11 happened which shouldn’t have derailed the economy by itself but it triggered the unraveling. So the lockdown may just be the trigger that will pop the bubble that has been building since 2008. My prediction is that measures will be taken to reinflate the bubble which will then go on for another ten years so we will probably have an even bigger collapse around 2028-2030. And every time more wealth will get moved to the top x percent.
- gremlinsinc 7y agoI think they'll try, but I honestly think we've got a perfect storm coming. Now's the best time ever for automation to take off. There's also going to be more big businesses eating little businesses and consolidation. Globalization's biggest leaders will come out ahead, and thrive as always - but a LOT less workers are going to be needed in general from here on out thanks to ML/AI/Etc... It's first step towards post-scarcity, except for the millions who will be hurt if govt's don't create repurposing plans to give people a purpose for existing and enough $ to eat and live. Also, I personally won't step foot in a sit-down restaurant or movie theater for at least 2-3 years, or until there's a viable vaccine. I'm sure I'm not the only person boycotting crowds. Real estate analysts estimate that 50%+ of mall retailers will close their door by q4 2021. that's a shit ton of jobs gone forever. I was starting to get skeptical of the claim that 40% of jobs would be gone by 2030, but 2020 definitely is showing it's highly possible. What do we do w/ 40% permanent unemployment?
- gridlockd 7y ago> What do we do w/ 40% permanent unemployment? This assumes that somehow people cannot be re-trained to do other things, if those jobs really all disappear, which they probably wont. There's always more work to do, things to improve, people to help. It will be like that forever. The question is, who allocates labor? Perhaps the kind of market system we have has run its course, perhaps this time it's over. I predict that the market will recover, just like it always has, but feel free to disagree.
- empath75 7y agoAre we going to go back in time and manufacture all the goods and services we didn't make this year?
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoNo. But that's another point: there should be a burst of demand initially. Delayed service appointments; postponed repairs and replacements. It seems temporary, and may only cause a roller-coaster effect but we'll see.
- fierarul 7y agoThe initial burst will exist but only for essential items I think. No need to get a new car if the old one will do.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoSure but then repairs/maintenance will have a bubble. Rent or buy, folks will be able to get out and do transactions that've been put off. Recently I took all our vehicles for service. Got an appointment the same day. They were essentially idle.
- fierarul 7y agoI agree about repairs/maintenance. Dentists too.
- empath75 7y agoIt's not just a demand shortage, there's a supply shortage. Let's assume demand shoots back up. We still will have spent 3-6 months or more not making stuff. What is everyone going to buy?
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoSounds like a recipe for prices spiking. It's going to be a rough ride.
- jellicle 7y agoMost of your local small businesses have already closed permanently. We haven't even gotten to the next contractionary wave where state and local governments lay off millions of people. It's conceivable to imagine a world where government response prevented almost all of this pain but that's not the world we live in.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoCitation? Because its not true in my town. Landlords have forgiven rent; businesses have put employees on unemployment. But the plan is, to restart afterward. Nobody has abandoned their business or fled.
- Marsymars 7y agoI don't know about most, but I'm seeing local gyms, fitness studios, restaurants, retailers, etc. announcing permanent closure on pretty much a daily basis. Many landlords are refusing to forgive or decrease rent, and pretty much any path forward involves a small business taking on additional debt while having zero revenue for an indefinite period of time.
- jandrewrogers 7y agoThe situation in Seattle does not support this view, and I know many small business owners here. Sure, some businesses are exactly as you describe but that is very far from all businesses. Many businesses have permanently closed their doors, and just as importantly, all of their capital was destroyed in the process so they no longer have the means to start a new business. The financial structure of many types of business intrinsically cannot absorb a couple of months of shutdown, it literally makes that investment a total loss to the owner. Many of these small business owners have almost all of their net worth in these businesses, it isn't like they are independently wealthy. You are seriously underestimating the scale of the destruction of capital that has occurred in the small business community. People without capital cannot afford to open a new small business. Most of them are not FAANG engineers, they don't have hundreds of thousands of dollars lying around to try again.
- 7y ago
- m3kw9 7y agoDepends if the business is still there.
- karatestomp 7y agoDemand will be way down after as people recover from lost income. Others will take that whole "have [3/4/6] months of expenses in an emergency fund" thing seriously and reduce spending for as much as a year. Restaurants and such are likely to have reduced capacity. Lower demand, lower need for workers. I think unemployment will remain high (though probably not as bad as it is now) for a while. [EDIT] and of course higher unemployment will suppress wages, further reducing demand. Yaaaaay.
- Aloha 7y agoI suspect we're going to come out of this with about 12% unemployment, I'm suspecting like 8% of jobs are just going to evaporate as part of this.