3 ms·
Some people are saying that. Others are asking if the response could have been more focused and surgical. For example, in New Jersey (USA), where I live, 40% o
by chiefalchemist 7y ago
Some people are saying that. Others are asking if the response could have been more focused and surgical.
For example, in New Jersey (USA), where I live, 40% of deaths are of people at extended care facilities (i.e., retirement homes). We locked down everything and everybody (i.e., no focus) and those deaths still happened; because we failed to "harden" the sites (and people) most in danger. If this is a war, that's not how you win a war. Furthermore, "flare ups" at such facilities continue to happen. That is, where is the lockdown win?
Now imagine taking 40% of the deaths off the table. Did the lockdown work? Probably. Just the same, the dynamic of the conversation changes when you look at how C19 hits - or doesn't - the general healthy population.
Finally, how many lives will be lost to the economic fall out? If the lockdown did save lives then the "side effects" of the lockdown must be considered as well.
Taking the data in aggregate and declaring lockdown a win is an oversimplification.
- JeremyNT 7y agoIt certainly should have been more focused and surgical. There are so many ways it could have been handled better. But, simply nobody made preparations for any of them in advance. By the time NYC locked down, the virus had likely already been spreading unimpeded for weeks. The only possible short term solution was the population-wide lockdown, which "fixed" the issue in that it stopped the immediate disaster from becoming even worse. In nursing homes already infected, it was simply too late at that time. The fact that the lockdown was required is evidence of a colossal failure on the part of our society. Our infrastructure should have been able to target this more precisely and we (the US) specifically squandered a huge advantage we had in that we had time to clearly see the progress of the virus overseas before it arrived, but did nothing useful with that time. Even after all of this, few steps have been made to make the transition from "shut it all down" to a strategy that involves broad testing and targeted protection of vulnerable populations. It seems people are resigned to keeping the daily death rate steady and eventually just letting all vulnerable members of the population contract the virus and die.
- chiefalchemist 7y agoBut NYC (and surrounding areas, including North NJ, Long Island, et al) is not the whole country. It's not every city. In fact, it's relatively fringe. Lessons to be learned? You bet. Of course. But we took a semi-effective - again, despite the lockdown nursing homes continue to be a significant contributor to deaths - and applied it _everywhere_. Certainly, it's now reasonable to look at other options. But that's not happening. It as if the "cure" isn't going to lead to deaths as well. That's naive.
- diehunde 7y agoYeah that's called Hindsight bias
- chiefalchemist 7y agoNot at all. We knew from Italy that pre-existing conditions were a significant co-conspirator. We knew the elderly were more susceptible. Yet, the extended care facilities _to this day_ remain a major contributor to the death toll. Even if you call it hindsight bias, what do you call the current refusal to step back and ask what we've learned so far? To stay the course, with a lack of data to support it? What do we call that?