3 ms·
My other favorite example is y2k. New Years 2000 came and went and the world didn’t end. Was y2k overblown hysteria, or did we take it seriously and do the wor
by ModernMech 7y ago
My other favorite example is y2k. New Years 2000 came and went and the world didn’t end. Was y2k overblown hysteria, or did we take it seriously and do the work necessary to prevent catastrophic system failure? Probably a little hysteria involved, sure, but I don’t think anyone here would argue we should have just let systems go unpatched and hoped for the best.
- __s 7y agoAn issue is when there's an issue which people with information are trying to work around, word gets out & the risk becomes exaggerated to societal collapse. Nevermind that a plague could come & kill half the population & society wouldn't collapse. So when people get the idea that we're trying to stop society from collapsing, they expect we'll still see society almost collapse. But instead we're averting a much lower risk (which is still very costly) & so the final price we pay is nowhere near "if we hadn't done X, society would've collapsed" Basically we need to moderate both opinions which effectively work together: the "there's no problem to begin with" group feels validated by the "the world is ending" group being way off the mark This happens with global warming too. Some people think everything's going to fall apart within the next 10 years. They're wrong. So others claim there isn't a problem, because they were wrong
- mistermann 7y ago> Basically we need to moderate both opinions which effectively work together: the "there's no problem to begin with" group feels validated by the "the world is ending" group being way off the mark. I agree. Do you have any idea what approach could be taken to accomplish this though, even where dealing with a single, otherwise logical person?
- __s 7y agoI have a fair share of interactions with the apocalyptic crowd, so this is based on interactions with that side I tend to try to demonstrate napkin math with pessimistic numbers to show that they're out of bound. Napkin math is particularly useful math because it allows one to play with parameters & abstracts/aggregates complicated bits. So we can also show how pessimistic things would have to be for them to be right, ie what we should be seeing now which would support their projection outside of their anecdotes or imagination It's important to not become identified as an adversary (ie, I'm not denying a problem when I assert they should reduce their perceived risk). This means making sure to underline which facts you agree on, & verify that your values are aligned
- mistermann 7y agoThat will work in some cases, but how might one best approach examples like we see in this thread, where numerous people seem to exhibit signs of allowing their heuristic biases to interfere with basic logical thinking, committing the very same logical errors that they accuse others of, in the same comment?
- willis936 7y agoWell, these types of arguments will get validated in the next few decades as GPS calendar errors break millions of field devices. If it was a big deal, then a lot of effort would be spent to fix the issue. All that will happen is that a bunch of harmless, somewhat useful stuff will turn into harmless, useless stuff. See [0] “Third GPS Rollover”, except know that many cheap GPS receivers made today do not implement the fix. 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_formatting_and_storage_bugs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_formatting_and_storage_bu...