3 ms·
Also, advocates of re-opening vastly overestimate their ability to make that happen. I don’t feel safe going outside, so any suggestion that for the good of the
by ashtonkem 7y ago
Also, advocates of re-opening vastly overestimate their ability to make that happen. I don’t feel safe going outside, so any suggestion that for the good of the economy I should do so will be met with a string of naughty words and continued quarantine on my part. If they want me to go back out and resume regular economic activity, they need to focus on what’ll make that feel safe again.
- hkai 7y agoThat can change very quickly once the fearmongering on the news stops reaching you. Here in Hong Kong, people who were obsessively sterilizing everything and were scared to go outside 2 weeks ago are now taking off their masks and going to the beach.
- ashtonkem 7y agoI think the differences between HK and America are quite a bit more than “fearmongering”.
- pjc50 7y agoThat is not because they've stopped listening to "fearmongering", but because the thing to fear - new infections - has receded! https://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/society/article/3081701/coronavirus-hong-kong-reports-no-new-cases-covid-19-second https://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/society/article/3081701/... By the sound of it most people are wearing masks most of the time. (Boilerplate warning about news reliability in nonfree countries)
- driverdan 7y ago> I don’t feel safe going outside Why? So long as you're not close to other people there's no risk in being outside.
- ashtonkem 7y agoThe implied detail is “and doing the regular economic activities that ‘opening up’ would entail”. The kinds of economic activities that I have stopped doing during this pandemic are relatively hard to social distance. I of course actually do go outside, but only to my patio, not to go back to my old gym or coffee shops.
- sershe 7y agoThat only applies to a small subset, like WFHing techies who are not significantly affected. Economically, regardless of the moral implications of this, people who are impacted are much more likely to go back to work (to take an extreme example, in the developing world the choices for some are already COVID or starvation). Recreation wise, I've seen lockdowns rolled out in WA. Whatever they didn't close immediately became extremely overcrowded; they even closed city parks for one weekend (2 weeks into stay at home order and with parking lots already closed), because they became insanely crowded, I run in a park nearby (Green Lake) and I've never seen it like that. Basically, I'm sorry but you are probably privileged, self-righteous or prone to media fear-mongering; I suspect all 3. For the majority of the population, only the 3rd will have some effect, and that less than you'd think.
- ashtonkem 7y agoIt’s absolutely true that as a tech worker, I’m blessed that I can work from home. I’m thankful for that. But you’re missing the point. Sending back my barista to Starbucks isn’t going to help said barista if I am unwilling to go to said coffee shop and spend money. The economy cannot start back up again until people start spending money again; my barista won’t spend money until they’re financially secure, and I won’t spend money on my barista until I feel that doing so won’t endanger my health. Keep in mind that restaurant bookings were down 50% by mid March according to OpenTable. This is before most states had stay at home orders in place. A non-trivial portion of the economic collapse has been caused by entirely voluntary behavior, which is very hard to reverse. I do however agree on recreation; governments should find a way to open up public spaces while preserving distance. I personally suspect that opening parks but constraining parking might do the trick, but I’m sure there are some weird caveats to that.
- sershe 7y agoThe point is that I was trying to make is that while you may not, I'm going to go out and order that coffee (I'm in the same WFH techie demographic); so will many others if the overcrowding of the trails and park in violation of the stay at home order and with media dialing COVID reporting up to 11 (and not just media, actually; we have signs on the highways all over the place saying stay home) is any indication. Also, I suspect that the utility of economic activity at this level is kinda like utility of money, i.e. logarithmic - going from 0% to 50% is much more significant, especially for individuals, than going from 50% to 100%.
- HarryHirsch 7y agoExactly. Consider the US meat supply chain. 15 % of production capacity is off-line because the workforce is sick. It's not that they are at home afraid of real or imagined dangers, they cannot report to work because they are too ill. (Strangely, it's only the US. You don't hear about this from Italy, Germany or Britain.) What are they going to do about it, conscript people to go work at Smithfield or Tyson until they fall over with coronaplague, too? You can't just issue edicts, you have to suppress transmission.
- vonmoltke 7y agoIt's offline because someone at those plants got sick and the companies can't operate the plants safely or effectively without additional PPE or modifications. The vast majority of the workforce itself is fine, and people are not what is needed to restart the plants.
- ashtonkem 7y agoYeah, that’s kind of the problem. Sick people can’t make an economy go. Of course we can eventually re-open, we have to re-open eventually; we’ll starve if we don’t. But we have to actually make decisions and come up with strategies that’ll make it possible for us to re-open first. If we pretend that we can just reopen the economy without doing that first, people will get sicker and the economy won’t get better.
- HarryHirsch 7y agoThe plant is shut down because it's a safety hazard to operate in its current form. It's a transmission hotspot, 200 people have tested positive, according to the Guardian: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/apr/13/south-dakota-pork-plant-closes-after-200-workers-contract-covid-19 https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/apr/13/south-dakota...
- ashtonkem 7y ago6.5% of the plant is already sick, and that’s half of the states positive cases. That’s ... less than great.