2 ms·
A new way to accurately estimate Covid-19 death toll
- samizdis 7y ago> "... there was high confidence (99 percent) the expected [US] death toll would be between 66,055 and 70,304."
- gus_massa 7y agoNah. There are so many possible unknown events, like patient 31 in Korea, if people will go to the beach when there is a sunny day, if people will crow in front of the banks in case of a bank run [1], when will the class start, will planes keep flying, ... Note that the paper says: > The new model predicts that the maximum total number of deaths will be approximately 62,100 across the United States due to the Covid-19 virus, and with a 95% confidence that the expected total death toll will be between 60,951 and 63,249 deaths based on the data until 22 April, 2020. When the intervals calculated with a high confidence at different day don't overlap, it's a huge red flag. For a more realistic interval, the paper also says: > On 17 April, the University of Washington’s Institute for Health Metrics Evaluation (IHME) projected that there would be 60,308 Covid-19 deaths with an estimated range between 34,063 and 140,381 deaths by 4 August, which is down from 68,841 as predicted earlier on 13 April. [1] we have something like this in Argentina, not a bank run, but something similar.
- necovek 7y agoIt's amazing how often death toll related to COVID-19 is taken in a vacuum. From all the little evidence we get (https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/06/well/live/coronavirus-doctors-hospitals-emergency-care-heart-attack-stroke.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/06/well/live/coronavirus-doc...), it seems that heart disease related deaths are reduced, or rather "swallowed" by the coronavirus deaths (in US alone, 650k people die of heart-related diseases every year, or more than 50k a month). To me, the explanation is logical — some who would have died of a heart disease anyway are now dying of COVID19. I do not want to dispute that it is having an effect — I just want to know what that effect is. Is it 20% more deaths? Or 4x (300%) more? Considering heart related diseases have been mostly linked to COVID19 deaths, I am surprised nobody is looking at aggregated data yet, which would help more "accurately" estimate the death toll.
- necovek 7y agoFWIW, I look at US data as a good proxy for what happens if you do not institute a full lockdown or strict social distancing rules only for the first full month with roughly 50k deaths. Assuming there was no decrease in heart-related deaths (up to 55k), that suggests that the effect is at worst 100% increase (doubling). I suspect that it's lower than that since there's bound to be an overlap, but that's still a big range (though it can also be negative since at-risk patients might get early care due to the panic, but that would be surprising).