5 ms·
How did Zuckerberg maintain his majority voting power throughout every funding round? VCs have to look at that very suspiciously. Is it possible for founders t
by echelon 7y ago
How did Zuckerberg maintain his majority voting power throughout every funding round? VCs have to look at that very suspiciously.
Is it possible for founders today to retain the same level of control, or do VCs outright refuse to fund such companies?
Are there good reading materials or strategies for maintaining control all the way through possible IPO?
How did Travis Kalanick and Adam Neumann get removed? Did they not have the same level of control that Zuckerberg did? Couldn't they have told their dissenters to fuck off? Or could the same fate befall Zuckerberg should he fall out of good graces or become involved in some controversy?
- jedberg 7y ago> How did Zuckerberg maintain his majority voting power throughout every funding round? He had a very popular product and everyone wanted in on the action. They were willing to accept founder friendly terms so they could get in the deal.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> How did Zuckerberg maintain his majority voting power throughout every funding round? If you're got majority voting power to start with then you can at every step use the majority voting power to vote to maintain your majority voting power in any deal you offer.
- icebraining 7y agoI think the question is how did Zuckerberg manage to find investors willing to take those deals.
- buran77 7y agoIt may have been pretty clear to investors that Zuckerberg is willing to do more than most other CEOs in order to make money. Easier to ask for forgiveness and all that. Investors are still getting richer and letting him in charge may actually prove to be a benefit in case the hammer ever drops on his actions.
- Mvandenbergh 7y agoWell they thought they would make a lot of money and they were right.
- hylaride 7y agoThe kind of investors who are really, really, really rich right now.
- tlrobinson 7y ago> Are there good reading materials or strategies for maintaining control all the way through possible IPO? Step 1: build a company with the growth trajectory of Facebook The rest is easy: set up dual voting class structure in which your shares have 10x the votes of everyone else. Don’t accept any investment deals that reduce your voting power to less than 50%.
- petilon 7y agoShould there be laws against depriving shareholder rights in this manner?
- justinmeiners 7y agoPresumably when you bought the shares you paid for that specific arrangement. If you don't like the share structure buy another company, or pay less for it.
- rmrfstar 7y agoGovernments are not obligated to lend their coercive power to enforce all agreements, particularly ones that lead to bad outcomes. See, e.g. Sherman Act. See also, bans on organ sales and indentured servitude. It is perfectly legitimate to say "this is a kind of agreement that should be enforced by the state." It is quite another thing to say (as you have), "a transaction happened in the market so this is legitimate." Limited liability did not exist as a legal concept in the United States until 1811. It is really strange that people now seem to view limited liability legal forms as an unqualified right, whose scope and governance can be defined by private contract without constraint.
- justinmeiners 7y agoYes, but this is far out of the context of this discussion. This topic has nothing to do with entering into an absurd unenforceable contract. Investments offer different terms to different customers. Those with fewer privileges are worth less, and you should be willing to pay less or not at all. This is not employment, or personal housing, this is a purchase purely for future financial gain, for which markets offer countless alternative offerings. Basketball teams sell different tickets and offerings, some are restricted to specific customers. You pay for the level of experience you want.
- dillonmckay 7y agoI believe this is a similar situation with the founder of Snapchat (majority voting power).
- mcny 7y agoThe last time I read about it, Snapchat reserved ~80% voting power to the founder.
- jasode 7y ago>How did Zuckerberg maintain his majority voting power throughout every funding round? VCs have to look at that very suspiciously. MZ didn't actually have majority control through every funding round. They key is that other investors (e.g. Sean Parker, Accel Partners, etc) gave voting control of their shares to MZ.[0] So the ingredients to maintain control (or eventually consolidate majority control) is to have leverage in some way. Multiple forms of leverage: + startup has real revenue and is cash flow positive and thus is not desperate for VC funding: Microsoft profits in 1981 would be an example. They didn't actually need David Marquardt's VC money before their IPO in 1986. + startup has exponential growth: Facebook is an example. Facebook was so popular that Accel Partners sought out MZ and not the other way around. + demonstrate amazing management skill: Jeff Bezos would be an example. He doesn't have majority voting power via dual-class share structure. Instead, other investors let JB control their votes. Even his ex-wife who he cheated on recognizes that her Amazon shares she got in the divorce settlement would be worth less if someone else besides her ex-husband ran Amazon. So she signed over her voting rights to him. Another thing that worked out for MZ was the older Sean Parker acting as a defacto "consigliere" to warn him how VCs strip power away from founders. And as noted earlier, when Sean was kicked out of Facebook, he turned over his voting rights to MZ. [0] https://venturebeat.com/2012/02/01/zuck-power-play/ https://venturebeat.com/2012/02/01/zuck-power-play/
- gargarplex 7y agoYou don’t know that he cheated on her. Bezos’s statements say that they were already separated. Please don’t malign either’s reputation in a public forum. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/09/business/jeff-bezos-wife-mackenzie-divorce.amp.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/09/business/jeff-bezos-wife-...
- s_y_n_t_a_x 7y agoThe cheater said he didn't cheat so no issue, gotcha. He got caught texting his girlfriend while having a wife, his wife divorced him and took $38 billion. Call it whatever you want but he smeared his own reputation. He made one of the worst social, moral, & financial decisions you could make all at the same time.
- someonehere 7y agoWhen I worked at FB, we had to sign paperwork to convert our options to common shares and that we were also signing to acknowledge Mark gets preferred stock. Our votes per share was set to one. Preferred shares were set to two (or maybe it was four) votes per share. Essentially he stacked in his favor this way. That’s how we all saw it when we got the paperwork.