4 ms·
I too assume that surgeons wear those masks for funsies. Of course the “masks don’t work” was pure, transparent, bullshit from the very beginning. It didn’t ev
by ashtonkem 7y ago
I too assume that surgeons wear those masks for funsies.
Of course the “masks don’t work” was pure, transparent, bullshit from the very beginning. It didn’t even pass the smell test. Now if the argument was “please save masks for healthcare workers first, they’re higher risk” that would be fine. But “they don’t work”? Fuck off.
Edit: I’m referring to the CDC here, not you personally, dear HN commenter.
- WrtCdEvrydy 7y agoIf you tell people to save masks for healthcare workers... then the hoarding would have been worse. At least by telling people masks don't work... peer pressure would keep them from buying them?
- ashtonkem 7y agoIt doesn’t look like anyone bought it, masks still sold out quickly and health care providers are still reusing N95 masks. And in exchange the CDC spent a large amount of their credibility; a real lose lose.
- PopePompus 7y agoThat's because the lies were so transparent. In the US we were told (by our wonderful Surgeon General) that citizens who wore masks were actually more apt to get covid than persons without masks.
- hsitz 7y agoI'm curious, was the official word always that even N95 masks didn't protect the wearer? Or just that "masks" in general (i.e., lesser masks) would not protect wearers?
- Consultant32452 7y agohttps://twitter.com/Surgeon_General/status/1233725785283932160 https://twitter.com/Surgeon_General/status/12337257852839321... Here he claims masks (general) do not protect you. But they do protect healthcare workers. It amazes me that he was willing to put two such contradictory claims in the same tweet. It was just such a transparent lie. Given the context and implication, I think it is referring to "medical" grade masks including N95, surgical masks, etc.
- ashtonkem 7y agoI’m genuinely not sure what makes me angrier: the lie, or how fucking lazy it was. The least he could do is come up with something that’s at least plausible.
- Consultant32452 7y agoLook at how effective it is. Even still in this thread.
- ashtonkem 7y agoYou have a depressingly good point.
- dreamcompiler 7y agoN95 masks protect healthcare workers because HC workers know how to properly fit them; the general public does not have this training and thus N95 masks are wasted on the GP. Another part of the confusion is that early on (six weeks ago) the assumption was that the virus spread like the flu, i.e. via droplets from coughing and sneezing. Masks alone (without face shields) are of little benefit for droplet-spread disease because they don't protect your eyes. Now we know the virus spreads via aerosols which are generated by talking or even breathing. Cloth masks do indeed help for aerosols by trapping virus particles electrostatically and by increasing humidity, both of which keep the virus out of your respiratory tract. Or so the latest thinking goes. Hanlon's Razor applies, but this virus is also an insidious bastard that behaves very differently from what public health experts had expected.
- ashtonkem 7y agoI don’t buy it. First of all, there are very different rationales for healthcare workers and the general public to wear masks. Healthcare workers know they will be exposed, so the protocols must be damn near perfect. The general population does not know if they’ll be exposed, they’re trying to work in aggregate to put a drag on the viruses’ spread; even partially effective mask wearing slows that down. The general population can also practice social distancing, while healthcare workers must spend hours in close personal contact with positive patients by the nature of their jobs, vastly increasing their risk. Second, this ignores the fact that mass mask usage prevents you from getting someone else sick. This is in fact exactly why surgeons wear surgical masks. Since we’ve known for months that this disease has asymptomatic transmission, the public health rationale for even cloth mask usage was obvious from the very beginning.
- 8ytecoder 7y agoI used to think like what OP said. But after seeing the response in Asian countries with their much larger families and denser cities working against them and yet slowing the spread, masks might be playing an important role there. It also reminds everyone constantly. It does stop me from touching my face as well. So yeah, even if it's not perfect it's going to help quite a bit.
- DanBC 7y agoN95 masks are used as part of a package of PPE. That includes eye shields, gloves, and gowns. There's a complex protocol to put them on, and to take them off. Without the rest of the kit, and without careful adherence to correct donning and doffing, there are at best marginal benefits to mask wearing. There's some concern that those marginal benefits are eliminated if people wearing masks go on to engage in risky behaviours. These behaviours include increased touching of their face (often without immediate handwashing afterwards), reductions in distance between people, increase in frequency of leaving the home, etc etc.
- ashtonkem 7y agoNonsense. PPE is designed to mitigate a completely different level and type of risk. PPE is designed for medical professionals who by the very nature of their job must spend hours in physical contact with known sick patients. The protocols must be strict because failure means guaranteed infection. I on the other hand have no obligation to physically touch random strangers, thank god, and don’t have to go interact with known sick people. Instead I’m trying to provide some protection for myself, and trying to work in aggregate to reduce the risk that asymptomatic carriers spread the disease while doing essential activities. “Marginal benefits” in this context is also known as “reducing R0”, which is absolutely a public health goal. Now all of that is a good argument for saving N95 masks for medical workers and relying on surgical or cloth masks for the general public, especially in the light of PPE shortages. But that is an entirely different argument from “masks don’t work”.
- DanBC 7y ago> I on the other hand have no obligation to physically touch random strangers, thank god, and don’t have to go interact with known sick people. What's the point of wearing the mask then?
- ashtonkem 7y agoGotta go get groceries at some point, and that means breathing in the air someone else exhaled.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- eli 7y agoI don’t know if that’s true or not, but I’m certain that lying to the public about what they can do to stop the virus was a bad call and will have lasting harm.
- ooobit2 7y agoNot just a bad call, the lack of ownership by Democrats and their half-working-on-the-issue, half-keeping-the-Trump-tabloid-train-moving throughout all of this contributed significantly to the overall failure, and has played a huge role in us reaching Great Depression-era economic status. Every overblown executive order, news report, today-people-are-dangerous, tomorrow-we're-readying-to-reopen. Lying was just phase one or two. We're up to phase six now.
- loopz 7y agoWe hear the same over the pond. The argument is that the masks may not be fit for purpose or be used incorrectly, thus might actually be more contagious as people will tend to touch their faces more often etc. The official stances are still that people need training in order to use masks correctly, and the masks must meet standards to protect the user. All masks may protect others to some degree though. "Masks work, don't work" are not cogent arguments. It's the same with plastic gloves. Their usage in ie. grocery stores etc. may not help as much as incorrect usage may work against the intention. Again the argument is that if you get your hands dirty, you know you need to wash your hands and might think twice before touching face. Even washing hands properly require some training. We've since learned that less extreme measures may be good enough once you have control, testing and tracking.
- ramraj07 7y agoThe problem is no one likes to look stupid, and this is one of the cases where anyone who can spell words together was able to see through the BS. Whether they are going to hoard it or not, the solution is not for an expert to lie to the public.
- lambdasquirrel 7y agoNo one knows why the CDC issued the guidelines that they did. There's also fairly little doubt that the CDC in previous decades would've been smarter and better organized. A lot of the commentary about the matter is disingenuous. Of course they won't filter out all the infectious agents for all healthcare workers forever. It was a matter of risk mitigation, just as much as shelter-in-place is. Getting infected is a numbers game, as is the live-locking of available hospital capacity.
- tzs 7y agoSurgeons wear masks to protect the patient from droplets from the surgeon's nose and mouth, which otherwise could easily fall right into the patient's open wound.
- ashtonkem 7y agowhich is still relevant for slowing down the spread of a respiratory virus.
- ardy42 7y ago> Of course the “masks don’t work” was pure, transparent, bullshit from the very beginning. It didn’t even pass the smell test. No, that's not true. Maybe the advice was wrong, but it wasn't "pure, transparent, bullshit." It was always clearly stated that N95s worked if worn properly, but there was a lot of debate if surgical masks would offer much protection or not (they're known to be inadequate for certain viruses). Especially early on, people didn't understand much about this virus, such as the particle sizes involved or if asymptomatic transmission was real or not. There were a lot of factors to weigh in the recommendation in an environment of uncertainty. > Now if the argument was “please save masks for healthcare workers first, they’re higher risk” that would be fine. They did make that argument: https://www.marketwatch.com/story/the-cdc-says-americans-dont-have-to-wear-facemasks-because-of-coronavirus-2020-01-30 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/the-cdc-says-americans-don... > Most people don’t know how to use face masks correctly, and a rush to buy masks could prevent the people who need them most — health care providers — from getting them, said Dr. Amesh Adalja, a scholar at the Center for Health Security at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health. > In fact the U.S. surgeon general recently urged the public to “STOP BUYING MASKS!” “They are NOT effective in preventing general public from catching #Coronavirus, but if healthcare providers can’t get them to care for sick patients, it puts them and our communities at risk!,” wrote Surgeon General Jerome Adams on Twitter US:TWTR > But “they don’t work”? Fuck off. It's also pretty clear that they were right that tons of people in the general public don't know how to wear masks correctly. I don't go out much, but when I do there's always a bunch of fools wearing N95s improperly (not using both straps, bunching both straps together behind the head, not shaping the noise area to fit the face). I even see people wearing surgical masks improperly (e.g. not covering the nose, not shaping the nose area, not folding out the material to stretch from the nose to under the chin, etc.). There's also the issue that the general public is unlikely to follow the kinds of rigorous protocols that make N95s effective in a healthcare setting.
- ashtonkem 7y agoThere are two core problems with your argument: 1) Wearing masks is a trainable skill. None of us know how to use condoms initially either, yet literally millions of Americans use them effectively yearly. 2) Masks don’t have to be worn with perfect correctness to produce an effect in aggregate. If mask usage was even 30% effective, this would drop R0 by roughly as much, which is a big freaking deal. The N95 vs surgical mask is a tricky balance to strike; of course N95 should be saved for those at the highest risk, and if you know your mask will be sprayed with virus droplets, extra precautions must be taken. But that’s much more relevant to medical workers, not those of us who want to reduce risk going to the grocery store.
- cycomanic 7y agoActually surgeons wear the masks to protect the patient not themselves. That's very similar to what likely is the biggest benefit of widespread mask use, reducing the infectiosness of people.
- ashtonkem 7y agoIt’s amazing how many people blindly repeat this as if it’s a good argument. It’s not a good counter argument at all. Stopping other people from catching something you might have is a fantastic reason to ask everyone to wear a mask during a pandemic. It’s actually probably the main reason you’d want to do so, from a public health perspective, because it helps you prevent asymptomatic thread. The idea that the surgeon general would beg everyone to not wear a mask is utter madness.
- cycomanic 7y agoI completely agree with you, they make perfect sense from a public health perspective and it was a major fck up by most of the health organisations World wide to say they wouldn't (if intentional or not doesn't really matter). However I was replying to a comment that was implying surgeons are using them to protect themselves. That is just wrong. There are enough good arguments for masks, one does not need to make incorrect statements.