2 ms·
That's out of context. It was an example of the kind of change the earth has seen in epochs where polar ice melts completely, not a prediction for the immediat
by ajross 18y ago
That's out of context. It was an example of the kind of change the earth has seen in epochs where polar ice melts completely, not a prediction for the immediate future. And the IPCC has 4C as its upper bound, not 2, and in any case they don't predict motion of antarctic ice sheets due to lack of models. Their predictions for sea level change are conservative, basically.
And as far as hyperbole goes:
> In other words, nothing worth returning to the stone age for.
Taking the bus and paying more for electricity is "returning to the stone age?" Now who's panicking?
- Prrometheus 18y agoMy point is that we should formulate Global Warming policy with an eye on likely consequences, not the worst case scare scenarios.
- ajross 18y agoThat logic doesn't work. You might as well argue that traffic laws are inappropriate because you almost certainly won't get killed on the way home today. This is called "risk assessment", and it's an important and crucial part of any policy discussion. You don't just pick the average and assume that will happen, you weigh costs vs. risks across the board, including the "best" and "worst" scenarios, and try to come up with a safe, conservative plan for avoiding the worst effects. I think you're misunderstanding the use of the "worst case" in the IPCC report. Those aren't OMGWTFBBQ scenarios from someone's dreams, they are the scenarios from the actual science that lie within a reasonably tight bound. They are likely consequences for some value of "likely" (probably a 95% confidence, or the like).
- MaysonL 18y agoSuppose there's a 10% chance that the Gulf Stream will turn off (an event which has previously occurred, and which was followed by extreme rapid cooling of northern Europe), given one set of policy choices, and a .1% percent chance, given another set. How much should we be willing to pay to implement the second set? The thing that always gets me about this debate, and the energy debates in general, is that energy efficiency is still far and away the most productive energy investment around: what is needed is ways for individual consumers to make those investment easily.