3 ms·
“Think of the children” is almost always cover for a lack of a rational argument. In this case, it is distracting from the fact that, compared to smoking, the
by sneak 7y ago
“Think of the children” is almost always cover for a lack of a rational argument.
In this case, it is distracting from the fact that, compared to smoking, the harm from vaping is so ridiculously tiny as to be deemed “harmless” on that scale.
Smoking kills half of its users (seven million smokers a year dead), and additionally kills OVER A MILLION non-users each and every year from proximity to smokers.
Your hate is misplaced. This is the pinnacle of whataboutism.
Vaping is a huge net benefit to society.
- MisterBastahrd 7y agoThere are plenty of kids who vape who would have never smoked because of the smell it has on your clothes. Now they're addicted to nicotine anyway and who knows how they're going to deal with the long-term repercussions of inhaling a bunch of hot PG and other crap.
- trcollinson 7y agoIs taking up vaping bad for youth that are under the age of 18? Is taking up vaping bad for adults over the age of 18? And I do mean, when they otherwise were not smokers? If so, has Juul actively tried to market their products to non-smokers in any range? Have they actively tried to inform the public about the potential harms of starting to vape when you are otherwise a non-smoker? There is no doubt that Juul is safer than a pack of cigarettes. But Juul can't make it as a start up selling to only smokers who want to reduce their risk of death, as has been seen by their sales numbers. They are actively marketing to groups of people who are in zero current harm from first hand nicotine. And nicotine does harm those people. Here's a peer reviewed article just to make the point. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4363846/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4363846/
- sneak 7y agoThere is no evidence whatsoever that the harmful effects of nicotine cause even 1% of the damage caused by the harmful effects of inhaling combustion byproducts. This is irrelevant, and is just emotional spillover from the decades of repetition of how bad smoking is. (In some ways it’s like people trying to ban rifles that cause ~700 deaths per year in the US while small caliber handguns cause >11k.) Salty fried foods are a bigger public health issue right now than if every nonsmoker took up vaping.
- trcollinson 7y agoI am not sure what the evidence is of nicotine vs inhaled combustion byproducts, but I do agree that the effects are far less. I don't find my questions irrelevant though, even though you have glossed right passed all of them. The other examples you have are a false equivalence. We can certainly say that nicotine sellers have an obligation to explain the effects of their products and also say that there are bigger public health issues right now. I certainly would not imply that nicotine is the largest public health issue right now. But we can deal with so many things at once.
- paxys 7y agoCigarette smoking among schoolchildren was already on a heavy downward trend for decades until Juul made it "cool" again. In fact there has been a slight increase in recent years, as teenagers start with Juul and then take up cigarettes. They have helped a ton of adults quit or reduce smoking, which is great, but they have also explicitly targeted kids via presentations in classrooms, paid underage Instagram influencers and lots more. There is no requirement to excuse the second because of the first.