3 ms·
An interesting thought experiment is would a video showcasing this paper risk being be banned on YouTube? I'm not going to bother checking if the WHO has a Vita
by roenxi 7y ago
An interesting thought experiment is would a video showcasing this paper risk being be banned on YouTube? I'm not going to bother checking if the WHO has a Vitamin D recommendation; but recommending many multiples of the FDA dose probably counts as misinformation.
- tlrobinson 7y agoBecause the WHO and FDA never got anything wrong...?
- Figs 7y agoNo; rather YouTube has taken it upon themselves to decide what the truth is and censor views they believe are wrong. e.g. see this news article: https://www.androidheadlines.com/2020/04/youtube-ceo-coronavirus-content-policy-ban.html https://www.androidheadlines.com/2020/04/youtube-ceo-coronav... --- (Snippet from the article) --- YouTube's response is now to simply remove videos containing misinformation while previous policies have seen most related content demonetized. Examples provided by the executive include videos claiming that people can be cured by taking vitamin C or turmeric. Neither has been proven to act as a cure according to the wider health community. Another example of prominent videos that are being removed, she continues, are those related to 5G as an underlying cause. The policy changes, like the rise of those conspiracy theories, have had to be rapid. As a result, for the time being, Videos that contain claims in direct opposition to information provided by WHO will be removed as well. YouTube hopes that by removing conspiracy theories and misinformation, it can help keep users better informed. ---- While it may squash some of the stupider and more dangerous ideas floating around right now, it tosses the baby out with the bathwater and harms important discussion about whether those in charge right now do actually have their information right.
- hutzlibu 7y ago"While it may squash some of the stupider and more dangerous ideas floating around right now, it tosses the baby out with the bathwater and harms important discussion about whether those in charge right now do actually have their information right. " Has been always like this with censorship.
- thu2111 7y agoI think a more likely reason for a ban would simply be that the Vitamin D connection was being highlighted by lockdown skeptics for quite some time already, as part of investigating the Swedish outcomes. The problem is that to highly liberal Google employees it might look 'racist' because the Vit-D connection came out of trying to figure out why Swedish migrants were over-represented in ICU cases, also African-Americans. For instance, in this comment from six days ago I write about a possible vitamin D connection: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22968268 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22968268