3 ms·
> I think it's pretty easy to say that Google was doing more impressive things at the beginning of the century... Within the last five years, there was a moment
by crazygringo 7y ago
> I think it's pretty easy to say that Google was doing more impressive things at the beginning of the century... Within the last five years, there was a moment when Google had 4 competing chat apps. This is pretty rank inefficiency. If you were to take 80k people (not all are engineers, obviously) and sit them down and ask them to use their talents to build separately, you'd end up with a lot more innovation and productivity, I'm pretty certain of that.
You're misunderstanding how large companies operate.
Their job is not to produce massive innovation -- that's what startups are mostly for, because most innovation actually fails in the market. Once innovation is proven, a big company like Google or Facebook can buy it to scale it larger and with less risk than the startup could have on their own.
Google's job has been to increase revenue, and they've been doing a great job at that. The productivity increase happens from building enterprise features, hiring gigantic sales teams, etc. Building Google Cloud.
And separate chat apps is necessary when WhatsApp and Slack and iMessage are eating your lunch. You can't risk having a single chat app that fails -- so you build one (Duo) that competes with WhatsApp and iMessage, another (Hangouts Chat) that competes with Slack, without pulling the plug (yet) on the legacy Hangouts.
So if you took all 80k people, as you suggest, you'd wind up with a mess of startups which will mostly fail. You're not going to wind up with Google's actual increases in revenues, that's for sure.
- gustavo-fring 7y agoI understand that's how lots of big companies operate, but I disagree that's how companies have to or should operate. The 80k thing isn't he notion that you'd get 80k success stories (you won't), but rather that if you had a .01% success rate, you'd still end up with 8 successful companies out of that, and the market is big enough for those 8 companies doing different things, making lots of money, and creating jobs/value. But more importantly, I feel like it would be better for us as societies.
- jmchuster 7y agoGoogle Ventures already spends $4.5 billion on that very thing? And there are tons of other VCs and incubators out there?