11 ms·
I don’t really understand what “no code” is. You can put up a storefront and conduct business without writing a line of code, simply by adding plug ins to Wordp
by gumby 7y ago
I don’t really understand what “no code” is. You can put up a storefront and conduct business without writing a line of code, simply by adding plug ins to Wordpress, calling out to stripe etc. The result is somewhat templatized and slightly generic looking but that’s great: your value comes from the content, as the author correctly describes, and the visitor will presumably understand navigation etc.
This kind of process has decades of predecessors, from dbs like Delphi, Excel, to Emacs in the ‘70s to (so it was claimed at the time) FORTRAN.
Is “no code” meant to somehow imply something more?
- gustavo-fring 7y agoHopefully this isn't ungenerous, but it seems like a marketing/signaling term that people on places like indiehackers use to market their products. If it wasn't labeled as such, a nondescript framework with the plugins + content that you could build for the last 20 years wouldn't stand out. Bothers me that it is something that apparently people are proud of, they'd empower themselves a lot more by sitting down and picking up a basic framework, where they aren't limited by someone else. It's not as though they aren't capable.
- _curious_ 7y ago"it seems like a marketing/signaling term that people on places like indiehackers use to market their products" Bingo.
- tmpz22 7y agoNo code is a signal of bullshit for a company who claims software development as their competitive advantage but in truth the core competency is something else or doesn’t exist at all. Wework is a good example.
- zerkten 7y ago>> Is "no code" meant to somehow imply something more? In a way it's less. The products you list are much more capable developer products. These are more in the direction of the FileMaker or Access level of constraint, but implemented in a more modern way which means they can be fairly effective. Using "no code" is just branding that hasn't been used broadly until now. Maybe it has, but it probably isn't well known enough to be unusable. I'd have called these "4GLs" perhaps. Lots of companies are getting in on the act to create a market for this. All of the established companies making business software have some no/low code solution. Then there are newer companies like Zapier who do automation and are trying to be a connector between these apps.
- bitexploder 7y agoAccess was one of my favorite Microsoft products of the late 90s. As a high school kid learning C, VB6, and Linux I came across access and really liked that it let me make easy forms. If you knew how to do DB design access was a great tool. I made a grading system for a teacher and several other teachers adopted it. They used it for almost 8 years before moving on. I was just a curious high school kid able to make useful software with a little persistence. It still feels like that level of accessibility in terms of software tooling does not exist in modern dev. It’s all watered down and abstracted in ways a simple Desktop app is not.
- decentralised 7y agoFWIW, 4GL is from the 70s https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth-generation_programming_language https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth-generation_programming_... (my favourite: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_Informix-4GL https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_Informix-4GL)
- ryanSrich 7y agoFrom what I can tell yes. It’s intended to imply something more. See bubble for example - https://bubble.io https://bubble.io . It’s basically “visual” Rails. The intention is to allow users to build complex, interactive software visually, without having to write code. Webflow has a ton of plugins that can get you something similar. You can have a user model (memberstack.io) with authentication and even the ability to create user specific content. I was able to create a fairly complex user dashboard that had real time charts pulled from an Airtable database that was synced automatically with user interaction using Zapier. ...but, here’s the issue. You just can’t do enough. I made it about a week before I abandon the idea and went back to Rails. I’m still bullish on the idea of no code though. The tools are there. They just need more functionality.
- chrisco255 7y agoThat's always the case though. The reason why we use programming languages is because we need the expressiveness they offer. Attempting to simplify it any further severely limits the type of applications you can build. And so you end up with cookie cutter apps. It might be fun, it might even be useful for some back office tasks, but if the marginal cost to produce a thing goes to near zero, it would imply the supply of apps competing for that category would explode.
- tluyben2 7y agoA lot nocode or lowcode tools are visual programming languages; they are in fact just programming tools but look (and often are) simpler to start off with. But when you need more, you are in fact programming with code, just via a visual interface. Which indeed can (will) become painful for many tasks. Then you are using the wrong tool for the job. Thing is, and this differs per market; most companies do not need anything more than endless streams of crud apps, and that is where these tools shine. You (and many of HN) might work in the b2c market, but where I work, people do not care much about how things look or ux; they care if they work just a little better than the sap or oracle interfaces they had before. Actually, this goes for many (most?) b2c products as well; most (traditional; challenger banks are a lot better) banking or airline apps I know look like bad template barf-ups (many are indeed that, bought from the same cooking cutting companies) and yet people use them. Would it be better if they were custom designed with money spent on actual ux and design? Sure, but apparently not enough to matter to the company commissioning it. When companies I work with look for no/low code, the only reason they will not use it is vendor lock in; if they cannot run on premise and/or ‘eject’ the code, they will not use it. Several products allow this and they are fairly popular (so much in fact that they cannot find enough ‘devs’ for their clients). These systems have their place; it is just (much) faster (some boring things in regular environments are just a few clicks with these tools) for some x% of applications while another y% you cannot do with them or is very difficult; I would still do the x% in such a tool as thinking ‘we might need x+y later on’ is premature usually and in my experience does not pan out. We have programmed applications ‘created for expansion’ 15-20 years ago that run to this day which would have fit in the x%; aka we wasted time and money while the expansion was never realised by the client. Edit; > it would imply the supply of apps competing for that category would explode. And that is a very consumer centric approach; we are not all making fitness apps or something; these apps would all look (more or less) the same but work on different APIs and data; that is fine for almost everything; not only some internal stuff. It helps companies a great deal to just have something their clients can use vs nothing, even if the cost is close to zero; and they cannot be the same as they talk with different systems and different data. Even creating partner dashboards more efficiently than slinging code is something people do all the time and you cannot ‘just copy paste that’ to another company. These products are not generally meant to build ‘the next whatsapp’. But you can prototype it with them and show investors; I agree with you there though; wrong tool for the job.
- quantummkv 7y agoI think of it as the final evolution of the Uber/Airbnb/Any process with a website is a tech startup thinking process. This whole no-code thing is basically a bunch of terms that allow people with valid, legitimate but boring old businesses to feel like they are Microsoft or Google. While extracting a whole lot of money of course off the fluff around it.
- flukus 7y agoUsually it means you're still coding, but entering the "code" into forms and wizards instead of text. After that inevitably fails there are usually text coding fallbacks that require 10 times more code than if you'd written the whole thing from scratch.
- renewiltord 7y agoNo, it's just that, but below some threshold of friction because of comprehensive integrations and simple UI. Think Zapier, in which you can build something that has real value in under 5 mins. It's a useful category for the people who use these (like me).
- Animats 7y agoI don’t really understand what “no code” is. Drag and drop plus lots of options in dialog boxes, looks like. It's been done before. Viamall, (later Yahoo Store) the first online shopping cart system, was very much like that. Totally hosted, updated through the web, pay by the month. When Yahoo bought them, they demanded a cut of revenue, too. Those seem to be the key components of this concept. Other ancestors include Visual Basic, Dreamweaver, and Hypercard, but those were not hosted by the company behind the system, so they didn't have the lock-in and profit potential of hosted systems. It's a reaction to the mess the HTML/CSS/Javascript crowd has made of web design. The web was supposed to be WYSIWYG, and that got broken.
- eru 7y agoHistorical note: Viaweb was the baby of our host Paul Graham and his cofounders.
- redis_mlc 7y agoHistorical note: Viaweb was written in lisp, so most of the users had a hard time customizing it (I heard of one book on modifying Viaweb, but have never actually seen it.) Yahoo eventually re-wrote it in another language.
- dragandj 7y agoWhereas if they wrote it in C++, the average store owner Joe would have a walk in the park with it?
- pphysch 7y agoDepending on how heavily metaprogramming is relied on, relatively so
- eru 7y agoYou are mixing up two layers. Viaweb was written in Common Lisp, but the end users used RMTL (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RTML https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RTML). Whether you implement RTML in Python, Unlambda, Common Lisp or Rust doesn't make a difference to the user.
- shrimpx 7y agoNo code/low code is reinvented over and over as trends/paradigms enter their late stages of consolidation. Yes it implies “something more” in that these new tools function in the modern world.
- PopeDotNinja 7y agoWhen you say it like that, I'm pretty impressed that I ran a successful no-construction business by renting an office in an existing building :)
- steve_taylor 7y ago“No-code” in this article refers to founders who don’t code.
- celloductor 7y agoyea building complex, polished apps using no-code tools is arguably more harder than just writing code and using frameworks. it's a different set of skills, albeit still a skill so i don't get why programmers are feeling threatened by it.
- ozim 7y agoI feel threatened by it in a very specific way. There are pointy haired bosses who will order that: "now we will do low code". When they bump into obstacle that is not doable in low-code they will be angry at the developers that cannot deliver what customer wants. Where with just normal development you would not run into such issues. As a developer I have some power to say no to such thing but marketing people at low-code can promise everything without ever providing what they promised.
- wccrawford 7y agoA "low code" or "no code" office would never hire me in the first place, so I'm not really scared of this. My talent lies in making hard things possible, not in the low-hanging fruit that can be done with "low code". That said, as senior developer I've been very happy lately to get the company to use more off-the-shelf libraries (like Material UI for React) rather than coding our own stuff, lessening our development and maintenance time and letting us work on more stuff that matters instead. Of course, we can also create custom components instead if we have to.
- GVIrish 7y agoI ran into this in my last federal contracting job. Customer was being sold on using ServiceNow as a low code solution to replace a custom .net application with something like 2 million LOC. No-code and low-code solutions are seductive to many because they can get easy wins fast, but those easy wins mask the fact that more complex functionality is either more difficult, or outright impossible. Not to mention that once you heavily customize those products, upgrades can become very painful and very costly.
- godzillabrennus 7y agoThe guy behind http://www.buildfire.com http://www.buildfire.com enabled companies to offer mobile apps without coding experience. He now has the means to race McLarens and sky dive religiously. Unlocking human ingenuity while making our species less depending on learning to think like a computer is always going to be a big market.
- contravariant 7y agoEvery time I've encountered it it's just textless programming. Typically these systems are either very limited or Turing complete. The better ones acknowledge this and allow you to use code when you want/need to.
- wenc 7y agoNo-code solutions are like Glide [1], which lets you create a mobile app using Google Sheets as a starting point and then assembling interface elements/flow logic in a designer. I think there's value in no-code even for seasoned programmers, especially for quick front-end work. The front-end world is currently very fragmented. Us backend folks are completely befuddled by all the options and frameworks that are out there (Angular, Vue, React, Oh jquery is out? Wait, there's a movement back to plain old Javascript? etc.). Many of us just want to concentrate on building the backend, and use a tool to quickly mock up a CRUD interface or mobile app in order deploy quickly and iterate with customers. [1] https://www.glideapps.com/ https://www.glideapps.com/