3 ms·
Didn't say it doesn't make sense to do more testing, but relaxing your reasoning standard in emergencies is a bad idea.
by seemslegit 6y ago
Didn't say it doesn't make sense to do more testing, but relaxing your reasoning standard in emergencies is a bad idea.
- tarboreus 6y agoThey said "looking at more results," not "relax our reasoning standards."
- seemslegit 6y agoYes, you should not look at any result in an emergency you wouldn't otherwise - in fact you should probably only increase scrutiny given how much incentive there is to merely get a headline with your drug mentioned as a potential covid19 cure. The OP is basically arguing for a "something must be done and this is something" reasoning.
- downerending 6y agoThere's always "We've tried nothing, and we're all out of ideas." :-)
- seemslegit 6y agoYes there is. Not having effective options against a new virus is the null hypothesis. So by all means do whatever research has promising leads but don't lower burden of proof for accepting something as clinically effective.
- downerending 6y agoI'm picturing the passengers on the Titanic standing around, refusing to move until presented with an option proven valid to p < 0.95.
- cy_hauser 6y agoI'm picturing the Feds and States shelling out desperately needed money to purchase an almost useless drug because the people on the Titanic are desperate for anything rather than the drowning.
- downerending 6y agoIf it does indeed turn out to be useless (which is far from obvious at the moment), it'll be dropped, and not much money will have been spent. It's unfortunate, but a lot of what we're trying right now will turn out to be useless. One or two recent analyses suggest that the (far more expensive) lockdowns might turn out to have been almost useless. That doesn't mean that trying them was the wrong thing to do. We're living in unusually uncertain times.
- gus_massa 6y agoIt is like the passengers discussing if they must carry a box with 10 pounds of oranges in each life boat, find some paddles, a plastic cover, or paint the Eyes of Horus in them before launching them. The first three look useful, but I'm not sure if they improve the chance of survival too much. You need some time to find them and enough room in the boat, so it is a trade off if they are useful at all.