2 ms·
I think we can put property taxes aside, you’ll have to pay your landlords property taxes if you rent after all. If you can afford the cost of a down payment (
by ashtonkem 7y ago
I think we can put property taxes aside, you’ll have to pay your landlords property taxes if you rent after all.
If you can afford the cost of a down payment (more on that later), then buying a home does have some utility in wealth generation. You’re right that most of the initial mortgage payments go towards interest, but even collecting 25% of your monthly payment towards your own net worth is a big deal compared to collecting 0%. Especially since there is a good chance that your landlord has a mortgage too, either original or secondary to afford more property, so you must pay their interest plus a portion of their living expenses. This is why generally speaking home ownership is considered superior to renting if you’re not going to move anytime soon.
I think the main argument against home ownership from a wealth standpoint is that it ties up a large amount of money as collateral that you could otherwise be using. Here in SoCal purchasing a home with a traditional 20% down would involve locking up $200,000 that could be put into the market productively, potentially making me even more money. This is why the counterintuitive rule is that if you have enough money to buy a house with cash, you should get a mortgage and invest the rest, as you’ll be better off that way in the long run[0].
[0] Caveat here being your age. If you’re 30, you have another 30 years for the difference to grow in the stock market, while if you’re 70 you’d probably appreciate the lower cost of living and stability that this provides.
- jerf 7y ago"Here in SoCal purchasing a home with a traditional 20% down would involve locking up $200,000 that could be put into the market productively" I've been saying this for years, maybe after this year it'll make more sense: It is not sensible to model "the market" as if it makes steady X% (for X somewhere in the 5-8 range) returns every year. It can and has gone decades being flat-ish, or slightly down after inflation, or up but nowhere near X% a year. The timescale where this is a reasonable model is longer than your expected productive working years. "Return X% a year" is basically the best case on a decade time scale, not the average case. There have been time frames in my life when paying principle on my mortgage was a significantly better "investment" than the stock market. In hindsight it'll be obvious what you should have done, but in hindsight you can turn a few hundred dollars into a few million in just a couple of weeks with perfect past knowledge of the market, so if we're stipulating hindsight you've made way bigger mistakes than merely "buying a house".
- ashtonkem 7y agoIn the long run, the market beats principle in your home. But “the long run” can often be far beyond a useful timeframe for a single human lifespan.
- amiga_500 7y agoIncorrect. Property taxes are not part of the price setting. You pay the max you are willing to pay for renting a place. You won because everyone else was willing to pay less. If your rent is 2000 and property taxes are 200, and they go up to 300, are you willing/able to pay more? Land taxes carry no dead weight. http://wealthandwant.com/themes/Not_Passed_On.html http://wealthandwant.com/themes/Not_Passed_On.html In general prices are set by the ability to pay, not by the input costs + some "fair profit". Many landlords have no mortgage, and are clearing loads of profit every single month. Are they charging lower rent because they only need "fair profit"? No, they charge the market rate.
- ashtonkem 7y agoExcellent point.