3 ms·
At best, computers can create art-lite commodities. They can't create art (yet), because art is not about creating objects. Or content. Or any of those other wo
by TheOtherHobbes 7y ago
At best, computers can create art-lite commodities. They can't create art (yet), because art is not about creating objects. Or content. Or any of those other words.
The only medium that matters in art is the culture around the art itself. That's what real artists really work with - cultures of perception, social context, and imagination. The objects produced are just souvenirs.
Computers - with or without AI - have exactly zero creative agency. Until that changes they won't be making art.
Randomly exploring a creative space a human has defined is not the same as creating an original artistic or cultural insight, dramatising it with art objects, defending it against cultural attacks, and leaving a lasting legacy.
Of course most artists don't do that either. But they do distill and concentrate human experiences into a saleable form. Computers can't even do that, because they don't have any experiences to distill.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dkersten 7y agoI disagree. There is plenty of abstract art that's considered art that is visually no different from what a computer might generate. There's plenty of art made by small children, animals or spilled paint and its considered art. None of these things distill any human experiences or creative agency or anything, but are considered art. Computers can totally do that.
- wkearney99 7y agoI can't quite put my finger on the best response to all that, other than to say "get a shovel, there's a lot of bullshit piled up here". "Real artists", oh, now THERE'S a shining bit of arrogance. Likewise the notion that the artist is somehow creating a distillation the audience themselves wouldn't be able to otherwise find revelatory and enjoyable from any number of other random AI influences. Because they quite probably would, and this no doubt presents a terrifying possibility to the merchants of your art "culture". But works of true value maintain currency over time. This, however, doesn't make everything else created in-between worthless. It's just different. AI art is likewise.