3 ms·
What law did Congress pass?
by krapp 7y ago
What law did Congress pass?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- IfIEverCatchYou 7y agoJust because Congress didn't make the gubernatorial orders doesn't excuse state governors from these constitutional rights violations.
- krapp 7y ago>Just because Congress didn't make the gubernatorial orders doesn't excuse state governors from these constitutional rights violations. They aren't constitutional rights violations by definition. Congress (and, explicitly, as written, only Congress as a body) is prevented from passing laws at a national level forcing states to violate their citizens' right to speech and assembly, but states have the right to do so of their own accord (as states by default claim all powers not given to the Federal government), and precedent has allowed it under exigent circumstances, such as 9/11 and prior pandemics. One could argue that the lockdown orders are unnecessary, but I think that would only be apparent in hindsight, and even then it would turn out to be a misuse of power that states legitimately have, but not abuse or an unlawful exercise of power, unless certain conspiracy theories about "globalist elites" turned out to be true (spoiler: they won't.)
- zaroth 7y ago> They aren't constitutional rights violations by definition. IANAL, but pretty sure that’s not how it works. Articles incorporated against the State prevent the State from passing laws that violate the Article. The Attorney General specifically has told the DOJ to be on the lookout for over-reach by the States in these lockdown orders.
- krapp 7y ago>IANAL, but pretty sure that’s not how it works. Articles incorporated against the State prevent the State from passing laws that violate the Article. IANAL either, but here are examples of legal decisions and opinions by the various courts including the Supreme Court which appear to disagree with you[0-2], as well as some articles [3-4] which provide a basis for a legal argument that states have the right to restrict the movements of citizens in the name of public safety, including the imposition of quarantine measures, and that these powers are not a violation of the constitution. What is not constitutional is a national quarantine enacted by Congress. >The Attorney General specifically has told the DOJ to be on the lookout for over-reach by the States in these lockdown orders. Indeed, here's an article on that[5] with the following quoted from a memo by AG Barr himself: "If a state or local ordinance crosses the line from an appropriate exercise of authority to stop the spread of COVID-19 into an overbearing infringement of constitutional and statutory protections, the Department of Justice may have an obligation to address that overreach in federal court." So even from the AG's own pen, we have the admission that states do have appropriate authority in this case, although that authority is limited and can be abused. This is a different and more nuanced argument than the one apparently made by GP, that the first amendment prevents states from having any such authority at all. If that were the case, the AG wouldn't be telling the DOJ to be on the lookout for something that already exists in plain sight. [0]https://casetext.com/case/best-v-st-vincents-hospital https://casetext.com/case/best-v-st-vincents-hospital [1]https://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=5388116257633967058&q=hickox+ebola&hl=en&as_sdt=2006 https://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=538811625763396... [2]https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/441/418/ https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/441/418/ [3]https://nationalinterest.org/blog/buzz/yes-all-coronavirus-closures-and-lockdowns-are-legal-135742 https://nationalinterest.org/blog/buzz/yes-all-coronavirus-c... [4]https://www.courier-journal.com/story/news/2020/04/19/protesters-say-governors-violating-their-constitutional-rights-stay-home-orders/5162295002/ https://www.courier-journal.com/story/news/2020/04/19/protes... [5]https://nypost.com/2020/04/28/barr-tells-prosecutors-to-look-for-coronavirus-orders-that-violate-constitution/ https://nypost.com/2020/04/28/barr-tells-prosecutors-to-look...
- Fjolsvith 7y agoWhen the issue goes to the SCOTUS, I'm sure that parallels will be drawn to how our society manages restricting vulnerable populations versus restricting all population. An example would be how children aren't allowed in establishments whose sole purpose is to sell adult restricted items like alcohol or pornography.