3 ms·
Lessig made this argument the center of his case, and redirected every line of questioning with the Supreme Court justices back to this theory. As a lawyer who
by tokenadult 16y ago
Lessig made this argument the center of his case, and redirected every line of questioning with the Supreme Court justices back to this theory.
As a lawyer who used to be a judicial clerk for an appellate court, and who has heard many oral arguments before that appellate court, I can't believe that Lessig would muff up on this basic issue of legal argumentation. Argue your preferred theory, sure, but also go along with any hints the court gives you in its order calling for review of the case or in oral argument about what alternative theory to use to PERSUADE THE COURT. The lawyer's duty to the lawyer's client is to win the case, after all, and especially if you have any factual basis for saying that a particular appellate decision would result in actual real-world harm, in addition to being inconsistent with sound abstract legal principles, SAY SO. I'm glad to see that Lessig is forthright about acknowledging his mistake, and I wish him well the next time he has opportunity to argue the issues dearest to this heart before an appellate court.
- barrkel 16y agoFrom what I understood, Lessig was looking for a broad-ranging principle, rather than something specific to the case in question and its related harms. He was overreaching.
- wnoise 16y agoAgreed. In precedent based systems broad-ranging principles often arise after-the-fact based on earlier, narrower-held opinions.