4 ms·
I can’t help but feel like we are on the verge of a new audiovisual era, one in which long paragraphs of text are almost never seen in any marketing context and
by keiferski 7y ago
I can’t help but feel like we are on the verge of a new audiovisual era, one in which long paragraphs of text are almost never seen in any marketing context and eventually in most contexts.
The initial reaction of most educated people is probably horror at our new illiterati leaders, but in an attempt to be optimistic, I’d note that the widespread dominance of writing is something of a material historical accident. Languages were originally spoken, not written. It’s been suggested that the semi-mythical Homer was specifically depicted as blind in order to emphasize that poetry is an aural art, not a visual (textual) one. If somehow audio recording devices had been invented prior to paper, I think we’d be living in a far different society, one filled with audio recordings rather than books.
So, knowing this, the challenge is to adapt to this new reality and form of communication and learn how to utilize it to achieve the level of depth seen in literature. I’m fairly confident we’ll get there eventually: the art of writing has been around for thousands of years, whereas video/film (moving images) is barely over a century old. We’ve got time to master it.
- julienfr112 7y agoHecker news would be audio only, and we would develop the ability to fast listen multiple accelerated audio at the same time like we can just read parts of the post and move on ?
- keiferski 7y agoSeems plausible. I am imagining a voice that reads all the submitted link titles and then lets you choose one and go to the link or listen to the comments. Having comments be actual recordings of the commenter's speech would actually be quite interesting and more personal than reading them in the fairly generic text form.
- mgummelt 7y agoText is much easier to skim than audio. Visual bandwidth is higher than auditory (though less so for communicating emotions), and the receiver has much more control over the cursor. Audio has some advantages, but it's limited.
- scollet 7y agoIntelligent audio communication is often more concise than its equal sum of text. Spoken poetry like rap is a vector for expression that can convey cultural plights and experiences in a few words or sentences. Ideas are compressed through memetics and words can share dimensions across the scope of the song as well as the (+/-) zeitgeist.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoThe Internet has been (depressingly) post-literate for a while. I adore good English. IMO writing peaked in the middle of the last century. There are some beautifully literate, clean, elegant, but unpretentious books from that period. Like this one: https://www.amazon.com/Structures-Things-Dont-Fall-Down-ebook/dp/B009G1PHP2 https://www.amazon.com/Structures-Things-Dont-Fall-Down-eboo... Elegance and simplicity started to become rarer in the 70s, when writing became more about ego, forceful persuasion, and opinionation and less about communication. Then YouTube happened, and now we're in the hyper-emotive era of "Wassup fam?" and "Mash that Like button." And memes. Some of it is certainly entertaining - because it has to be. But it's not so good at sharing complex and nuanced world views. So I don't think we will get there, because moving pictures and sound are inherently not a literate medium. They can be a literary medium, but you get Maximum User Engagement™ with crude lowest-common-denominator content, and not with subtlety, difficulty, or complexity.
- keiferski 7y agoI don't really think you've understood my point. The art of writing is thousands of years old, whereas the use of audiovisual media is barely a century old. Widespread use and access to technology that lets you create audiovisual communication and share it is perhaps 15-20 years old. This is extremely recent, considering that spoken language (which became writing) was itself in development for hundreds of thousands of years. The first writing by cavemen was probably scribbles, too. I'd give video another thousand years before writing it off. And to be clear: I am a writer by profession myself. So I'm definitely on the side of "writing is important." I'm merely acknowledging that technology trends are changing.
- scollet 7y ago> Then YouTube happened, and now we're in the hyper-emotive era of "Wassup fam?" and "Mash that Like button." And memes. > ...crude lowest-common-denominator content, and not with subtlety, difficulty, or complexity. It goes beyond this. Grokking complex ideas through media goes well beyond text. Often times visual media can bridge cultural gaps and be a primer for learning a new language. Don't discount the platform with generalizations (which I understand you're not trying to do) about its content. I regularly subscribe to channels that communicate complex subtext under a veneer of sensationalism. Even your quoted language can have an ironic meta game that supports both mine and your arguments.