4 ms·
>What gives Google/YouTube the justification to silence them? The fact that it is their platform. >Fauci can defend himself, Fauci is a 79 year old man busy
by Barrin92 7y ago
>What gives Google/YouTube the justification to silence them?
The fact that it is their platform.
>Fauci can defend himself,
Fauci is a 79 year old man busy working 20 hours a day trying to stop more people from dying, he doesn't have the time to debunk garbage on the internet.
Youtube is completely within their rights to remove dangerous disinformation from their platform and I hope they take an agressive stance going forward.
- dapf 7y agoYouTube gets a tax exemption because it has "public forum" status, which puts some restrictions on them, basically they cannot censor anything they want, they must uphold free speech. So, they cannot have their cake and eat it. https://youtu.be/d6C6_NVj964 https://youtu.be/d6C6_NVj964
- snowwrestler 7y agoDo not believe everything you see on YouTube.
- iancarroll 7y agoYouTube is most certainly not tax exempt. Section 230 is about liability for user-generated content. And that video is a dubious interpretation of it, at best.
- thdrdt 7y agoI know it's their platform so they can do what they want. But why not show a warning like "the following content has false and dangerous information"? Now it is gone so it can't be discussed. And I also think you take away responsibility of the viewers if they don't need to be critical about any information.
- loceng 7y ago"And I also think you take away responsibility of the viewers if they don't need to be critical about any information." This is exactly the problem currently though - the general population doesn't have either the time or critical thinking developed to understand this. Daniel Schmachtenberger on Eric Weinstein's The Portal episode #27 said: “... and the most awesome thing of the current system [of suppressing unruly people] we don’t even have to deal with protestors with tear gas or bean bags or whatever mostly, because mostly addiction, and student debt, and information overwhelm and those things deal with the people adequately so they don’t actually understand enough or care enough or have the capacity to organize very meaningly." Eric replied: “We just legalize weed and make porn free and everyone’s de-motivated.." - timestamped link to talk https://youtu.be/_b4qKv1Ctv8?t=3780 https://youtu.be/_b4qKv1Ctv8?t=3780 - but I'd highly recommend watching the whole interview. The goal has to be getting the population healthy enough to be responsible and reasonable, rational enough, otherwise these hierarchal systems lead by people are guiding this like parents raise children until people are mature enough; the extreme of this would be CCP controlling China's population.
- skuthus 7y agoI think if you disagree with what they have done, you should express that fully and also stop using the platform in favor of others who share your views.
- thdrdt 7y agoWell I was just pointing out there are other options besides removing content.
- gccxsse 7y ago>dangerous disinformation What does this even mean?? Have we forgotten the importance of free speech?
- slenk 7y agoFree Speech allows you to say whatever you want, not guarantee you no repercussions. Besides, private businesses don't need to allow free speech...
- jonny_eh 7y ago> What does this even mean?? Misinformation that can lead people to doing dangerous things.
- djsumdog 7y agoThere was a time when saying black people where just as intelligent as white people was considered misinformation and a dangerous way to think. There was a time when many leaders considered homosexuality dangerous and magazines promoting homosexuality was misinformation. It's easy to say something is misinformation now, but the standard of truth does not come now, it comes 20 years from now when history judges this moment.
- washadjeffmad 7y agoYou've failed to justify your equivalence. How many neo-Nazis, homophobes, self-styled "truthers", and xenophobic racists came to their conclusions naturally, without any external guidance or rhetoric? We don't exist in a vacuum, and people are socialized into their beliefs. Either these doctors weren't given the faculties to distinguish fact from fiction in their education, they lack the mental and social capacities to protect themselves from falling for twisted logic and half-truths, or they're intentionally manipulating those vulnerable members of society for their own gain.
- philipov 7y agoBecause the constitutional amendments only place restrictions on the government, we don't get to have free speech if we rely on private platforms to be the primary means of political expression.
- lchills098 7y agoIf that’s the case, then 99% of all videos on MSNBC’s YouTube channel should be removed for misinformation. All they do is lie constantly about everything and you don’t ever see a single video of theirs removed like the physician’s video. And that’s hilarious that you think Fauci is trying to help this countryDo you not realize that Fauci is the one who sent a $3,700,000 grant to the lab in Wuhan to continue testing on this virus when our Dept of Homeland Security deemed it to much of a public health risk to keep testing on this virus in the US like Fauci and his team were doing under the Obama administration. If Fauci wouldn’t have outsourced the testing of this deadly contagious virus to China, maybe we wouldn’t be in this mess.
- shkkmo 7y ago> Do you not realize that Fauci is the one who sent a $3,700,000 grant to the lab in Wuhan to continue testing on this virus when our Dept of Homeland Security deemed it to much of a public health risk to keep testing on this virus in the US like Fauci and his team were doing under the Obama administration. If Fauci wouldn’t have outsourced the testing of this deadly contagious virus to China, maybe we wouldn’t be in this mess. Do you not realize how confused and misinformed you are on this topic? The 2014 ban was a ban of "Gain of Function" (GoF) research (i.e. research that deliberately makes a virus to virulent to study the possiblity for future mutations to cause an epidemic) on a number of diffurent corona and influenza viruses. It was not an overall ban on research into these viruses and was not specific to corona virus. [0] The 3.7M grant was not given to the labs in Wuhan. It was provided to the EcoHealth Alliance, the president of which says that while they had collaborated with the lab in Wuhan on research funded by a past grant, none of the 3.7M grant money went to the labs in Wuhan. Sure, he may be lying, but I'd like to see some evidence to back up that claim. [1] It is true that there isn't non-circumstantial evidence on if this covid outbreak started with a containment failure at a lab or jumped directly from bats (or possibly through an intermediate animal). However, the evidence against covid-19 being engineered (i.e. the result of GoF research) is more conclusive and getting stronger. [2] When US officials visited the lab in 2018, they noted the importance of the research given the labs findings (which showed that transmission from bats was easier than previously though) and recommended that the US pay more attention and provide support to the labs in Wuhan to help improve the management and safety of the labs (which they found concerningly lacking). [3] So, ironically, if the virus did escape from one of the Wuhan labs, it seems like our good way of reducing the risk of this mess would have been to provide funding and support for those labs when we were warned about the risks in 2018. [0] https://www.nature.com/news/us-suspends-risky-disease-research-1.16192 https://www.nature.com/news/us-suspends-risky-disease-resear... [1] https://www.politico.com/news/2020/04/27/trump-cuts-research-bat-human-virus-china-213076 https://www.politico.com/news/2020/04/27/trump-cuts-research... [2] https://www.forbes.com/sites/brucelee/2020/03/17/covid-19-coronavirus-did-not-come-from-a-lab-study-shows-natural-origins/#1a8e101b3728 https://www.forbes.com/sites/brucelee/2020/03/17/covid-19-co... [3] https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2020/04/14/state-department-cables-warned-safety-issues-wuhan-lab-studying-bat-coronaviruses/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2020/04/14/state-dep...
- heddon 7y agoYou make the excuse to remove the video with no actual proof that this is dangerous misinformation. In fact, YouTube, and the media are the real danger.The biggest threat to Americans in the history of all.