3 ms·
That was concerning, so I finished what I was doing, restarted in macOS Recovery by rebooting while holding down Command-R, launched Disk Utility, started First
by userbinator 7y ago
That was concerning, so I finished what I was doing, restarted in macOS Recovery by rebooting while holding down Command-R, launched Disk Utility, started First Aid, went to make dinner, and promptly forgot about it.
One thing I've learned over the years is that if you suspect a hardware failure, especially to the boot drive, there's a very good chance that a reboot is not going to succeed. As the article shows, the "true end" came not long after that. Good that he has backups, and that's probably why he could even forget about it.
The drive supposedly has 128 MB of cache memory, but it’s only 5400 rpm, and while its speed has never been a noticeable problem while making backups, it’s painful beyond belief to use as a boot drive. USB 3.0 might theoretically be capable of 625 MBps, but when I tested the drive in Blackmagic Speed Test, it averaged just 20–25 MBps for both read and write speeds.
Maybe SSDs have spoiled us, but I'm still surprised just how much disk activity newer OSes produce, especially upon boot; or perhaps it's just the non-default stuff loaded upon startup by apps, which can easily build up without affecting performance if you normally have an ultra-fast SSD. I know someone who used a regular USB flash drive (probably <10MB/s) with a "portable" copy of XP for several years as a basic minimal development environment, and it wasn't actually slower than a HDD of the time; in fact, it was quite responsive, probably due to the much better random read performance of flash vs. a spinning disk.
- tom_ 7y agoAt some point, I strongly suspect, Apple upgraded all their OS development employees to SSDs, and they just stopped caring about HD performance. I don't know when that was exactly. 9-10 years ago or thereabouts? I just quite distinctly remember the experience of upgrading the OS, and straight away finding that the boot time had gone from 15 seconds to 1 minute :( That was annoying back then, but I don't think it's a problem nowadays. Technology has moved on, just as it moved on from the floppy disk and the Pentium 3 and so on. If anything, mechanical hard drives are doing well to still be useful - the price/performance/capacity tradeoff remains decent! Just not decent enough to use one as your boot drive.
- bluedino 7y ago>> I tested the drive in Blackmagic Speed Test, it averaged just 20–25 MBps for both read and write speeds. I found this odd. My 2.5" Seagate and WD external USB 3.0 HDD will both run 120MBs+ using Black Magic. Not that it would be something you would want to use as an OS boot drive, you'd want the Samsung T5 SSD that the author ended up buying.