4 ms·
Believe it or not, there are people who don't drive, take long-distance buses, or buy guns, and therefore don't have valid photo ID. > Most states will issue a
by triceratops 7y ago
Believe it or not, there are people who don't drive, take long-distance buses, or buy guns, and therefore don't have valid photo ID.
> Most states will issue an ID card good for 4-7 years for a very minimal cost
It's not just the cost of the license. There's also the opportunity cost of going to the DMV and potentially spending all day in line, which can mean missed work and lost wages, or childcare costs. And if you don't already have a driver's license and don't live someplace with good public transit, how are you going to get to the DMV in the first place?
> trickery of the individuals involved should not be used as a defense against the underlying concept.
Why not? If the intent is voter suppression rather than rooting out fraud (which hasn't been found to be widespread), then the crafting of the legislation would reflect that intent. A good voter ID bill would also mandate that the IDs are free and easy to obtain.
https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2017/12/12/16767426/alabama-voter-suppression-senate-moore-jones https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2017/12/12/16767426/...
https://www.vox.com/2020/4/15/21222084/kentucky-voter-id-coronavirus-pandemic https://www.vox.com/2020/4/15/21222084/kentucky-voter-id-cor...
- giantg2 7y agoSo just because they don't exercise those privileges/rights means they should be legally barred from doing so? If that is a valid argument, then you could use that same line of thinking against your position to say that who people who haven't voted impacted by the voter ID laws. Sure, there's opportunity cost to everything. Take the kid with you. What do you suggest we do about it? And not just on this issue, but filing taxes, marriage licenses, etc. If you think we should hold the actions of a few bad people as parts of debates, then I don't think I should pay taxes because of misappropriation, or because criminals use them to travel. Again, (because I don't think you got it) my position is that I don't see the issue with requiring photo ID because it is required for many other aspects of life, including other rights. The law should be congruent in that respect. If there are implemetion issues, then that is a different story. If you wanted to advocate the removal of ID requirements in other areas of life, then I'd be open to that too.
- triceratops 7y agoI'm not against the idea of voter ID. But a well-intentioned voter ID law would make ID easier and cheaper to obtain. It would set up ID registration at banks, post offices, libraries, courthouses, city halls, senior centers, college campuses, churches or other religious/community centers, workplaces, school gyms, supermarkets and convenience stores, gas stations. Make it as easy as buying Girl Scout cookies. Heck, let Girl and Boy Scouts get merit badges for volunteering to take pictures - with adult supervision even a 10-year-old can handle a camera well enough to take an ID picture. Maybe even have a person who comes to your door to take your picture, if you're physically disabled - contract it out to Uber or something. > Sure, there's opportunity cost to everything. What do you suggest we do about it? When it comes to voter ID...reduce it? Make it as close to zero as possible? Is that really so crazy? If we care about free, fair, and secure elections, they're worth investing in, right? > And not just on this issue, but filing taxes, marriage licenses, etc. Ditto. Tax filing shouldn't cost hundreds of dollars and hours of work.
- karatestomp 7y agoIn this case a common Republican position is that voter fraud is a big problem worth devoting serious resources to, and that a good solution to that problem is a voter ID program, and (leaving the Republican position now) very clearly the best and fairest solution for that is just to issue an official ID for every citizen (and god knows that'd make a ton of other stuff less prone to problems/fraud, more convenient to citizens, and cheaper), but they also really don't want a citizen ID program, so even if they were well-intentioned in their calls for voter ID they'd end up coming off as incoherent and disingenuous once you put those two positions together. And that's if.
- giantg2 7y agoYou mention having that service at many places, including sending individuals to homes. What about that opportunity cost? You could use that budget for other community services. With voting as a part of your civic duty, one should be willing to incur small costs like spending a day getting a license every 4-7 years. My experiences have been fairly convenient, much better than other government agencies like the sheriff's office, county treasurer, etc. It should be seen as a service to their fellow citizens of not having to pay another government employee salary, benefits, and retirement. The DMV handles the same ID services for drivers licenses, so they are a logical choice to be efficient (if there are no political games with availability). I was going for a more general approach to reducing opportunity cost. What about the opportunity cost of reducing this opportunity cost? It's a tradeoff for what to tackle. Should we spend effort and money here, or on education, etc. I'd rather they just modernization the process or address the tax situation. Yep, thanks to turbotax etc lobbyists.