12 ms·
Zoom 5.0
- dddddaviddddd 7y agoMost dystopic feature: > Audio Watermarks: Turn this on to embed a user's personal information into the audio as an inaudible watermark if they record during a meeting. If the audio file is shared without permission, Zoom can help identify which participant recorded the meeting.
- elldoubleyew 7y agoI wonder how they are doing this. Wouldn't a low quality recording render this fingerprint invisible?
- diebeforei485 7y agoI'd love to see some analysis of what's going on as well. I assume this would work better for audio recorded on-device (eg. using screen capture software) than audio recorded externally after being played out on the speaker.
- grenoire 7y agoI wonder if it can be filtered out, on the other hand. Does anybody have knowledge on audio fingerprinting/watermarking? Or is it perhaps security theater?
- jcelerier 7y agomost common technique is a spectral encoding, which can be quite resistant to degradation. here's some old (ugly) code - quite short as you can see: - encoding: https://github.com/jcelerier/libaudiotool/blob/master/src/libwatermark/watermark/SSWEncode.h#L43 https://github.com/jcelerier/libaudiotool/blob/master/src/li... - decoding: https://github.com/jcelerier/libaudiotool/blob/master/src/libwatermark/watermark/SSWDecode.h#L46 https://github.com/jcelerier/libaudiotool/blob/master/src/li...
- banger180 7y agoMy Guess is that it is mostly a security through obscurity thing for now, we do not know exactly how they mark the audio. When someone figures this out I believe that it should be possible to filter this out. It would be interesting if they found a way to watermark the audio in such a way that removing the mark makes the audio unusable.
- slezyr 7y agoJust compare two records from two different users.
- eigenvector 7y agoIf the watermark is inaudible, can't it removed by re-encoding the audio with a bandpass filter tuned for audible range?
- ithkuil 7y agoInaudible just means that a person can't perceive it, not necessarily because it's outside the frequency range a human ear can sense. A common technique is to add pseudo noise to encode data over the whole audio spectrum. It's related to the spread spectrum techniques used for radio communications resistant to signal degradation (natural or jamming), common in many radio protocols, like your GPS receiver in your phone. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Audio_watermark https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Audio_watermark
- lozf 7y agoStreaming and downloaded audio from Universal Music Group, and some Sony releases has been "inaudibly watermarked" for some years now, but there are several cases of people complaining that the watermark is actually audible in their supposedly lossless FLAC/ALAC/WAV download. AFAIK these are just used to identify the streaming / download source (e.g. Spotify / TIDAL / Qobuz etc.), rather than the individual user as will be the case with Zoom. It'll be interesting to see what, if anything, has changed with the technology.
- logicandreason 7y ago*help identify the participant's account, but not the actual participant.
- qubex 7y agoThat’s not much of a leap, though: if you know you were talking to some people, and then audio is leaked, then you can figure out which account did it. I’m not defending (or denouncing, for that matter) this feature, though I have opinions.
- WhyNotHugo 7y agoI guess this is targeted at corporate users. If a watermarked audio is leaked, the owner of the account will be liable. If he shared he's zoom credentials, is just as bad as sharing the recording.
- ktpsns 7y agoThis is really a terrible feature for anybody who doesn't like DRM. I only can hope clever hackers will identify these steganographic features in video and audio recordings of zoom sessions.
- ilogik 7y agowhat does this have to do with DRM?
- crazygringo 7y agoWhat's dystopic about it? Movie studios have done watermarking in the past with DVD screeners. Color laser printers output almost-invible patterns of yellow dots to match a document to a printer. When you download an academic paper as PDF, the PDF generally imprints the IP address and time of the downloader. Watermarking is nothing new. For a company or government worried about employees leaking sensitive information to the press, this is an intriguing feature. And if you're a determined whistleblower, this isn't going to stop you anyways.
- Awtem 7y agoAttention tracking ... Oh great... I'm sure we all have been waiting for more big brother features like this one
- ArlenBales 7y agoMany game developers do this for any kind of NDA-enforced testing. Not necessarily to the audio but to the video.
- madeofpalk 7y agoApple Retail has/had an internal communications iPad app called RetailMe that overlayed their employee number in a massive watermark on the screen to capture people to leak screenshots. It was slightly visible under normal use, but load it into photoshop and play with the curves and becomes super visible. One day there was an Ars Technica article leaking some news, included a screenshot of RetailMe. I put the screenshot into Photoshop and low and behold there was the employee's ID.
- renewiltord 7y agoThis is a fantastic feature. It isn't so much for the company to prevent it but a way for the guy being pressured to share the recording to say "I'm sorry, I can't. They embed details in it that if they were leaked would ruin me." i.e. technology that allows you to say no to things is great. The most extreme example is a secret that if I shared with you, I'd die painfully. You can't threaten me with death or torture because that's what's going to happen to me if I share it with you.
- JadeNB 7y ago> The most extreme example is a secret that if I shared with you, I'd die painfully. You can't threaten me with death or torture because that's what's going to happen to me if I share it with you. I say this regretfully because I really like the slogan "technology that allows you to say no to things is great", and, of course, it's not what you meant; but, taken to its extreme, the combination of this paragraph with the logic from your first paragraph: > This is a fantastic feature … technology that allows you to say no to things is great. means that an imaginary Zoom feature by which it would kill you painfully if you leaked sensitive data would be fantastic.
- renewiltord 7y agoHaha, right, that is the natural syllogism that one would arrive at. The missing pieces of the picture are the prior probabilities of accidental leaking vs. coerced leaking and the value of the individual. For a spy in danger of being exposed, yes, technology which guaranteed violent death on exposure would be fantastically desirable. I won't condescend to you by walking through the entire thing, but I think you can tell I'm not an extremist and have left out all the bits about the ROI etc.
- hootguy 7y agov6?
- MR4D 7y agoFor companies in healthcare and finance, this is a good feature to protect clients.
- derision 7y agoPrinters have done this for decades
- vikramkr 7y agoDystopic? That's a privacy forward feature. Accountability to protect the privacy of meetings.
- robbyt 7y agoApply some time stretch, pitch shift, slight distortion, and the watermark is likely destroyed.
- BrowserMeeting 7y agoSome of these features sound like anti-security and definitely anti-privacy features. Will definitely make you think twice about having a “private” meeting on Zoom if they’re going to embed my email on a screenshot someone else takes. Great way to get a meeting organizers email... > Screen Share Watermark Superimposes the image of a meeting participant’s email address onto shared content in the event a participant takes a screenshot.
- mft_ 7y agoIsn’t the point that it embeds your email address onto screenshots you take?
- WhyNotHugo 7y agoI wonder how zoom determines if a screenshot is taken. On Linux/Wayland at least, there's no API for an app to determine that this is happening. So they'd have to show the watermark all the time.
- diebeforei485 7y agoLikely by detecting certain keystrokes (that's what Snapchat does on iOS for example). Idk if there are other ways on macOS or Windows.
- WhyNotHugo 7y agoDefinitely not on Linux. Global hotkeys are managed by the compositor and can't be spied on by applications. There's also no API no read keystrokes from external apps. This is actually a security feature. AFAIK, on iOS, the app is actually sent an event by the OS when a screenshot is captured.
- kbr2000 7y agoYou might be specifically talking about Wayland here then, but with X on the other hand, it's not difficult for example [0] [0] https://security.stackexchange.com/questions/170596/is-it-possible-to-do-exploit-free-linux-keylogging-with-non-root-client-only-x-w https://security.stackexchange.com/questions/170596/is-it-po...
- diebeforei485 7y agoStill no Mac App Store version? Sigh...
- welder 7y agoProbably due to the Apple tax.
- diebeforei485 7y agoTheir macOS app is already notarized by Apple, there is no additional "Apple tax" for them to make a Mac App Store version.
- saagarjha 7y agoNo, it's probably because then the app would need to be sandboxed and they wouldn't be able to justify their insane Hardened Runtime exemptions.
- jxy 7y agoSince they are already on iOS, this is not an excuse. I would only trust a sandboxed version from them.
- rstupek 7y agoApple tax on free?
- asdff 7y agoThere is a mac version, why do you require it from the mac app store instead of the developer's site?
- glogla 7y agoBecause the non-app store version does weird stuff - faking installation, background services, etc. Sandboxed version would hopefully be less malware-like.
- romantomjak 7y ago
- judge2020 7y agoThankfully the major version update doesn't mean a completely new UI, which would have cut their userbase in half.
- fossuser 7y agoLooks like a good update and they're moving in the right direction. I think this should fix the main issues people have had with them (at least the most public problem with 'zoom bombing'). There's not much they can do about having all their development in China, but at least their focus on security otherwise seems to be paying off. ### Quick Feature Summary: - Mandatory GCM encryption requires Zoom clients to upgrade to 5.0 by May 30th [0] - Hosts can prevent screenshare, chat, user renaming - Hosts can report users to Zoom’s Trust & Safety team, who will review any potential misuse of the platform and take appropriate action. - All hosts may now turn on the Waiting Rooms while their meeting is already in progress. - Lock your meeting after everyone has arrived to prevent any unwanted disruptions. - The host may remove a participant and they will be unable to re-enter the meeting. - Waiting Room enabled by default - Complex Meeting IDs - Meeting passwords are now more complex and enabled by default - Meeting Registration and Authentication (require email registration/restrict meetings to preset profiles) - All cloud recordings are encrypted with complex passwords on by default. - Audio Watermarks/Screen Share Watermark (help prevent leaks) - Message Preview Options (Users can now enable Zoom Chat notifications to not show chat content while screen sharing.) - Host or account admin can disable the ability for participants to show their profile picture or change it in a meeting. - Hosts can now select which data center regions they would like their in-meeting traffic to use when scheduling a meeting, and participants can see which data center they are connected to by clicking on the info icon at the top left of the client window. - Zoom 5.0 supports a new data structure for larger organizations, allowing them to link contacts across multiple accounts so people can easily and securely search and find meetings, chat, and phone contacts. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galois/Counter_Mode https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galois/Counter_Mode
- beefee 7y ago> There's not much they can do about having all their development in China, but at least their focus on security otherwise seems to be paying off. They could start moving their development to the US. There are plenty of successful software companies in the US. There's a good ecosystem, a huge amount of talent, and tons of enthusiasm about their problem space. What they can't do anything about is the trust they lost by misleading their customers about their security model.
- SlowRobotAhead 7y agoReal end to end encryption? No? Must be a hard problem that other people have solved.
- thekyle 7y agoTo my knowledge there is no zoom competitor that has end to end encryption and allows people to join a call from landlines.
- jxy 7y agobluejeans? Skype for business? Webex?
- cbm-vic-20 7y agoHow are they encrypting the telephone connections?
- bearcobra 7y agoAll those services don't encrypt connections if they include PTSN phone calls or other features. Example: https://help.webex.com/en-us/WBX44739/What-Does-End-to-End-Encryption-Do https://help.webex.com/en-us/WBX44739/What-Does-End-to-End-E...
- bscphil 7y agoAre there services that have opportunistic end-to-end encryption that is only disabled if someone is calling in from a landline? That seems vastly superior.
- sinatra 7y agoCan Zoom stop logging me out from current computer (while I'm using Zoom) just because there's another computer on standby where I forgot to log off Zoom (and I'm not in any Zoom call on that computer)?
- skinnymuch 7y agoHah finally a criticism for Zoom I can immediately relate to and is really frustrating. Why log me out like you said if I’m not in a call.
- andruby 7y agoWhy are they touting "GCM encryption" without explaining what that means? Do they mean "Galois/Counter Mode" [0]? If so, _why_ is that better than the encryption they were using before? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galois/Counter_Mode https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galois/Counter_Mode
- jsmith12673 7y agoThey were using ECB mode before
- j7ake 7y agoThere was discussion before that Zoom had serious security issues. Have these been fixed in the new version of zoom ? Eg would companies that previously banned zoom now allow zoom 5.0? Eg some previous issues with zoom https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22736608 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22736608
- ralusek 7y agoWhy don't people just use Hangouts/Google Meet. I get so enraged when I see a meeting with Zoom or Ringcentral or Free conference call. Just click the fucking Hangouts link or call in. Don't have to download an application, just join. You're also very likely using Google mail and calendar.
- ricefield 7y agoI use Google Meet every day and it's a pretty terrible experience. Lots of lag and audio/video distortion. Meanwhile, Zoom works pretty seamlessly for me, always.
- fossuser 7y agoVideo and audio quality in hangouts is terrible, it also doesn’t support gallery view so groups larger than 2 are a lot worse than zoom for that reason alone. You also do need gmail, an app, and to have it enabled. Zoom is in a class of its own in terms of actual call quality and UX, it’s a lot better.
- fock 7y agoso, do you mind telling me, how I can get this fantastic video quality. Since we (university) don't want to share our whole desktop (and some are using Windows, so xephyr is out as well), a lot of people got OBS+some virtual webcam. Now, I spotlight my video, it's okish on my screen and the receivers get garbage with nonlegible text, doing a live-coding demo is basically impossible (the same with math-heavy slides). Works as expected in Jitsi though (but everyone needs chrome there for it to work - or the app. But who uses the jitsi-app...). So: can you tell me, what I'm doing wrong and how I can get this fantastic video quality of Zoom every shill is writing about?
- tobyhede 7y agoYou don't have to share the whole desktop on zoom. You can share single apps or even windows of an app. Use it all the time and it is flawless. I am unsure what OBS is but it sounds like you're recording your screen via webcam and then streaming that ... My guess is the compression on talking heads is aggressive and has a different profile to a screenshare.
- fidla 7y agoI'm very concerned about the China connection. there has been zero analysis of what they actually look at and how they use the data
- Awtem 7y agoAccording to their 10-K filings, zoom has more than 700 heads in RnD in China, and about 5 subsidiaries in China IIRC, but none of those are listed as subprocessors of personal data, which I, personally, find somewhat hard to believe
- ponsin 7y agoA few weeks ago they required login to join a meeting from the browser. This make it harder for older people who I like to talk to. Since then I have moved to jit.si . The quality is slightly lower, but it is much easier to use
- skinnymuch 7y agoJitsi is much worse in a number of ways. If you use it casually with small crowds then it’s prob fine. Otherwise the pains of Jitsi are huge for the year I had to use it a lot.
- dybber 7y agoNice to see all the security improvements, however, the new UI seems less crisp, the fonts have become much more blurry, with too much anti-aliasing going on. Also the up-arrows for audio/video settings have been made much smaller and thus harder to hit - you will mute yourself rather than opening the audio settings.
- dybber 7y agoThe font smoothing/antialiasing problem is not everywhere, which makes it look even weirder. See this dialog for instance: https://i.imgur.com/L5S8Tqn.png https://i.imgur.com/L5S8Tqn.png Where the text "0 participants per room" have been applied too much anti-aliasing.
- ojilles 7y ago"How was your experience?" [Great] / [Had issues] So infuriating. And yes it disappears by itself after a while, but no, I do not need that dialog box. Anyone know how to turn that off?
- JadeNB 7y agoIt's a setting that's exposed on the website ("Feedback to Zoom"), but, at least for my licence, it's locked. Incidentally, I am able to close the box, rather than just waiting for it to go away, in case that's better.
- dreamercz 7y agoI was hoping a new major version would help me fix the problem I have with the Zoom desktop application on Xubuntu. Every time I join a meeting, the entire desktop start lagging. Sadly, this update did not help.
- jedisct1 7y ago"GCM encryption". What? o_O
- terrywang 7y agoNot a security expert but deal with PKI (openssl, openssh, etc) / OpenGPG/GnuPG a lot on a daily basis, I just don't understand why Zoom would let their marketing people put buzzword like `GCM Encryption` on such an important landing page, not nitpicking, seriously... At least, use AES-256 (mode can be optional as most people don't even know what GCM XTS CBC stands for).
- DonHopkins 7y agoBecause focus groups liked the sound of "GCM Encryption". Be glad they didn't slap on a bunch of Trim Level Designators like "GCM LX Sport Encryption CE". https://www.liveabout.com/glx-gls-se-si-lx-what-do-they-mean-4083747 https://www.liveabout.com/glx-gls-se-si-lx-what-do-they-mean... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trim_level_(automobile) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trim_level_(automobile)
- tatersolid 7y agoI think because the big failing before was that Zoom was using AES, but was using it in ECB mode. Zoom clearly paid near-zero attention to security until recently. So by saying “GCM encryption” they’re highlighting that the fixed the mode by which they are using AES encryption.