3 ms·
You would have to decide on a process for senators to formally register their votes remotely, and that process would have to be one that could not be hacked eve
by lisper 7y ago
You would have to decide on a process for senators to formally register their votes remotely, and that process would have to be one that could not be hacked even by a state actor because the stakes are incredibly high. That is a tall order even for a group of technically competent people, and the U.S. Senate is not generally known for its technical competence.
- smt88 7y agoThere are only 100 senators, and lots of people track their votes. A senator logging a surprising vote would be asked about it and able to correct the record. Hacking a senate vote wouldn't be much use in the long run.
- ufo 7y agoExactly. Remote voting is easier when the votes don't need to be secret.
- lisper 7y agoThat is far from clear. Imagine that the famous vote on repealing Obamacare had been done remotely and someone had hacked John McCain's famous thumbs-down vote to be a vote in favor of repeal. Imagine further that before the matter could be clarified with McCain, he had become incapacitated and died. That is a plausible scenario. It only takes one hack at the margins to change the course of history.
- smt88 7y ago> * Imagine that the famous vote on repealing Obamacare had been done remotely and someone had hacked John McCain's famous thumbs-down vote to be a vote in favor of repeal.* It would've been corrected in minutes. McCain knew he was the deciding vote and the media firesform would've alerted him to an incorrect vote almost immediately. All of these people have large teams monitoring their coverage and managing their PR. A voting mistake would be caught.
- pwinnski 7y agoAnd yet the Senate still often takes votes by voice, where precise counts aren't even logged. Registry of votes seems easy enough. If there's ever a question or a surprising vote, ask again. As-is, senators regularly vote by means of hand-waving and thumbs up/down gestures, so it's not like things are always super-formal even before this change.
- lisper 7y agoYes, that's true. But when a senator is on the Senate floor there is no doubt about his or her identity. How are you going to insure that the person registering a vote remotely is in fact the senator and not someone posing as the senator? Yes, there are ways to solve this problem, but they are not trivial.