2 ms·
False dichotomy: you can do both of course. And in my state, a food producing state, the food banks sell off their excess inventory to anybody willing to pay d
by JoeAltmaier 7y ago
False dichotomy: you can do both of course.
And in my state, a food producing state, the food banks sell off their excess inventory to anybody willing to pay dime on the dollar (Scout events, festivals etc) because cash is more useful to them.
Never mind noble; it can be selfish to wish a favorite restaurant stays in business. Discretionary income is exactly that, to be spent at your own discretion.
We could all quit restaurants entirely and spend every waking moment collecting and donating to food banks etc. But we don't. It's not essentially different from the previous comment (false dichotomy) to say that. And of course we don't do either one.
- dangus 7y agoThe food bank thing is just an example. It’s an example of something worth donating to: a non-profit charity organization that can redirect funds to help people in some way. So yes, you can do both things. You can donate to whatever you want. My whole argument here is that donating to a for-profit business is never noble and never logical. If you give money to a for-profit entity you should either receive a product, service, or ownership stake in return. Again, my whole argument is that this crisis has made many people in an act of group-think start considering donating to for profit entities, especially ones that frequently churn in the first place, to be a desirable action. It’s not, full stop. Nobody should do it. Another example: my gym has an option to continue paying dues to support their “employee relief fund.” But the owners of the gym administer this fund. How do I know it won’t be used for profit? It’s not a 503(c) organization. The owners could just keep 90% of it and give 10% to the employees and that would be perfectly legal. So it’s the same thing with all of these hastily-arranged informal restaurant/bar donation funds. There’s no oversight, there’s often not even an official organization that’s behind them.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoI patronize three small mon-and-pop restaurants. I'm supporting my neighbors. Where does that fit in this utilitarian view?
- dangus 7y agoIt completely fits in. You wouldn't patronize your mom-and-pop restaurants if they burned your food or charged $30 for a box of Kraft Macaroni and Cheese. You also say the word "patronize" which means you receive a service or good in return for your payment.