6 ms·
The lack of effort here seems like such a strategic mistake for Google... For this to work, it has to be single click, it has to be slick, it has to 'just work
by londons_explore 7y ago
The lack of effort here seems like such a strategic mistake for Google...
For this to work, it has to be single click, it has to be slick, it has to 'just work', it has to integrate with otp's, security keys, SMS 2 factor, etc.
It should be for both work accounts and home accounts, and Google should have come up with a strategic set of default options. Those options should have included "just log me in with a low privilege account which can browse the web like chromeOS, but still syncs everything like chromeOS".
I put the failure of realising this vision mostly due to lack of inter-department communication within Google. This is a direct (yet years late) response to active directory logins for GSuite, when it should additionally have been shipped for home users and marketed as a "do anything from anywhere any time" thing.
- pjc50 7y agoHow much of that is actually possible within the windows third-party authentication framework?
- londons_explore 7y agoThe authentication provider runs as a highly trusted account, it can do anything it likes. The only tricky bit would be not opening massive security holes. After all, a regular windows box you can't do anything at all with without a password. With my proposed solution, you'd be able to log in and browse the web with just any old random gmail password. Thats a massive increase in attack surface - now any buggy printer driver or router web interface is suddenly open to attack by anyone with access to the screen and keyboard.
- monocasa 7y agoAuthentication providers are a huge pain for modern software security unfortunately since updates mandate that the system has to be restarted (they're only loaded at boot).
- buro9 7y agoKinda agree. But then they failed to make the "One account all of Google" true of Gmail and Gsuite accounts (there's a long list of things you can do with one account that you cannot do with the other, and this is with Google products and features). So it doesn't feel suprising that Google lacked the organisational-wide impetus to get this working fully for Windows and Microsoft products and features. These kinds of projects need to be driven with very strong vision from above. It makes me think of the Yegge rant about platforms at Google, and the mentioning of the Bezos mandate on APIs https://gist.github.com/chitchcock/1281611 https://gist.github.com/chitchcock/1281611 His Big Mandate went something along these lines: 1. All teams will henceforth expose their data and functionality through service interfaces. 2. Teams must communicate with each other through these interfaces. 3. There will be no other form of interprocess communication allowed: no direct linking, no direct reads of another team's data store, no shared-memory model, no back-doors whatsoever. The only communication allowed is via service interface calls over the network. 4. It doesn't matter what technology they use. HTTP, Corba, Pubsub, custom protocols -- doesn't matter. Bezos doesn't care. 5. All service interfaces, without exception, must be designed from the ground up to be externalizable. That is to say, the team must plan and design to be able to expose the interface to developers in the outside world. No exceptions. 6. Anyone who doesn't do this will be fired. 7. Thank you; have a nice day! When it comes to making the experience right for Google accounts (of any type, anywhere)... this is what it takes. But this is precisely Yegge's rant, Google lack this.
- izacus 7y ago> But then they failed to make the "One account all of Google" true of Gmail and Gsuite accounts (there's a long list of things you can do with one account that you cannot do with the other, and this is with Google products and features). The clients of GSuite explicitly do not want any of that - even more, they (and the media and HackerNews) is very vocal that GSuite data should never be merged or touch the GMail account data, ML advertising systems and other non-enterprise data. Did you consider that perhaps you're not the target market for these kind of features? It is an Enterprise cloud system after all. (The arbitrary GSuite limitations are pissing me off as well though.)
- discordance 7y agoPretty shoddy indeed. Makes me shiver to know the Googlers behind this are getting paid somewhere between 250-500k/year