4 ms·
> In my opinion, we stay locked down until healthcare workers have what they need even if a gigantic wave hits. Do you think that's practical? This virus has a
by taneq 7y ago
> In my opinion, we stay locked down until healthcare workers have what they need even if a gigantic wave hits.
Do you think that's practical? This virus has a hospitalisation rate of somewhere between 10% and 20% and an ICU rate of 4-10%, and people who are hospitalised need to be in there for 2-4 weeks. If a 'gigantic wave' is even 10% of your population (which realistically it would far exceed, given how contagious the virus is) you need 10-20 free hospital beds per 1000 population of which 4-10 are ICU beds.
The United States has 800k hospital beds of which ~100k are ICU beds, for a population of 330 million (source: https://www.aha.org/statistics/fast-facts-us-hospitals https://www.aha.org/statistics/fast-facts-us-hospitals) That's 2.4 hospital beds per 1000 population, of which 0.3 are ICU beds.
You're gonna need at least 10x as many additional beds as you currently have. At least. And that's for only 10% of your population getting sick.
Edit: To be clear, I'm not saying that lockdowns are pointless. I'm saying that they need to be longer and more thorough to get to the point where the virus is entirely eliminated, or they need to remain at current levels indefinitely until an effective vaccine or other treatment is available.
- argonaut 7y ago> This virus has a hospitalisation rate of somewhere between 10% and 20% and an ICU rate of 4-10% Part of the reason there is even a debate is because we don't know this for sure.
- taneq 7y agoI've seen a lot of discussion about a "submerged iceberg" population of asymptomatic or lightly symptomatic infections that haven't been picked up by testing, but IMO this doesn't pass the sniff test when considering populations like Australia / NZ / South Korea. Any such population should cause a steady stream of serious cases popping up that can't be traced back to known sources, along with random community testing seeing an unexpectedly high positive rate. We're seeing no such thing. The few studies where a large population was tested and shown to be widely infected but largely asymptomatic seem to fall into one of two camps: They used immunological tests (which are now under serious suspicion don't seem reliable) or they tested a newly infected population after the first cases were found (before the majority of infections had time to manifest symptoms.) They've also been reported misleadingly (eg. the aircraft carrier case where it was reported "80% of the crew were infected but asymptomatic" when actually 80% of the crew who tested positive were asymptomatic.)
- argonaut 7y agoI'm also not asserting we know for sure that there is a 20-50x (or something along those lines) undercount in cases. Just that there is a huge amount of uncertainty with IFR and hospitalization rates, and none of your points really rule out that uncertainty.
- taneq 7y agoAlso true, and there's a chance I'm wrong and most people have already had a mild version and everything will be fine. There's enough evidence suggesting that the rates of severe complications and death are far higher than we're comfortable with, though, that I, for one, would prefer to err on the side of caution rather than run with "well, it might not kill 10% or more of the population."
- rusticpenn 7y agoThe goal of lockdown in Germany is to get herd immunity in a controlled way ( over a longer period of time, without stressing our healthcare etc)
- taneq 7y agoWhat's their estimate of the period of time required to do this?
- rusticpenn 7y agoNo real estimates. The number of hospital and ICU beds are being increased rapidly. Medical students are now allowed to work with patients until the crisis passes ( thus increasing the healthcare capacity). After carefuly observation the plan is to slowly reduce the stringent lock down measures and increase the infection rate, while keeping the medical staff sane. We will get the next update in the first week of may, whether the first step of "easing" worked as intended.
- taneq 7y agoI'll be interested to see how it goes. Very early on (start of March) I did some calcs for Australia and basically estimated that we'd need to be in partial lockdown for something like a decade in order to not overwhelm the health system, even assuming a significant increase in hospital beds. The numbers are a little more favourable at this point though.
- rusticpenn 7y agoThis is a major issue. Most of the Fair halls (like halls where CEBIT etc take place regularly) have been converted to hospitals now. Robert Koch Institute has asked all hospitals to build seperate wings for CoViD19 patients as the lung infections of those affected will also create after effects that will increase healthcare needs even after the disease is "eliminated". What we are going to see is a new normal, even if we find a working vaccination soon.
- pedrocr 7y ago> or they need to remain at current levels indefinitely until an effective vaccine or other treatment is available It isn't quite so bad. Lockdowns are a continuum of measures, and you can modulate them over time. We're having to do such strict lockdowns because we were so slow in responding. Once the R is below 1 you can release measures to keep it at that threshold and modulate it over time to match your health care capacity. Merkel seems particularly well informed about this, having even explained what the curve of healthcare capacity versus R looks like for Germany. This was a good discussion on this at the beginning of the lockdowns: https://medium.com/@tomaspueyo/coronavirus-the-hammer-and-the-dance-be9337092b56 https://medium.com/@tomaspueyo/coronavirus-the-hammer-and-th...
- taneq 7y agoOh definitely, once the number of infectious carriers is properly under control, lockdowns can be relaxed. I just meant we can't "go back to normal" until the virus is all but eradicated and no new unexplained cases are seen for at least a couple of weeks.
- pedrocr 7y agoIf you define "back to normal" as absolutely no restrictions sure. But there's a world of difference between being locked at home and having simple restrictions like no events with more than 50 people, and lower density seating at restaurants. The plan is to find a reasonable balance that's <10% of a full lockdown in terms of restriction and ride that while measuring evolution to tweak the measures. A simple control loop.
- bsder 7y ago> You're gonna need at least 10x as many additional beds as you currently have. At least. And that's for only 10% of your population getting sick. The problem is that even if we just fill the current beds we have, we STILL don't have enough equipment for the healthcare workers. This is a major problem. Especially so since we can substitute therapies. For example, apparently high-flow ventilation is just as good as invasive ventilation--and maybe better. The problem is that it aerosolizes the virus, so your workers need a lot more equipment. If you don't have enough equipment for the healthcare workers, things fall apart long before you reach available system capacity.