3 ms·
Sure, they are comparable. Maybe not 1 to 1, but you could make up some metric that evened things out a bit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quality-adjusted_lif
by maxerickson 7y ago
Sure, they are comparable. Maybe not 1 to 1, but you could make up some metric that evened things out a bit:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quality-adjusted_life_year https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quality-adjusted_life_year
(even if you don't agree with that metric, equivalence at some ratio is pretty clear, unless old people are just completely disposable)
At the moment it seems that individual susceptibility is a bigger factor than medical capacity, and we are researching dozens of possible treatments and working towards a vaccine. Makes it even harder to gauge the trade offs, as an effective treatment would pay big dividends when combined with a slowed spread.
I also wonder about attributing poverty deaths to economic shut downs. They are pretty preventable, and more a failure of our broader society than a result of the specific policy. The societal failure when it comes to suicide is less direct, but it's a factor there also.
- mewpmewp2 7y ago> I also wonder about attributing poverty deaths to economic shut downs. But this is always the case. If you can't solve this issue during normal times, how could you solve this issue during crisis? Force part of the society to pay more taxes during this time? There's certainly a lot of people dying all over the world due to poverty - these deaths could be prevented as well. Since there's less production things are probably even more scarce and expensive during crisis - if economy is shut down and people can't be productive. Regarding ethical/moral dilemmas, to me it seems like the trolley problem is definitely highlighted during this crisis (it to some extent exists also during normal times), but now it's extremely apparent in my opinion. Especially because also another question is very apparent - how valuable are different human lives? Loosening economy means less deaths within general population, while it means more deaths specifically for elderly. Loosening isn't binary either so there's a balanced line that you have to draw. So you have to draw that balance between somewhere where you have to weigh economic damage, young productive human lives vs lives that are about to end anyway. For instance. Would you save 20 people who were expected to live 1 year compared to a person who would go on to live 40 years? If we considered years and probably higher quality years it would be 40 > 20 however death count would be 1 < 20