4 ms·
I have not seen a single serious attempt to model quite how expensive they will be How about the fed's estimate of a ~5% hit to GDP in Q2. The economic ramifi
by refurb 7y ago
I have not seen a single serious attempt to model quite how expensive they will be
How about the fed's estimate of a ~5% hit to GDP in Q2.
The economic ramifications of the shelter-in-place are going to be massive.
- runako 7y agoFor those who don't have the numbers handy, US GDP is about $20T. If it were even spread out through the year (it is not), a 5% hit in Q2 would be $250 billion in that quarter.
- fspeech 7y agoYou blame the shelter-in-place order which actually improves over an uncoordinated economic shutdown that the epidemic is fully capable of generating on its own. You can't separate the effect of the shelter-in-place order from that of the viral epidemic. With a raging outbreak, even without a shelter-in-place order people will still not go to most businesses. You could have the same economic downturn without the benefit of a shelter-in-place order where people's actions are more coordinated. And this is without accounting for the cost of a possible social breakdown if enough people panic about not having fair access to healthcare when the hospitals are overwhelmed. If we could coordinate a perfect shelter-in-place the outbreak would have been gone by now. If people don't cooperate with each other we will have a much prolonged outbreak.
- thepope 7y agohmm, I'm OP and you might have a good point there. I will think about that. I'm not saying you are right ...lol btw i dont know why literally every single fucking thing i say on the internet no matter what always gets downvoted even when im talking about a neutral subject and being positive but where was i? oh yeah, I'm not saying your right but at first thought I think you are making a good point.
- afiori 7y agoregarding the downvotes I can share an opinion based on similar experiences: in my case it often was about not being thoughtful in choosing what to say. Or in another perspective think about whether your comment is what you feel like saying or whether it is something that contributes to the discussion.
- cycrutchfield 7y agoOn the other hand, what are the economic ramifications of no shelter-in-place during a global pandemic? Will people still be going to restaurants, movie theaters and malls?
- epistasis 7y agoOnly 5%? It seems like this should be much larger, especially to see the reactionary takes about opening the economy. Put that way, it's a hell of a deal. Killing off 1% of the population, plus the economic damage of nobody wanting to go out because of fear of getting sick, and that's unimaginably worse than 5% for a quarter, economically. Of course there are are likely to be knock on effects for several quarters, but given the typical lifespan of a human, we could go several years of 5% less GDP before it would equal the economic cost of the loss of life. Not to mention the social cost, which is hard to assign a value to. It makes me think of other comparisons. Imagine if we had terror attacks that killed 60,000 people a year if we worked to stop them, but several million people if we didn't work to stop them. How much did we decide to spend on wars in response to 9/11, and his manu soldiers of our own did we decide to kill in military actions, and how many foreign innocent civilians? It really puts 5% GDP into perspective, as almost a nothingness compared to what we willingly sacrificed in response to the last disaster, which had economic effects on top of that.
- jyounker 7y agoThe expected lifetime value of a 60 year old is around 5 million. So one million sixty years dying is a cost to the economy is about 5 * 10^12, or five trillion dollars. The US GDP is around 22 trillion a year. Therefore each million >=60 year olds saved is worth completely shutting down the US economy for around three months.
- afiori 7y agoI am always quite confused about these comparisons, as value is not money and it is unclear to me what is even bring talked about
- sershe 7y agoAnd where are those numbers coming from? 1) Taking this https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid19/index.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid19/index.htm and combining with SS Life Expectancy tables, the average years lost per death is ~12; that corresponds to the age of 72-73, not 60. 2) Even the most alarmist reports barely predicted million deaths in the worst case scenario. 3) How is lifetime value of 60 year old 5 million? Based on the same SS tables, that's for 21.5 years, so ~230k per year. Where is this number coming from? 3a) Using some objective standard like annual income, it would obviously be far lower. 3b) You can even use a personal take - would you rather have $5 million (translation: very safe ~$150-200k/year for life including childhood, so you never have to work while living an upper middle class lifestyle), and have a risk of death at 60 with a COVID probability for 60-year-old (~4% CFR or so, so lower IFR and even lower combined with non-100% infection rate), or have $0, live with a median job and income, and not have that risk? What about throwing out the "60-year-old" and taking the real average case, 72-73yo (with its increased CFR/IFR)? I'm pretty sure I'd roll that dice for as little as a $200-300k head start. 4) Moreover, disability adjusted life years and other similar metrics often (quite justifiably) weight later years of life lower than the earlier ones. Again, to make this more personal or less numeric, would you rather be paralyzed from neck down in your 30ies (and then remiss) or die at 80 instead of 85? I'd take dying earlier.
- sershe 7y agoUpdate: I double counted the probability in 3b, it should be guaranteed death if we are talking full amount of money. I'd still definitely take dying at 73 while starting with even ~$500-700k over average-job-income-expectancy life (a free house and a college degree, basically).
- microtherion 7y agoHow about the fed's estimate of a ~5% hit to GDP in Q2. That's true. This is a serious attempt to model, and I did in fact hear about it, now that you remind me.