3 ms·
> You cannot mitigate economic damage with fiscal or monetary means in any serious way. You kind of can. In a situation like this, you have a lot of people who
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> You cannot mitigate economic damage with fiscal or monetary means in any serious way.
You kind of can. In a situation like this, you have a lot of people who can't work because they're at home (or have no customers because their customers are at home), which causes two types of economic damage. One, the thing they were making is not being made. Two, they're not getting paid, so they're not buying what they would have bought with the money, and then that isn't getting made and so on down the line.
The second problem is actually bigger (because of "and so on down the line") but can be addressed entirely via fiscal means. Give people money to replace what they're not making.
And it even helps some with the first by increasing general demand. The things that are still open (e.g. because they're work from home) will then see increased business, have to hire more people to fill the demand and provide jobs for the people who can't do their normal jobs so they're still being productive.
Doing that is not going to eliminate the entire cost, but it is going to make it a lot smaller.
> It’s like trying to claim your company is growing because share buybacks made your per-share price go up, yet your market cap in an efficient market has been unchanged.
Buybacks actually reduce the market cap because there are fewer outstanding shares and the company has fewer total assets (in the amount of the cash used for the buyback which the company no longer has because it is now in the hands of the shareholders who sold their shares).
And doing that does tend to cause the overall economy to grow because it moves cash from a company that apparently had no need for it to investors who are incentivized to find somewhere else to put it to productive use.
This isn't to say that your overall conclusion is necessarily wrong. Even 10% of the cost of shutting down the whole world is large. But if you want to compare the numbers they should be the right numbers.
- mariodiana 7y ago> Give people money to replace what they're not making. Count yourself among those who do not understand the difference between money and wealth. What they're "not making" isn't money; what they're not making are goods or services. That's the point you're attempting to respond to, and you've missed the point.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThey are making stuff and making money. The money is often just as or more important because it is necessary to buy other stuff, particularly when "essential" things are still operating and "non-essential" things are shut down, because the people doing "non-essential" things still need money in order to buy "essential" things.
- __blockcipher__ 7y agoYou should read http://paulgraham.com/wealth.html http://paulgraham.com/wealth.html, particularly "The Pie Fallacy". Here's an excerpt: > What leads people astray here is the abstraction of money. Money is not wealth. It's just something we use to move wealth around.
- romwell 7y agoI see no problem in moving the wealth from those who have accumulated an obscene amount of it to those who need it to eat.
- __blockcipher__ 7y agoAgain, you are entirely missing the point. I'm not sure how, we've explained this now like 4 different times. Money is not wealth. You can play whatever games you want with redistributing the money, but without the wealth you have nothing to eat.