3 ms·
I'm not sure what I'm supposed to see in Table 2. I see more dead than Influenza. And that's despite most everything being closed. We don't close the country
by jedberg 7y ago
I'm not sure what I'm supposed to see in Table 2. I see more dead than Influenza. And that's despite most everything being closed. We don't close the country for influenza. So clearly this thing is way worse.
- eric_b 7y agoThanks for not even trying. What you should see if you open your eyes and your mind is that anyone under 54 is many times more likely to die from something else other than COVID. Surely even someone such as yourself could imagine a scenario where not EVERYONE needs to be locked down? Perhaps just those in the higher risk brackets?
- jedberg 7y agoThe elderly still need to interact with society. Infected but asymptotic people are even more dangerous to them, because they can still get infected. If the 22 year old check stand worker at the market goes to a bar and gets COVID-19 and then spreads it to the elderly patron they serve, that's bad. How can you protect against that? Also, they are now finding that COVID-19 causes strokes in young people. Those deaths were not counted as COVID related. We just have no idea how this virus works or what it does to the human body. Every health official says "stay home". I tend to agree with them. The solution is not to "open the economy", it's for the government to step in and help people. Why are we the only country that is begging to reopen? Perhaps it's our social safety net that needs reevaluation, not our lockdown.
- eric_b 7y agoThe faster the young and less vulnerable get the disease and get over it, the faster the older folks can be let out. It's really not complicated. This disease is too contagious to contain. The only way forward is through. Lockdowns merely delay the inevitable. Yes, some people will die. We can't stay home forever. It's not just the US that wants out, but you go on thinking like you do and enjoy your privileged bubble.
- sfkdjf9j3j 7y agoCan I suggest you remove the personal attacks from your comments in here? It's hard to read your argument in good faith when it's full of insults.
- jedberg 7y agoThere is no evidence that getting the disease prevents you from getting it again. Furthermore there are currently four known strains, so you’d have to get it four times if you even can get immunity.
- mikem170 7y ago>There is no evidence that getting the disease prevents you from getting it again It's normal for exposure to a coronavirus to confer a couple years of immunity. I've read that it would be typical for something like this to become endemic, decreasing in severity, possibly circulating as another one of several coronaviruses that already make up 15% of common colds.
- mikem170 7y ago>Why are we the only country that is begging to reopen? Because as time goes on we learn that the virus is not as bad as first feared. And more people are being negatively impacted by the varied costs of the lockdown. Do you think that a continued lockdown will have a significant effect on the final death rate from this disease? As long as the hospitals are not overwhelmed, what will be the difference in the end?
- bagacrap 7y agothe elderly need to interact with society, yet we currently live in a world where no one interacts with society?
- IIAOPSW 7y ago>What you should see if you open your eyes and your mind is that anyone under 54 is many times more likely to die from something else other than COVID. Table 2 is total deaths not the death rate. Pneumonia has killed more young people than corona because more people have gotten pneumonia than corona (so far).
- eric_b 7y agoOver the same time period. So it's about as apples to apples as you can get at this point. Also, you can calculate the death rate per million from the available chart data. This stuff really isn't that complicated...
- URSpider94 7y agoFirst of all, these are the deaths for other causes since early February, while the covid deaths are heavily back-loaded over the past three weeks. Second, these are the deaths WITH a nationwide shelter-in-place, if we had not done that, the deaths would be much higher. Third, the death rate for your average 30-year-old in the average week is pretty darned low, so this will indeed add to it. Fourth, what do you propose to do to keep Americans over 60 from dying when they catch covid from their live-in family members, their caregivers, or the clerk at the bank?