3 ms·
> I really don't understand why systemd seems to have provoked so much hate and controversy in the Linux world A few major reasons: * It's originally written
by jcranmer 7y ago
> I really don't understand why systemd seems to have provoked so much hate and controversy in the Linux world
A few major reasons:
* It's originally written by the person who also wrote Pulseaudio, so any vitriol people have left over from Pulseaudio's configuration issues gets poured into systemd as well.
* The project takes a monolithic approach to the problem of configuring services, and many people think that's wrong. [1]
* It's change, and change means work for people who have their old setups.
[1] This criticism is usually described as "it breaks the Unix model," a formulation I don't like because it's meaningless and an appeal to authority instead of articulating the issues they have with it. Watch how people try to explain how the similarly monolithic Linux kernel doesn't break the Unix model, it can be funny sometimes.
- kyuudou 7y ago> explain how the similarly monolithic Linux kernel doesn't break the Unix model It does one thing and one thing well: talk to hardware.
- tptacek 7y agoThen what, all the other things it does it does poorly?
- thu2111 7y agoRight, what does monolithic approach to configuring services even mean? I seem to have hundreds of systemd services on my box, all of which appear to do a tiny part of system startup. That doesn't come across as very monolithic, if anything service overload is one of the things I dislike about systemd (but it wasn't better previously).