4 ms·
The culture simply isn’t there anymore in any focused form. Reddit, HN or wherever probably isn’t comparable to having an entire empire’s brightest minds in the
by keiferski 7y ago
The culture simply isn’t there anymore in any focused form. Reddit, HN or wherever probably isn’t comparable to having an entire empire’s brightest minds in the same cafe on a daily basis.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Barrin92 7y agoI think that's mostly because today there are so many bright minds they don't fit in a coffee house. Go to the cafeteria of any large business or university and you'll probably find more highly educated people than you found in all of Vienna 150 years ago. I think what you're yearning for is really the bourgeois culture of high-minded intellectuals participating in exclusive clubs rather than facilitating good discourse between intelligent people. Access to the latter nowadays is thankfully much easier than it was in the past.
- ValentineC 7y agoI suspect that some of the posters in this thread are looking for a physical place to collaborate and share ideas, rather than just a bunch of bright minds in one venue. Please support your local third place, like a hackerspace or a non-profit community centre: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_place https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_place
- keiferski 7y ago> Go to the cafeteria of any large business or university and you'll probably find more highly educated people than you found in all of Vienna 150 years ago. Maybe, but those people aren’t really interacting with each other or sharing ideas in a way that isn’t aligned with their personal or professional goals. The cafe of yore was a melting pot of people and ideas; the contemporary cafeteria is far more functional and teleological. Maybe it was my fault by using the term ‘brightest minds’, but intelligence or education level is also not really the main draw. Certainly the revolutionary artists of the late 1800s weren’t the most academically educated ones.
- Xelbair 7y ago>Go to the cafeteria of any large business or university and you'll probably find more highly educated people than you found in all of Vienna 150 years ago. Highly ecudated != bright mind I think it is because nowadays you can communicate with other bright minds instantly, as long as you can find them in the mazes of the internet. Back then you had to be physically with them in the same space. Today you don't have that physical limitation. But to be honest, due to sheer curiosity - i would love to try such coffee house, but unless we discover a time machine i doubt it will ever happen.
- asdff 7y agoThere's a fallacy here. The only bright minds permitted in the imperial cafe of yore were those of the right ethnicity, of the right social class, of the right parents who could afford to spend time in cafes talking about literature instead of laboring for wages. Think of all the bright minds that could have been, but never even had an opportunity for education and never learned to read, for example. You say its the entire empires brightest minds in that cafe, I see an echo chamber composed of a small subset of whoever was the socially favorable class of people of the day, regurgitating the same already accepted ideas, failing to innovate for fear of being ostracized by each other in a world where high school level petty politics decided whether or not you kept your head attached to your body. Even a parisian cafe with a drunken hemingway pales in comparison to a ted talk, in terms of sharing and improving ideas and introducing them to anyone in the world with an internet connection. Not just who could get into a parisian cafe.
- keiferski 7y agoYour comment is wrong and historically anachronistic in a number a ways. I don’t really have the patience to go through it point by point, but I’ll say this: The idea that cafes were locked off to certain people because of lack of wealth or not being the proper social class is demonstrably false. Plenty of places catered specifically for avant-garde artists, obscure literary movements, and other things not deemed proper by the upper classes. Plenty of other cafes were focused more on workers, especially in somewhere like Paris. It was a part of everyday life. > ...they also used the cafe’s writing paper, but apparently many of them did not bother to order anything. > Between the two world wars, in 1925, there were over 1,250 coffee-houses in Vienna...There were special coffee-houses for pianists and others for string-players, for operetta composers and for serious composers, for stamp collectors and court councilors, for radicals and conservatives. Almost each self-respecting soccer club had its coffee-house, and almost each unrespected ministry. > And there was a generous assortment of ‘Viennese Schopenhauer’s’, such as the Hungerkünstler (Hunger Artist) Ottfried Krzyzanowsky who could go without solid food for days, and was nourished by the stale coffee-house air. He became a local legend but never wrote a line. This hunger artist later died of starvation. Many cafes were filled with poor artists. If you read Hemingway, you quickly learn that he was quite poor while living in Paris and had to strategically plan his meals. I recommend the anthology book On Bohemia by Graña, specifically the essay The Viennese Kaffeehaus by Joseph Wechsberg. (Quotes are from the latter.)