7 ms·
I hope that someday cafe culture makes a comeback. As much as I love sitting in a cafe working on my laptop, the current iteration of cafes is but a pale imitat
by keiferski 7y ago
I hope that someday cafe culture makes a comeback. As much as I love sitting in a cafe working on my laptop, the current iteration of cafes is but a pale imitation of what they were in the past.
Revolutions were plotted, art movements invented, and history made in places like Cafe Central in Vienna. I recommend reading literature from the 1880s-1930s to get a sense of how important they were for the time period. A Moveable Feast by Hemingway is a good start.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coffee_culture https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coffee_culture
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coffeehouse https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coffeehouse
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Café_Central https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Café_Central
- chrisseaton 7y ago> Revolutions were plotted, art movements invented, and history made in places like Cafe Central in Vienna. What makes you think people aren't doing this on their laptops? The person you think is doing corporate work on their MacBook could be changing the world.
- keiferski 7y agoThe culture simply isn’t there anymore in any focused form. Reddit, HN or wherever probably isn’t comparable to having an entire empire’s brightest minds in the same cafe on a daily basis.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Barrin92 7y agoI think that's mostly because today there are so many bright minds they don't fit in a coffee house. Go to the cafeteria of any large business or university and you'll probably find more highly educated people than you found in all of Vienna 150 years ago. I think what you're yearning for is really the bourgeois culture of high-minded intellectuals participating in exclusive clubs rather than facilitating good discourse between intelligent people. Access to the latter nowadays is thankfully much easier than it was in the past.
- ValentineC 7y agoI suspect that some of the posters in this thread are looking for a physical place to collaborate and share ideas, rather than just a bunch of bright minds in one venue. Please support your local third place, like a hackerspace or a non-profit community centre: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_place https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_place
- keiferski 7y ago> Go to the cafeteria of any large business or university and you'll probably find more highly educated people than you found in all of Vienna 150 years ago. Maybe, but those people aren’t really interacting with each other or sharing ideas in a way that isn’t aligned with their personal or professional goals. The cafe of yore was a melting pot of people and ideas; the contemporary cafeteria is far more functional and teleological. Maybe it was my fault by using the term ‘brightest minds’, but intelligence or education level is also not really the main draw. Certainly the revolutionary artists of the late 1800s weren’t the most academically educated ones.
- Xelbair 7y ago>Go to the cafeteria of any large business or university and you'll probably find more highly educated people than you found in all of Vienna 150 years ago. Highly ecudated != bright mind I think it is because nowadays you can communicate with other bright minds instantly, as long as you can find them in the mazes of the internet. Back then you had to be physically with them in the same space. Today you don't have that physical limitation. But to be honest, due to sheer curiosity - i would love to try such coffee house, but unless we discover a time machine i doubt it will ever happen.
- asdff 7y agoThere's a fallacy here. The only bright minds permitted in the imperial cafe of yore were those of the right ethnicity, of the right social class, of the right parents who could afford to spend time in cafes talking about literature instead of laboring for wages. Think of all the bright minds that could have been, but never even had an opportunity for education and never learned to read, for example. You say its the entire empires brightest minds in that cafe, I see an echo chamber composed of a small subset of whoever was the socially favorable class of people of the day, regurgitating the same already accepted ideas, failing to innovate for fear of being ostracized by each other in a world where high school level petty politics decided whether or not you kept your head attached to your body. Even a parisian cafe with a drunken hemingway pales in comparison to a ted talk, in terms of sharing and improving ideas and introducing them to anyone in the world with an internet connection. Not just who could get into a parisian cafe.
- keiferski 7y agoYour comment is wrong and historically anachronistic in a number a ways. I don’t really have the patience to go through it point by point, but I’ll say this: The idea that cafes were locked off to certain people because of lack of wealth or not being the proper social class is demonstrably false. Plenty of places catered specifically for avant-garde artists, obscure literary movements, and other things not deemed proper by the upper classes. Plenty of other cafes were focused more on workers, especially in somewhere like Paris. It was a part of everyday life. > ...they also used the cafe’s writing paper, but apparently many of them did not bother to order anything. > Between the two world wars, in 1925, there were over 1,250 coffee-houses in Vienna...There were special coffee-houses for pianists and others for string-players, for operetta composers and for serious composers, for stamp collectors and court councilors, for radicals and conservatives. Almost each self-respecting soccer club had its coffee-house, and almost each unrespected ministry. > And there was a generous assortment of ‘Viennese Schopenhauer’s’, such as the Hungerkünstler (Hunger Artist) Ottfried Krzyzanowsky who could go without solid food for days, and was nourished by the stale coffee-house air. He became a local legend but never wrote a line. This hunger artist later died of starvation. Many cafes were filled with poor artists. If you read Hemingway, you quickly learn that he was quite poor while living in Paris and had to strategically plan his meals. I recommend the anthology book On Bohemia by Graña, specifically the essay The Viennese Kaffeehaus by Joseph Wechsberg. (Quotes are from the latter.)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- nabla9 7y agoYeah but at the same place? Imagine Osama Bin Laden, Dick Cheney, Satoshi Nakamoto, Putin, Xi Jinping, Jeff Bezos, Edward Snowden, Elon Musk and Geoff Hinton sitting in the same cafe in the early 2000s.
- systemvoltage 7y agoHow is that even possible?
- nabla9 7y agoIt's not anymore. In the the early last century Vienna it was.
- asdff 7y agoI wonder how you would be perceived in that cafe in vienna if you looked neither austrian nor hungarian? The proportion of who even got their hands on literature in the first place was tiny. The majority of Vienna's brightest minds over the course of history likely died forgotten and illiterate, never having an opportunity to turn their intelligence into action and progress. The 1800s and first half of the 1900s were extremely toxic environments for sharing ideas, driven by massively inflated egos of a few people cornering their fields who wanted to hoard their theories and ideas for themselves, while also being at the ready to shoot down any dissenting opinion from someone in the same field who could have been a collaborator in saner times. Even Darwin suffered so much toxic abuse from his peers that he walked back a lot of his master work by his death. We harp that people use the internet to waste their time, but that is such a privileged and myopic stance to blame societies shortcomings on the rising internet. Misinformation and propaganda weren't invented by mark zuckerberg. We fixate on the bad and ignore the benefits to people in different situations than ours. So many more people around the world have access to knowledge that would have otherwise been impossible to ever receive, simply because they came out of the wrong womb on top of the wrong speck of dirt.
- Igelau 7y agoThat sounds more like the Bohemian Grove than a cafe!
- amiga_500 7y agoI could be proven wrong, but I'm almost certain no assault on the status quo will be mounted from a mac book.
- Ericson2314 7y agoThe revolution will not be plotted on an Apple computer.
- djohnston 7y agoprobably a thinkpad
- che_shirecat 7y agoWhat would it take to get this social aspect of cafes back? Exclusivity? No-smartphone rule? Dedicated discussion times? How do you envision us bringing this back while adapting to modern social norms?
- Ididntdothis 7y agoMore leisure time.
- RandomBacon 7y agoThat will just be filled with more Internet (see people who have tons of leisure time (and are still being paid) due to the virus).
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gundmc 7y agoI don't disagree, but it's hard to point to the current mandated social distancing as empirical evidence. It's not like the people increasing their internet consumption could hang out at a cafe instead.
- RandomBacon 7y agoTrue, but there are other alternatives: You can draw, write, read, build things, etc. It just requires people getting creative, which is something we've getting less acustomed to as we instead consume more and more.
- asdff 7y agoThe virus isn't a good example. All you can do with your time really is spend time on the internet or wander your neighborhood awkwardly shifting past people for the 100th time. I think we might have a whiplash when this is done, where people start engaging with public space at a higher rate than before the pandemic. Imagine everyone itching to just go to a bar, or a beach, or a trail, or a movie theater, or a cafe, or anything. I can see stuff being packed for months.
- tyre 7y ago(posted below) great piece on this exactly: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2018/12/24/what-cafes-did-for-liberalism https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2018/12/24/what-cafes-did...
- Mikeb85 7y ago> Revolutions were plotted And this is why it'll never come back. Governments will push for social distancing to be permanent (to 'protect' us from future pandemics), they'll hold on to all the power they amass during the pandemic, they'll keep tracking people and do everything they can to prevent social change which threatens their power.
- freehunter 7y agoThat might end up being a reason why they would never come back, but that doesn’t explain why they weren’t still around two months ago.
- Zenst 7y agoCan't help not mention https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lloyd%27s_Coffee_House https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lloyd%27s_Coffee_House A whole industry born in a coffee shop.
- blawson 7y agoIt may still be happening? https://www.forbes.com/sites/tomiogeron/2011/11/16/coupa-cafe-where-startups-meet-work-and-test-products/#2f1fae1ce6f2 https://www.forbes.com/sites/tomiogeron/2011/11/16/coupa-caf... I would guess you wouldn't expect to walk into a random Vienna coffee shop in the late 19th century and plot the future, either.
- nabla9 7y agoCafé Central is probably historically most important cafe. It seems like everybody was there at some point. The list of regulars and visitors is who is who of the 20th century. For the short period (20 years or so) in the early 1900s Vienna was where the history happened and modern ideas were born. Then everybody scattered around the world and executed those ideas with varying results. Philosophy, math, psychology, physics, economics, politics (left and right) you name it. In 1913 Hitler, Trotsky, Tito, Freud and Stalin lived within the same square kilometer.
- oarabbus_ 7y ago> the current iteration of cafes is but a pale imitation of what they were in the past. >Revolutions were plotted, art movements invented, and history made in places like Cafe Central in Vienna. That was simply out of necessity. Revolutions are plotted, art movements invented, and history is made on the internet now. If these things are your metric, cafe's will never again return to the glory days.
- crispyambulance 7y agoA return to 19th century cafe culture is perhaps a bit optimistic. I would be satisfied with a re-emergence early-90's (that is 1990's) chill coffee house. But those days are gone too. I'd say it's because of two reasons: Real Estate (rent too damn high) and no time because everyone is either working or not in the right head-space. There was a time in 1990's where one could read about 19th-century flaneurs and actually think they were also a flaneur, spending all afternoon in a coffee house hanging out with random people, talking about cool stuff. I did it, for a very short while then -poof-, it was gone.
- sportsaw 7y agoThis sounds sentimental, I can’t think of anything worse than being stuck in a coffee shop talking to people all day.
- sammalloy 7y agoThen you aren’t thinking about it in context. One reason as to why people hung out in coffee shops talking all day has to do with climate. This was a phenomenon in particularly cold climates with inclement weather. So clearly, it was worse to be stuck outside in the cold and rain than inside in the warmth, surrounded by friends and a steaming cup of coffee.
- steve_adams_86 7y agoThis was my late teens and early 20s on Vancouver Island in British Columbia. A long, wet, cold, relentless "winter" can only be beaten by warm drinks and good friends. Actually, they don't even have to be great friends, haha. Just need to get out of the house and remind yourself there's more than rain and grey.
- freehunter 7y agoWho said anything about being stuck? If you were there, you were there because you wanted to be.
- crispyambulance 7y ago
- brenden2 7y agoSounds like rosy retrospection[0] to me. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosy_retrospection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosy_retrospection
- markdown 7y agoLook for a good kava bar for a similar experience.
- Swizec 7y agoI think we’ve replaced a lot of that culture with HackerNews and Twitter. You come here to find many of those conversations now. Private chat groups/slacks for more intimidate revolution plotty stuff
- BurningFrog 7y agoCall me crazy, but I think that era could have done well with fewer revolutions!
- voz_ 7y agoI resent your comment as low effort. This is a rather non-nuanced take on history. What happened, happened. History does not really work like that. To make it concrete - my great great grandma was born in shtetl, in the pale. She was illiterate, and her village was pogromed often. The revolution allowed her daughter to get some education, and her granddaughter to become a leading civil engineer. For this I am grateful. That being said, I also understand the futile impossibility of even attempting to "what if" history.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- DrScump 7y agoUsername checks out
- firecall 7y agoAh yes - back in London in the 90's, I'd stop at a cafe or two in SOHO and get an espresso, smoke a cigarette and read the paper as a break. It was a wonderfully urbane and civilised way to live. (although we may now consider smoking barbaric).
- seattle_spring 7y agoFor some reason Salt Lake City has (or had? I haven't been there in ~8 years) a fantastic cafe culture. Lots of art and culture centered around places like 9th and 9th and Greenhouse Effect (before the current dickhead owner bought it). Last I saw though, places like The Rose Establishment are doing their best to squash the culture and bring in SF coffee culture, meaning pretentious drinks, rude waitstaff, and a sea of dudes at their own tables with laptops covered in <company they work for> stickers.
- sbrother 7y agoThis is still (well, pre-COVID) pretty true! Coffee Garden and Publik at 9th and 9th are great places to hang out and chat and I'd feel weird pulling a laptop out. And there are lots of new arrivals, most of which feel more like community gathering spaces than workspaces. I love the cafe culture here and I miss it when I'm in norcal.
- DrScump 7y agoThat's surprising, given the number of LDS there.
- seattle_spring 7y agoThe presence of LDS has created a diverse array of counter cultures in Utah. It's really a fascinating place.
- Thorentis 7y agoAustralia's Cafe culture is the closest I know of to this. Not only is American coffee gross, but the takeaway in-and-out culture is not what cafes used to be. In Australia, there are thousands of cafes where you can buy quality coffee, have free WiFi, aesthetic seating area, lounges, music you can still hear yourself think over, usually has pretty good food too. Now sure, you're paying $4 for a coffee, but the environment is like no other in the world. Even the coffee is fairly unique in terms of quality and style compared to American and continental European (french, even Italian).
- DrScump 7y agoNot only is American coffee gross Your tone is like somebody saying "Australian food sucks" because they had a bad meal at Outback once. There are great sourcers and roasters here. If you couldn't find any, that's on you.
- DrScump 7y agoThe earliest coffeehouses I was exposed to growing up in SV were in bookstores and became great gathering places, especially after dinner. The Upstart Crow (bookstore and cafe) was in the Pruneyard shopping center in the 1980s. I had my first espresso drinks there. In 1990 or so, Coffee Society opened in Cupertino, just a few doors down from A Clean, Well Lighted Place for books. This all was before Starbucks hit the area.
- ignoramous 7y ago> This all was before Starbucks hit the area. Interesting. Books aside, what specifically, you think, about Starbucks that killed the social aspect of it all-- Free WiFi?