5 ms·
this is a huge win - although it's interesting that Ginsburg and some other "liberal" judges seem to side with Georgia in saying that the state should be able t
by olliej 7y ago
this is a huge win - although it's interesting that Ginsburg and some other "liberal" judges seem to side with Georgia in saying that the state should be able to put the law of the land behind a pay wall.
- irrational 7y agoWhy?
- tantalor 7y agoThat dissent refers to "non-binding annotations" which are more like the opinions of the law-makers, hence not part of their duties because they are not law.
- pmiller2 7y agoIndeed, here is the very first paragraph of the dissenting opinion by Ginsburg (joined by Breyer), beginning at p. 39 of the linked submission: > Beyond doubt, state laws are not copyrightable. Nor are other materials created by state legislators in the course of performing their lawmaking responsibilities, e.g., legislative committee reports, floor statements, unenacted bills. (Ante, at 8–9). Not all that legislators do, however, is ineligible for copyright protection; the government edicts doctrine shields only “works that are (1) created by judges and legislators (2) in the course of their judicial and legislative duties.” (Ante, at 9) (emphasis added). The core question this case presents, as I see it: Are the annotations in the Official Code of Georgia Annotated (OCGA) done in a legislative capacity? The answer, I am persuaded, should be no.
- huffmsa 7y agoWhich is reasonable, but isn't this publication THE only codified publication of Georgia's laws?
- ejstronge 7y agoHow would your argument change in the event that this were the only such publication? How about if there were 1,000? EDIT: I now realize that George effectively only published an annotated version of its laws, which can only be purchased (it seems) from LexisNexis. While a free version is available, this version appears to be prepared by LexisNexis (all of this is my understanding from ref 1) 1. https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2019/12/justices-debate-allowing-state-law-to-be-hidden-behind-a-pay-wall/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2019/12/justices-debate-...
- greggyb 7y agoThe free version is the unannotated code and Lexis is required to make it available per the contract with the Georgia legislature.
- ejstronge 7y agoI recognize this, but (at least, per the reference I linked) the free version isn't an official state of Georgia document. It seems the only official version of the state laws is the commercial version.
- greggyb 7y agoI tend to agree with you, but availability of the text of the statutes is not at issue in the case here. In all of the opinions, every justice agrees that the text of the laws should be freely available, and not one of them raised any issue with the fact that the text of the statutes is made available through an agent, rather than directly by the state. It is difficult to make an argument from a negative, but it is interesting to note that no one seems to care that Lexis distributes the text. Also, if you go to Georgia's legislative web site and click on the link for "Georgia Code"[0], this takes you directly to Lexis Nexis. This seems as official as anything you'll find. The fact that a government contracts a third party to provide a service does not imply that that government is failing to provide said service. As an analog, if I am a landlord, I am required to maintain any premises I let in a state that is fit for humans to live in. Whether I hire third party contractors to do the work to maintain these conditions or do the work myself, I am discharging my duties as landlord. No one would ever complain that I hired a plumber rather than fixed a toilet myself (assuming that the work is of the same quality). [0] left-side nav bar, under "Legislation" heading, second from the bottom of its section. Edit: I'll note that the arrangement as laid out in the syllabus of the Supreme Court decision reads differently than that in the Ars article. The syllabus clearly states that the annotations are produced as a work for hire by a division of Lexis for the Georgia Assembly in a contract managed through the Code Revision Commission (a committee of the Georgia legislature). The copyright vests in the state of Georgia. The Ars article implies (based on my reading) that the copyright belongs to Lexis. These two readings provide very different starting points. Separately, the Ars article raises FUD about the copy of the statutes hosted on the Lexis website, but the state of Georgia clearly links to this as the code. Lexis, as a third party without the ability to make law (and as an organization of lawyers) has some hedges it probably has to make when posting legal documents. Georgia claims this is the official text of the statutes. I'll defer to Georgia on this matter and accept the Lexis text as canonical.
- ejstronge 7y agoIn case someone sees '5-4' and assumes the standard Republican vs Democractic appointee divide, this is definitely not what happened. Might be a case where one should read the various justices' opinions before deciding how they feel about the case.
- wahern 7y agoGinsburg daughter is a copyright law scholar who is very pro-copyright. Ginsburg's decisions tend to be very reliably pro-copyright on a court where consistency on copyright matters is utterly lacking among all the other justices. As compared to Ginsburg, it's a crap shoot how any particular justice will decide a copyright case. I personally don't think this is a coincidence. I would guess that Ginsburg's thinking is heavily influenced by conversations with her daughter. Or perhaps Ginsburg's strongly held opinions on copyright influenced her daughter's career.