2 ms·
I mean, sure, it is relatively impossible to get into. I wouldn't expect newbies to embedded programming to get their feet wet with these systems. My complaint
by derefr 7y ago
I mean, sure, it is relatively impossible to get into. I wouldn't expect newbies to embedded programming to get their feet wet with these systems.
My complaint is that even the old hands in e.g. the demoscene aren't bothering to play with these modern embedded devices, when hacking on at-the-time-modern "happens to have a computer in it" embedded devices was exactly where the demoscene got started. Nowadays, for some reason, it's ossified into just building hacks for the same old retro devices that were popular in the scene 30-50 years ago; rather than exploring what can be done with modern appliances.
I feel like the only modern "playfulness" in exploring the capabilities of these devices, comes when someone writes a funny "we did it" screen to be triggered by their PoC exploit chain for some "secure" device at DefCon. But they never bother to go further than that and actually make it to something neat—because they're security people and that's not their thing.
Maybe it would be fruitful if there were an event where security folks and demoscene folks team up and collaborate—the security people to handle getting code to run on the device using known (if still only PoC) exploits; the demoscene people to explore the capabilities the resulting "access surface" of the device grants them, and create art demonstrating their findings.
- CobrastanJorji 7y agoBut that's the point. If you want to make something neat with severe computing limitations, the old devices are great for that. If you want to try to run your own code onto a thing trying to stop you from running your own code, the new devices are great for that. But how many people are in BOTH groups?
- derefr 7y agoThe old devices tried to stop you from running your own code, too! These problems have long been solved; but hacking around lock-out chips, manually re-flashing soldered ROMs, etc., was always part of the original demoscene culture—just like urban exploration and parkour has always been part of street-art culture. Sometimes a fence gets between you and your canvas, and you need to go around! I suppose that might imply that "the old demoscene" had this intersection of interests, and so was inherently limited to a much smaller group of people than "the modern demoscene" is; but it still was large enough to exist and have network effects of people joining in—so I'd expect to see some analogous community today, however small, and I still find it kind of weird that I don't! On another note, remember the venerable https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crack_intro https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crack_intro ? It seems warez groups had this intersection of interests, too: an equal focus on reverse-engineering/copy-protection-removal; and on attaching hardware-bending art to the results. Where'd those people go? Who are their spiritual descendants?