4 ms·
GNU mailman is more or less fine; what sucks is the pipermail archiver that it comes with. That doesn't have to be used, luckily. Mailing lists benefit from a
by kazinator 7y ago
GNU mailman is more or less fine; what sucks is the pipermail archiver that it comes with. That doesn't have to be used, luckily.
Mailing lists benefit from a good web archive. For anyone who hasn't received everything in their inbox, the archive is the only interface to past material. It has to be presented well, searchable, threaded and so on, so you don't miss anything due to not having it in your inbox.
I've been using Lurker for years, with my own modifications.
http://www.kylheku.com/cgit/lurker/ http://www.kylheku.com/cgit/lurker/
Some of my hcanges are cosmetic (like different icons), but the main one is to HTML in posts to be rendered. To do that, the HTML is passed through a rigid HTML cleaner that validates for allowed tags and attributes:
http://www.kylheku.com/cgit/hc/ http://www.kylheku.com/cgit/hc/
(That is connected to Lurker via a new Lurker config option htmlfilt which specifies to path to the hc executable).
In spite of that, when I contacted the Lurker author about this, he was vehemently dead set against HTML going into archives.
My mods to Lurker look dated, but the upstream has not moved. The SourceForge page is still offering 2.3 for download in the Files area, dated 2009.
"No HTML in mailing lists dammit" may work for some open source projects, but it's not realistic; people use HTML e-mails, and want the archive to have the content that people see who have received the e-mail directly.
- hannob 7y ago> GNU mailmain is more or less fine; what sucks is the pipermail archiver that it comes with. That doesn't have to be used, luckily. Pipermail is part of mailman 2, which is the about to be deprecated very soon version (it's python 2 only). Mailman 3 has a different thing, but I haven't tried it yet.
- syntheticnature 7y agoThis is interesting, because cPanel still ships with Mailman 2 as the 2->3 archive conversion still has bugs[0]. 0: https://features.cpanel.net/topic/upgrade-to-mailman-3-0 https://features.cpanel.net/topic/upgrade-to-mailman-3-0
- kazinator 7y agoIf archive "conversion" is an issue, that sounds like the new archive tool that Mailman 3 comes with is not good at importing mbox files and generating an archive from them? That seems hard to believe. I had no issue with this with Lurker. A few times in the (now fairly distant) past I gone in there and blew off all the generated content (after editing an mbox archive file), then re-generated. Since then I developed an invisible delete button right in the web UI, for removing spam from the web archive. If you know where to click, and what the password is, you can blow off any post. An archiver that can't import your historic mbox files has a showstopper issue for anyone with existing archives, and may present a problem to someone who wants to rebuild a damaged web archive.
- syntheticnature 7y agoLooking at that thread, it's not clear whether the problem is the archives or moving some other configuration aspects; it seems like they think an archive-less move is easier, but given there's no support at all...
- kazinator 7y agoLooks like this is HyperKitty? Any examples of this in use? The web page has a link to some dated mock-ups (2012): https://wiki.list.org/HyperKitty https://wiki.list.org/HyperKitty It looks like some random web BBS forum. (Please tell me the actual thing does not have up/down "like" votes; that's completely stupid in a mail archive (not to mention misleading), and preventing abuse of it would require visitors to be authenticated, which is also a complete stupid thing in a mail archive.)
- banger180 7y agoFedora usses mailman 3 and hyperkitty at https://lists.fedoraproject.org/archives/ https://lists.fedoraproject.org/archives/ It is infidelity inspired by the layout of a forum, but looks great IMO.
- kazinator 7y agoWow, that's pretty awful. And they did implement the moronic voting buttons, too (facepalm). Lurker wipes the floor with Hyperkitty. (And is fast: C++ that generates static pages!)
- zimpenfish 7y agoI saw something about this yesterday and the stated rationale for votes was that mailman is supposed to bridge between mailing lists and forums (where votes are useful.)
- m463 7y ago> "No HTML in mailing lists dammit" and javascript. webgl too. and phone and tablet support. And support for inline ads. We should allow zero-pixel tracking links to so we know advertising statis... I mean to protect us from covid-19. and animated avatars. it's a slippery slope.
- kazinator 7y agoYes, namely this one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slippery_slope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slippery_slope