7 ms·
Excellent counterpoint from r/AskHistorians (paragraph breaks added for legibility): [1] > Cross-cultural psychologists have observed that, regardless of cultu
by crazygringo 7y ago
Excellent counterpoint from r/AskHistorians (paragraph breaks added for legibility): [1]
> Cross-cultural psychologists have observed that, regardless of cultural background, people who suffer persistent emotional disturbances in the wake of a traumatic event exhibit intrusive memory symptoms in some form. Here in the US, these are closely related to what we commonly call "flashbacks." For the Romans, people experiencing intrusive memories were said to be haunted by ghosts. These individuals show up in historical, philosophical, and even medical texts.
> Josephus, who was an outsider to Roman culture, also describes this phenomenon in his history of The Great Revolt. Those haunted by ghosts are constantly depicted showing many symptoms which would be familiar to the modern PTSD sufferer. Insomnia, depression, mood swings, being easily startled, frequent eye movement, alertness all day and night, paranoia, avoidance of crowds, suicidal thoughts/attempts, loss of appetite, shaking/shivering, self-hatred, and impulsive violence have all turned up in association with these individuals.
> Since in almost every case the person experiencing these things had made himself an object of public shame, the "ghosts" in question often came in the form of those he had killed or wronged in the past. These would either appear spontaneously to the sufferer, or would come in the form of vivid, frightening nightmares.
> The key component to these experiences, as with modern cases of PTSD, was that the sufferer had no control over his own symptoms. Thoughts or vivid memories would occur unexpectedly and uncontrollably. It is easy to see why the Romans, who were religiously superstitious to begin with, would attribute such things to the foul play of malicious spirits.
[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1j6ssm/are_there_any_indications_of_combat_ptsd_in/cbbvfib/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1j6ssm/are_t...
- mattigames 7y agoPlus there has been strong indicators that other animals can suffer from PTSD e.g. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/ejn.12860 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/ejn.12860
- kylek 7y agoAstounding that we’d think otherwise.
- Frondo 7y agoPurely anecdotally, as a pet owner this doesn't surprise me at all. I have two rescue cats that, from the descriptions from the fosters, had very stressful lives before I got them (attacks from dogs, being attacked by other cats in a feral cat colony, etc). I've also cats that had a very relaxed prior life. The differences in their behaviors is stark; one of the rescues displays a lot of stress behavior whenever there are loud noises or anything surprising. One of them has calmed down a lot, but those behaviors still pop up pretty regularly. I don't know enough about animal psychology or their inner worlds to say, "that's PTSD," (I do think, mind, that animals experience emotions, but how that experiences compares to human emotion, I don't know) but there sure seems to be something about reliving trauma there.
- valuearb 7y agoReproducibility crisis.
- wetmore 7y agoPlease elaborate.
- Uehreka 7y agoI unfold my interpreter spectacles It would appear that GP wishes to express skepticism of the concept of PTSD by invoking the “Reproducibility Crisis” that has affected the social sciences. It would seem that GP believes the crisis to be so all-encompassing and fully invalidating that merely speaking its true name is enough to dismiss any modern psychological finding.
- phkahler 7y ago>> believes the crisis to be so all-encompassing and fully invalidating that... That's the danger in publishing sloppy work across an entire field. In many peoples mind they lose all credibility. If the peer review can't separate the wheat from the chaf, why should anyone else? No taking a stance on any particular findings, or field of study. Just pointing out that the posters response should not be unexpected. Nor should it be universal ;-)
- tptacek 7y agoIf that's really what you believe, I have bad news for you about computer science.
- valuearb 7y agoCan you name a single “modern psychological finding” that is well supported by reproducible studies with statistically relevant results?
- palimpsests 7y agoThanks for this. I’m a trauma therapist, I work with many people who have PTSD. Reading this article all I could think was: Trauma is a sophisticated concept. As a society and species, we are pretty “trauma naive” in that we have just recently come to this understanding of the very complex web of psychological, somatic, emotional, sociological, intergenerational, and cultural aspects of this experience. Because of this, we are refining the therapeutic modalities that are most efficacious for treating trauma. See all the latest literature by Peter Levine, Bessel van der Kolk, Gabor Maté. So I wouldn’t really expect these societies to know what to look for - in fact, it could have been so ubiquitous that the symptoms (and/or suppression of them e.g. regular intoxication) were normalized. Given how warlike they were as he described in the article, it could be like asking a fish to describe water. We know for a fact that mammals get PTSD after being in highly stressful experiences that they are unable to metabolize. I can’t see why humans would be any different. Also, many different cultures have historically had taboos around the expression and natural resolution of PTSD. I don’t know about the culture of society around the age he is speaking of in this regard, but I wouldn’t be surprised if that was a normal aspect of life back then, too.
- Cederfjard 7y agoStupid question here, but isn't it possible that experiencing violence and death isn't as highly stressful/traumatic if it's to you like water is to a fish, to borrow your phrase? Especially if you have some sort of belief in an afterlife to console you. Just a question from someone who knows very little about this.
- palimpsests 7y agoIt's not a stupid question at all. Death nor violence does not have to be inherently traumatic. I would be very surprised if 100% of people back then had degrees of PTSD (and that's not what my comment was meant to imply). A working definition of trauma: "trauma can be defined as any unresolved autonomic nervous system response. It’s about the nervous system’s response to an event, not necessarily the event itself. Events can affect each of us very differently." The context in which these events happen plays a huge role in whether or not someone develops symptoms of PTSD afterwards. Spiritual beliefs can play an important role in acceptance of death and therefore it not being a terrifying experience.
- RookyNumbas 7y agoI'm not sure that is actually a counterpoint. It think they are somewhat in agreement. The blog states that there is very little evidence that people of the ancient and medieval world experienced PTSD from combat the way modern soldiers do. The askshistorians poster focuses on two points: - Combat and violence were normalized, and there was little moral or ethical ambiguity surrounding it. Unlike today. - PTSD seemed to come from public perception of the acts and the resulting shame, rather than the acts themselves. Also unlike today.
- Mvandenbergh 7y agoOne of the interesting comments from the AskHistorians FAQ on PTSD is that, in the classical world, PTSD like behaviour was more commonly associated with public shame rather than private guilt. They might have felt much less conflicted by killing because they did not come from a cultural background where killing your enemies is usually prohibited. Our justification as a culture for warfare starts with "of course, killing is bad, but..." and then looks into when it is allowable. Many of the examples we have of things that look like PTSD are from failed rebels, people who were involved in civil wars, or people who had been disgraced. That would mean that they experienced the same sort of reaction to a stressor that they couldn't process but that the type of stressor that might trigger such a reaction was fundamentally different.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoIt wouldn't just be the killing. It would be the experience of watching friends and colleagues being dismembered and maimed around you. We have a very sanitised and romantic notion of war. Battles are framed as "historical events", not as personal experiences which would be considered horrific by most people today. In medical terms we're talking about gangs of (usually) thousands of armed men people trying to cause as much death and injury to each other as possible through physical trauma, stabbing, dismemberment, burning, drowning, and disemboweling - with almost certain infection and sepsis for the survivors. And relentless peer pressure to participate. Sociopaths might thrive in that environment, but anyone with any empathy would find it challenging. Even if they viewed the enemy as subhuman, they would still have to deal with the extreme personal stress and the direct personal experience of uncommon brutality. And the losers would experience all of that mingled with the usual psychological effects of failing to win.
- Garlef 7y ago> In medical terms we're talking about ... trying to cause as much death and injury to each other ... Are you sure about this? What do you base your statement on? I remember having read as a child an article in a science magazine claming that war in ancient times was far less deadly than war today; If I remember correctly, one of the reasons stated was that the participants were not intent on actually killing every soldier on the other side but rather on overpowering them or on making them surrender. (Also: "trying to cause as much death and injury to each other" is not a medical term.)
- anthk 7y agoIn Spain we talk about those PTSDs coloquially as "fantasmas del pasado" (ghosts from the past).