3 ms·
OK, we need to stop discussing China and Chinas approach because we know they are lying about all of their numbers. That's what basically every Western country
by LatteLazy 7y ago
OK, we need to stop discussing China and Chinas approach because we know they are lying about all of their numbers. That's what basically every Western country had said.
If you don't believe me, that's fine, just go Google it. US intelligence have publicly stated this. Just in the last few days the UK has stopped listing Chinese numbers at all because they as so badly wrong.
I don't doubt that there are a lot of personal anecdotes coming from China, but as far as I know the only numbers are the official ones and they are pap.
If you can offer factual evidence that that is not true, I'd be very pleased to be wrong since apparently Chinese coronavirus is 100 times less deadly than average...
So that brings us to contact tracing.
I'm happy to agree that contact tracing would mean we could keep R values lower with less disruption to people's lives. You could let people without contact go out more etc IF AND ONLY IF you can accurately do contact tracing.
But we've never done that before in the West. I belive it has been semi managed in Africa with Ebola. But Ebola is easier to test for. And its much faster to show symptoms. And patients tend to self isolate because they're so sick they can't get out of bed.
Coronavirus is airborne and seems to survive for long periods on surfaces. So you get many many more contacts even if you get fewer infections per contact.
The article doesn't attempt any maths despite these factors being key to knowing whether contact tracing works for a given disease. Do you know of any such model? Do we know what parameters we need to input for coronavirus (what defines a contact, how many contacts require quarantines etc)? I think these values are total unknowns for coronavirus, it's taken us this long to get to a semi reliable R0 value, we still don't know how R changed with quarantine methods and levels. So will we discover any of this in time to use it with COVID-19? Or will we just do the less accurate but just as effective measures we need to do and get through this in another 2-3 months?
Fyi, 0.6% (plus or minute 0.2percetage points) overall population fatality is what we are aiming for already based on having 100% treatment availability as far as I know. So apparently contact tracing offers exactly the same outcome? I have to ask again, what's the point? Isn't this at best a nice to have and at worse a wild goose chase?
- DiogenesKynikos 7y agoYou keep asserting that Chinese numbers are all faked, and then you want me to prove a negative. > That's what basically every Western country had said. I've heard the US and UK governments say this, coincidentally at exactly the moment when they were coming under political pressure because of their insufficient early responses to coronavirus. > US intelligence have publicly stated this. They're not a reliable source of information. > apparently Chinese coronavirus is 100 times less deadly than average... Where are you getting that from? Case fatality rates in China were similar to what was later found in Western countries. > we still don't know how R changed with quarantine methods There's actually very interesting research coming out of China about how different measures affected the reproductive rate of the virus. The Journal of the American Medical Association just published a study on exactly this question.[1] It strikes me as careless to write off this important information so easily. I think the reasons for doing so are primarily political: a lot of people have a hard time accepting that the Chinese government did something effectively, or that it succeeded in suppressing the epidemic where Western governments have so far mostly failed. 1. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2020.6130 https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2020.6130
- LatteLazy 7y agoI don't think i can convince you that Chinas official numbers are wrong if you the US and UK governments can't. Whatever you think of the US intelligence agencies (I also don't much rate them) the fact they publicly call out China on this should cause you to at least question the numbers. But that's up to you. Sorry if that sounds snippy, I just think we have different views on the Chinese numbers and are unlikely to find a matching set of facts. May I ask, what do you believe the Chinese death toll has been in total so far? The official number is 4642 I think. So if other countries are as efficient as China, this whole pandemic will kill only around 23,000 world wide. Let's up the Chinese are being accurate and we get these excellent numbers! Just for the record, I am actually very happy to concede that the Chinese government has been effective (after the first few weeks of the outbreak at least). I think China has a very effective government and I envy them that. But effective does not mean reliable. Aside from the above and needing to close their wet markets and treat their minories better, I don't have major objections to China...
- DiogenesKynikos 7y ago> May I ask, what do you believe the Chinese death toll has been in total so far? The official number is 4642 I think. So if other countries are as efficient as China, this whole pandemic will kill only around 23,000 world wide. Let's up the Chinese are being accurate and we get these excellent numbers! Your reasoning doesn't make any sense. The number of deaths is dependent on the number of people that get sick. China's lower number of deaths simply reflects the stricter containment measures it took to control the spread of the epidemic. The mortality rate among those who get infected is probably similar in China and Western countries. I could imagine that the mortality rate might vary by a factor of a few, based on how many ventilators are available, how overwhelmed hospitals are, and other similar factors. But the percentage of the total population that gets infected can vary by orders of magnitude, based on how aggressively you contain the epidemic. As of yesterday, based on the number of confirmed cases (a lower limit, but it gives you a sense of the differences): * 0.02% of the population of South Korea has contracted the virus. * 0.3% of the population of the United States has contracted the virus. Expecting the same percentage of the population to die in South Korea and the United States would be silly, based on the very different rates of infection. The same goes for China. > I am actually very happy to concede that the Chinese government has been effective (after the first few weeks of the outbreak at least). Then why is it so surprising to you that the extreme public health interventions they took (cordons sanitaires, quarantine centers, strict lock-downs of many cities, regular symptom checks for large swaths of the population, etc.) suppressed the reproductive rate of the virus and drove the number of new infections down drastically?
- contravert 7y agoIt's unbelievable how effective the west's disinformation, FUD and propaganda, lead by the US, against China has been. It's pretty much on par with the narrative leading up the the Iraq war. There's even documents describing this blame China strategy as a way to deflect Trump's failures: https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2020/04/25/senate-gop-talking-points-coronavirus-blame-china-not-trump/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2020/04/25/senate-go... Despite not having any concrete evidence, you don't trust China's numbers and that they have coronavirus contained. Have you considered that you might be thinking this way because of a coordinated propaganda campaign? Objectively looking at the situation on the ground in China right now, life is going back to normal and there hasn't been massive outbreaks of covid19 and rushes to the hospital. You can't hide exponential growth if the virus was not contained.
- LatteLazy 7y agoIf Chinas numbers are accurate, then we are doing this all for nothing, the total global deathtoll will be less than a normal year's flu season. Is that your position? I should be clear: I don't trust Trump or the West particularly. But mass faking numbers like this is common in China and very rare in the west. The west cheats in other ways...
- DiogenesKynikos 7y ago> If Chinas numbers are accurate, then we are doing this all for nothing, the total global deathtoll will be less than a normal year's flu season. How do you figure that? The lesson from China is that the way to keep the death toll low is to enact extreme public health interventions to stop transmission of the virus and suppress the epidemic. The lesson isn't, "Everything will be fine if we do nothing." The reason fewer people have died in China is because fewer people have gotten sick in the first place. The way that happened was through lock-downs that were far stricter than anything implemented in the West (and a whole host of other measures, like regularly checking everyone's temperature and quarantining anyone with a fever).
- LatteLazy 7y ago