4 ms·
Not the entire world consists of ‘did you just assume my gender’ people. Most people don’t care at all. Stereotypes exist because they model people pretty well
by tinus_hn 7y ago
Not the entire world consists of ‘did you just assume my gender’ people. Most people don’t care at all.
Stereotypes exist because they model people pretty well.
If you enter that your gender is unicorn you probably just get slightly more generic ads.
Here’s a scary thought: if you walk the street everyone who sees you will assume your gender.
- pasabagi 7y agoEh - if you're trans and experiencing dysphoria it can be pretty painful when people misgender you. The whole 'did you assume my gender' thing is a sort of weird take on the fact that yes, it is pretty hurtful when somebody's going through a really hard and vulnerable time in their lives, then some douchebag is determined to make a political point that a complete stranger is 'really' x, or y. It's also just really bizarre and rude. Imagine referring to a cis woman with a beard as an 'it', or 'he'. For whatever reason, people go out of their way to commit this kind of absurd faux-pas with trans people.
- abjKT26nO8 7y ago> It's also just really bizarre and rude. Imagine referring to a cis woman with a beard as an 'it', or 'he'. I do that sometimes, unintentionally (regardless of the person in question having a beard or not). It's just that gender in language is most of the time redundant and it only introduces noise into conversation. For most topics, the gender of the persons involved is irrelevant. But many languages force you to choose one, which just creates confusion if this piece of information is crucial or if it's just this bloat that the language forced you to include in your sentence. Oh, and genders are much more prevalent in my native language. English is actually better than most languages in this respect. But let's go a step further and just get rid of it. I've heard the Swedes chose to move to "person/thing" pronouns, as opposed to "male/female/thing". In my native language, verbs change their forms based on subject's gender. And then when you have sentences like "if I were in your shoes, I would verb", my brain tells me to assume the gender of the other speaker when I say verb. I mean, it's only logical: if I were in your shoes, I would be of your gender. But the language works otherwise. It's just stupid. As to people's reactions to my occasional misnamings, most people don't care at all, some are amused. Because, really, this part of language is ridiculous. And making an issue out of it is immature.
- sascha_sl 7y agoOh C'mon, have some empathy. Of course cis people are just going to be amused to mildly annoyed. Trans people however are in a daily grind to be recognized. From personal experience, it always depends how deliberate a misgendering is, once with subsequent correction stings but is fine, not putting in any effort is quite uncomfortable and deliberately doing the opposite is "fuck off and never talk to me again" territory. The later happens not as infrequently as you might think, so the second might be misunderstood for the the later (and really, it costs nothing to not make people feel like trash). While most people will eventually be recognized - at least if they fit within the binary somewhere and medically transition - a few will not, and almost nobody will on the long way there. To insist it is not a big deal because you can't relate, that is immature.
- WorldMaker 7y ago> Oh, and genders are much more prevalent in my native language. English is actually better than most languages in this respect. But let's go a step further and just get rid of it. I've heard the Swedes chose to move to "person/thing" pronouns, as opposed to "male/female/thing". It's an interesting tangent here: English has been very slowly converging on singular `they` since Shakespearean Middle English. It's interesting that singular `you` (which started after singular `they`) beat singular `they` to the modern English party, but it somewhat makes sense that removing language formality distinctions was quickly more useful in short term language evolution than removing English's few remaining gender-required assumptions.
- knolax 7y ago> Stereotypes exist because they model people pretty well. That isn't true for any stringent definition of well. Plus you don't have to be a "did you assume my gender" person to be peeved that someone's poorly trained ML system is making false assumptions about you and then labeling you with those assumptions. Even if it were an "are you an innie or outie" field it would feel intrusive to have an automated system guess and label you off of "stereotypes".
- perl4ever 7y ago"someone's poorly trained ML system is making false assumptions about you and then labeling you with those assumptions" That IS the internet these days... While some ads could be targeted at anybody, I've recently seen ads that presume I'm - Jewish - Muslim - a woman - a millionaire - Black - have HIV - am schizophrenic - am diabetic - am bipolar - am a musician ...none of which are things I have reported about myself or verifiable facts. I am a lot more annoyed by people who say "stereotypes exist because they model people pretty well" than by the AI systems going haywire.
- randomcarbloke 7y agoHot take, and likely to provoke the ire of a woke internet. Genetic testing does a great job determining sex objectively. What if what we "feel" is wrong and our fabrication of identity has led us to a point where a machine can determine our "truest" gender based on our behaviours much better than an individual can self-ascribe one? Rendering it (to borrow from econ) a preference that is expressed and not always revealed, and nullifying any socially inferred stereotyped. At best (for those that care) this at least can give us a gender spectrum, and a means of objectively assessing someone, which has upsides and downsides of course.
- thechao 7y agoSex expression is strongly, but not perfectly, correlated with the existence or absence of the Y chromosome. Genetically, and biologically, sex determination can be complicated by, at least: nonfunctional Y, XXY, XYY, and other issues. In these cases, (about 1% of the general population), sex is not determined biologically according to the binary standard. This doesn’t even take into account social sex determination, or gender identification, which are psychological (and physiological!) in scope & involve a much more complicated biological system.