3 ms·
> But this is a global pandemic, that can only begin to be approached at the national level. Why pick national? Almost any aspect of the response can be implem
by roenxi 7y ago
> But this is a global pandemic, that can only begin to be approached at the national level.
Why pick national? Almost any aspect of the response can be implemented on any level of governance except maybe individual.
It isn't at all obvious that centralising on the federal level is sensible. Realistically; the optimal organisational unit for the response might be the catchments around each hospital and so somewhere around the local level.
- XorNot 7y agoBecause the federal government has control over fiscal and (indirectly) monetary policy. It can literally print money and borrow at rates which no single state can. It has an independent power to levy taxation against the citizens of those states. If the US states were literally independent countries, then they'd be able to do more. They're not, so the federal government should be doing a lot more then it is. Your taxes pay for federal government. An entirely different set of taxes pay for state government. _Why_ are you not demanding better service?
- roenxi 7y agoFor me particularly I'm not American. But Australia is in the same boat where our states are doing most the heavy lifting around the response. Everyone needs food; not printed paper. Who controls monetary and fiscal policy isn't so important. Having a big pile of cash doesn't really change anything - the crisis is in the real world and responses need to be in the real world too. Any level of government can manage that. And note the US Federal government creaking under a historically high level of debt, it has already given people far more than any taxpayer is contributing to the tune of something like @3k per if https://usdebtclock.org/ https://usdebtclock.org/ is accurate.
- senderista 7y agoAlso: most state and local governments are legally prohibited from deficit spending. That is absolutely crippling in a crisis like this one, given that tax revenues have dropped massively.
- torgian 7y agoNational level works, as proven by other countries (Hong Kong, Korea, and most notably, Taiwan.)
- Grue3 7y agoHong Kong is basically city-level. And Korea has implemented highly-localised measures.