3 ms·
>> That states are having to implement their own policies and plans of attack for this virus is a total travesty. Blame the constitution. In the US system of
by sandworm101 7y ago
>> That states are having to implement their own policies and plans of attack for this virus is a total travesty.
Blame the constitution. In the US system of government health is largely a state matter. Setting aside trump, the federal agencies just aren't setup to lead. They can issue statements and guidelines but lack any actual authority on the ground. State governors have the power, but even then they cannot boss corporations around (hospitals/insurance companies). They cannot even divert masks from one hospital to another, let alone demand that a patient be moved.
Now in other countries, the ones with government-provided healthcare, the national government has real authority. They can directly order policy changes. They can close individual hospitals and/or move patients. They can control the flow of equipment because they are the ones paying for that equipment. Canada just deployed soldiers into some care homes. It took less than 24 hours without any new legislation needed. A US state governor might be able to use the local national guard, but deploying the army within the US? Into a privately-run care home? That is a power trump doesn't have.
- stormbrew 7y agoIn Canada health is constitutionally devolved to the provinces. Explicitly, since our constitution was actually written in the last 40 years so was written with the awareness that health care is a major government concern. In so far as the federal government sets health policy, it does so through the carrot and stick of federal funding through equalization and other programs. I am reasonably certain that this is also an approach the US federal government has used in areas of devolved authority (particularly education). And looking at the specific situation you're talking about, it appears the Ontario government requested military assistance, and it was granted, not the other way around. The US federal government may not have explicit authority, but the idea that it is absolutely helpless to coordinate efforts among the states (aka interstate commerce) seems kind of blatantly absurd. Never mind that they seem to, in fact, have done quite a lot of diverting masks from where they were going to elsewhere already. Just you know, not in a helpful way.
- sandworm101 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Posse_Comitatus_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Posse_Comitatus_Act Domestic use of US soldiers, even with a state request, is not a simple matter. Trump wanted to deploy troops along boarder --> no go. Federal troops cannot be used to implement domestic policy. New York probably couldn't get troops if it asked. Canadian troops, if asked by any level of government, can deploy domestically and do so regularly. That's the advantage of a single sovereign authority (the crown). Everyone is literally on the same team. The US fed exercises its health power indirectly, through spending. It can demand that certain hospitals, those that receive federal funds, act in certain ways. But it cannot dictate treatment regimes. (This fed-state split on health has been heavily influenced/reinforced by the abortion debate.)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- clairity 7y agoor praise the constitution for its perceptive foresight and resilience against dystopian concentrations of power in a country with an unbelievably massive military and nuclear weapons stockpile? one where blind fear and panic can’t easily trigger a cascade into surveillance fascism for a pandemic trending to be ~3x worse than the flu?
- Lewton 7y agoThe IFR of the flu is 0.04% Non-biased random sampling anti-body studies reliably point to an IFR of around 0.5% 3x is just wishful thinking at this point
- rhizome 7y ago>Blame the constitution "The Constitution is not a suicide pact." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Constitution_is_not_a_suicide_pact https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Constitution_is_not_a_suic...