3 ms·
>> The view of advertising as fundamentally manipulative succumbed in the 1970s to the view that prevails today: that advertising does no more than convey usefu
by sandworm101 7y ago
>> The view of advertising as fundamentally manipulative succumbed in the 1970s to the view that prevails today: that advertising does no more than convey useful product information to consumers.
There is a line by Jude Law in 'The New Pope' about harvard being ossified and in decline. The above line is exactly that. They are working on a dated understanding of advertising. Advertising today includes a vast array of activities. The above statement only applies to old fashioned billboard-type ads, which are basically meaningless in the modern context. Those online reviews that are making "ads" less influential? Those ARE modern advertisement. They are purchased. That great review on YouTube, also purchased. Those white ear bud designed to be seen across a busy street? Part of an advertising campaign. That music crafted to be that little bit louder when played. Advertising.
>>Persuasive advertising should be subject to per se condemnation because advertising is, like price fixing, harmful to consumers in all cases, requiring no case-specific inquiry to determine net effects. Persuasive advertising makes consumers willing to pay more for the advertised product for reasons that, because of the principle of innovation primacy, must be assumed to involve no gain in consumer welfare.
Lol. That is the entire fashion industry. Fashion advertising is about adding perceived value to otherwise identical products. "Consumer welfare" is also an outdated concept. Anti-features are deliberately engineered to weaken products. The goal of a producer is not to increase 'consumer welfare'. It is to SELL product. If that means damaging the consumer with a product designed to fall apart, then so be it. The advertising is there to convince the consumer to re-purchase the nearly identical product by attaching perceived value. Modern advertising even convinces consumers to throw away perfectly functional products by creating false perceptions of inadequacy or danger. The above line in effect condemns modern consumerism. Good luck with that fight.
- decasteve 7y agoAdvertising is an environmental striptease for a world of abundance. Marshall McLuhan
- ardy42 7y ago> "Consumer welfare" is also an outdated concept. Anti-features are deliberately engineered to weaken products. The goal of a producer is not to increase 'consumer welfare'. It is to SELL product. If that means damaging the consumer with a product designed to fall apart, then so be it. The advertising is there to convince the consumer to re-purchase the nearly identical product by attaching perceived value. Modern advertising even convinces consumers to throw away perfectly functional products by creating false perceptions of inadequacy or danger. So basically, "modern" advertising is as beneficial as a viral infection, so it really ought to be criminalized or regulated into nonexistence.
- claqp 7y ago> ... old fashioned billboard-type ads, which are basically meaningless in the modern context. What? Billboard ads that I see from a train are literally the only ads that I remember after months (if they are well done). Billboard ads are ideal for subliminal propaganda, that's why they are used for state propaganda in Germany (the government is just, state television is awesome, the military is great).
- blaser-waffle 7y agoThis is a good explanation but one that can be ultimately summed up with "rent seeking behavior".