6 ms·
New Air Force One instruction manuals cost $84M
- gentleman11 7y agoHow many person years of salary is $84M for that manual from Boeing?
- flyinglizard 7y agoAssuming a cost of $200k per person, it's 420 man years, or 100 person team on a four year buildout like this. It does not sound unreasonable - or at least, about the right order of magnitude for such an undertaking.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- objektif 7y agoWhat is the undertaking here and what does it involve? Can you please explain?
- ars 7y agoCollecting information from every single team that worked on the plane, describing how the plane is built and how to repair and maintain it. The compiling all of that into a cohesive whole.
- flyinglizard 7y agoThe article mentions the figure of 100k pages. Well, 100,000 pages of high quality and specific technical writing is quite an undertaking. If we take the size of the team in my previous post as a given, that's 1000 per writer over four years, or about 250 pages per year, or about a page per working day on average. It's quite a bit.
- downerending 7y agoI hate stories like this. Yeah, excellent documentation for an immensely expensive one-off, bespoke, incredibly complex product costs a ton of money. Duh.
- rapind 7y agoTotally agree, and hey, if you or anyone you know is looking for documentation, PM me!
- badrabbit 7y agoNot $84M ,unless you're talking about a death star. And even then! I mean, back up a bit here, even the greediest tech company (oracle!) Has not thought of to charge for documentation. On what insane world would someone purchase a complex product like this without the docs? Why is it billed differently?
- Scramblejams 7y agoThis works out to $840/page. How many hours does it take to write the page, by people who are making how much? And don't forget, they get revisited and revised as the design changes. On the subject of why it's billed differently: well, first, transparency. What would you make you feel better? Getting a $4 billion lump quote for a giant project, or seeing that $4 billion itemized down so you can check the underlying data? Edit: Oops, sorry, data entry failure. Thanks for the corrections. Fixed.
- zoomablemind 7y agoMeanwhile (ok, over a year ago) Angela Merkel took a commercial flight to G20 in Argentina.... https://m.dw.com/en/man-finds-himself-sitting-next-to-germanys-angela-merkel-on-flight-to-g20/a-46533339 https://m.dw.com/en/man-finds-himself-sitting-next-to-german... Not by first choice, but still.. Respect!
- netsharc 7y agoI'm surprised they couldn't just call Lufthansa and get a plane with crew. But obviously Lufthansa doesn't just have that lying around, and needing to fly from Germany to Madrid first would also take a lot of time. Meanwhile, Trump flew to Switzerland to the World Economic Forum (wow, that was actually this year, while Wuhan was in crisis) with 2 "Air Force One"'s...
- NickNameNick 7y agoI'm sure Lufthansa have aircraft and crew sitting idle now. As for moving the president around - It's not just the vc-25a 'air force one's They would have had at least one cargo plane to deliver his car. And there was probably an E-4 Advance Airborne Command Post somewhere nearby too.
- gmueckl 7y agoI don't recall exactly, but from what I remember, the choice to fly commercial was made to get to the destination as fast as possible. The time for readying a new plane and flying to the pickup airport was considered too long.
- Scramblejams 7y agoI have no knowledge of this particular situation, but... Before I worked in aerospace as a structural engineer, I couldn't understand why airplanes are as expensive as they are. Once I'd worked in aerospace as a structural engineer, I couldn't understand why airplanes aren't more expensive than they are. I worked in stress analysis, where you'd analyze a part of an airplane to determine whether it fulfilled strength/fatigue life requirements. At this stage, the part's already been designed. So you take the part's material properties, geometry, surface preparation and coatings, machined features, and so on, and check it against anywhere from a few dozen to many thousands of load scenarios. You find the handful of critical load cases, and then you write up the analysis against those. The analysis is intended to be mostly self-contained, readable by any qualified engineer, and serve as a complete treatment of the part's structural sufficiency. It's not much of an exaggeration to say that every single structural component of an airplane is backed up by a stress analysis report running somewhere between 20 and 400 pages, written by one or more degreed engineers making what was, in the U.S. probably an average of $50-60/hr. Airliners are made up of many, many structural parts. The costs of proving the safety of those parts add up quickly. Now, if I had to guess, instruction manuals are probably a bit cheaper to produce. Tech writers probably aren't as well compensated as engineers. But a lot of engineers' time will be eaten up nonetheless. (I once spent a memorable few weeks (!) proving that a dowel pin on a part that hadn't been machined correctly would not, during installation, shear off, so that existing installation documentation could still be used. Yay. After that I was known as the office dowel pin SME.) Good maintenance documents sweat the details and require input from designers, stress analysts, manufacturing engineers, supply chain representatives, and others. And then as the design evolves -- the design always evolves on the way to delivering a product -- these documents must be tweaked, added to, subtracted from, sometimes entirely rewritten, and those changes must be checked by a variety of folks. So, $84 million for 100,000 pages might sound like a lot. But for what is in many ways a custom built aircraft, with divergences from the base aircraft that probably run into the millions, to me, it doesn't seem ridiculous.
- starpilot 7y agoPrinting manuals, $1 million. Research by thousands of highly trained engineers, compiled by experienced technical writers and illustrators: $83 million.
- lr 7y agoThis is a prime example of why America will eventually fall: We pay taxes for the benefit of the few, instead of the good of the many. Meanwhile, the current president blames immigrants and liberals for all of the country’s problems, and tens of millions of Americans believe him. Fear and greed before science and compassion. I just wish all of the followers of this BS would fully reject science and go to war with only gut instincts and a bolt action rifle. (I know i am going to be seriously downvoted for this comment, but so be it.)
- MattGaiser 7y agoAmerica does not need its aircraft well documented as that only benefits a few??? 84 million for 100,000 pages is $840 a page and that's for a page with diagrams and one written by and reviewed by engineers. Your imagination is leading you to think that they paid 84 million for a 10 page manual.
- dataflow 7y agoThat's $840/page, right? So like if you have just 1 person responsible per page, and they cost $100/hr, that's 8.4 hours of work per page? I feel like I had to spend longer on my high school essays...
- Turing_Machine 7y agoYeah, that doesn't seem unreasonable at all, especially since producing a page on (made-up example, obviously) maintaining and replacing the starboard arglebargle frammistat is gonna require that the technical writer spend a fair amount of time talking with the engineers who designed the frammistat, as well as the techs who will perform the actual maintenance/replacement work. You've gotta know how to tell when the frammistat can be safely reused and when it has to be replaced, how much torque can be applied to it without messing it up, what lubricants and sealants can and cannot be used, maximum temperature ranges, all kinds of stuff, because if you mess up the docs, the plane falls out of the sky and kills the President of the United States, plus potentially many others on the ground. That would leave a significant resume stain. Then, of course, the final document needs to be reviewed and signed off on by all those people, likely with multiple revisions. 8.4 hours per page seems like it'd be on the low side, if anything.
- pcurve 7y agoWell. It's $84 million to modify commercial 747-8 manual. Not re-write one from scratch. "This contract modification is to modify commercial manuals, update with VC-25B-specific information and deliver integrated manuals for the VC-25B system"
- exabrial 7y agoI oppose 99.88% of taxes because it literally is all spent in this exact manner (YMMV in other countries, I'm just speaking of the USA). The money is best kept your pocket. Both Blue and Red need to oppose new taxes and advocate for keeping money in people's pockets.
- redis_mlc 7y agoI'm not going to comment on the cost of the manuals, but on a couple other concerns: 1) Mechanics and pilots are responsible for knowing the aircraft systems. Who has time to read and memorize 100,000 pages? How do you recruit new pilots in an efficient manner? 2) The cost could have been largely avoided by using an off-the-shelf airplane, instead of a billion dollar frankenstein. Possibly with the additional electronics in pods that have a limited interface with the airplane electrical system. Source: commercially-rated airplane pilot.
- anonu 7y agoI say this often: but not all dollars are created equally. I think the size of the recent stimulus packages: $2tr and ongoing trillions on top of it are case-in-point. These numbers are so astronomically large it is hard to fathom what they mean for the US and what it means for future generations. My point about the headline number of $84 million... this is not a real number in that it reflects more than just the cost of manuals. It reflects the stimulus and backstop of strategically important private defense manufacturers like Boeing and others.
- pengaru 7y agoWell, Boeing does need money, overpaying for a bunch of crap already in the works is probably easier than a proper bailout. Though I imagine both will occur in the fullness of time.
- patio11 7y agoBespoke professional services work costs bespoke professional service work rates, film at 11, but one factor not already discussed here: A lot of contracting arrangements like this will ratably assign overhead to particular change orders or line items in ways which will cause the apparent cost of the line item to be higher than one might think necessary. This is, mostly, to avoid there being a "$250k for the manual; $5 billion for Miscellaneous Expenses" sort of bill. (The question of whether government contracting is optimal is a long and involved one outside the scope of this comment.)
- hedgehog 7y agoThere is reportedly a lot of specialized gear added so it's not surprising there's extensive documentation. What I find really surprising is the new aircraft cuts aerial refueling capability: https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/14199/the-next-air-force-one-aircraft-will-not-be-able-to-refuel-in-midair https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/14199/the-next-air-for...
- wglb 7y agoBack in the 90s, the documentation for a fighter jet, if printed out, would weigh more than the jet itself.